CreateDebate


Debate Info

32
15

Jay Rockefeller (D)


Jay Wolfe (R)

Debate Score:47
Arguments:24
Total Votes:47
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 
Jay Rockefeller (D)
(17)
 
 
Jay Wolfe (R)
(7)

Debate Creator

CreateDebate(732) pic



Who should I vote for in the 2008 West Virginia Senate Race?


Jay Rockefeller (D)

Side Score: 32
VS.


Jay Wolfe (R)

Side Score: 15
3 points

Jay Rockefeller has placed the economic progress of West Virginia's coal, steel, and chemical industries as one of the top priorities during his term in the Senate. He is dedicated to efforts that will attract new investors to West Virginia while, at the same time, preserving and expanding existing businesses and companies in the state.

He was apart of the founding and organization of the Discover the Real West Virginia Foundation (DRWV), a non-profit devoted to introducing innovative ideas and projects that will bring new jobs to the West Virginia economy. He was also a supportive voice behind the passing of the the Fair Minimum Wage Act of 2007, which saw the minimum wage increase from $5.15 to $7.25.

Rockefeller believes that the economic playing field in West Virginia and the nation needs to be fair and families and small businesses have access to the same opportunities and investments as larger, richer enterprises. His support of middle-class tax cuts is a crucial component of his plan to bring a much-needed diversity to the market.

Supporting Evidence: Rockefeller's Economy (rockefeller.senate.gov)
Side: Rockefeller's Economy
2 points

As co-chairman of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, Jay Rockefeller did more than any other person in the U.S. Senate in 2004 and 2005 to drive the neo-conservative liars out of the Pentagon. When the media, the GOP majority, and the White House were lined up against him, Sen. Rockefeller persisted in demanding answers as to WHO produced the faulty intelligence that duped Congress and the public into supporting the Iraq war; how did they do it; and how far up the chain of command did it go. While it was never admitted, the ousting of Donald Rumsfeld, Paul Wolfowitz and Doug Feith, centers of the ``neo-conservative cabal,'' was greatly aided by Sen. Rockefeller. It is a tragedy that Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi took the impeachment of Dick Cheney "off the table." With greater support from the Democratic leadership, Sen. Rockefeller would have been likely to unearth the evidence that secured impeachment.

Side: Jay Rockefeller
2 points

Jay Rockefeller (D) has expressed his confidence that Obama will carry the state of West Virginia despite the bitter partisan split in the state between Clinton supporters and Obama supporters in the Democratic Primary.

Rockefeller supports the more diplomatic angle to foreign policy aligned with the Obama/Biden ticket rather than the McCain approach, which he criticizes as being viewed "through Cold War glasses."

He feels he speaks for the voters of West Virginia when he states, in regards to the United States' handing of the war on terror and nuclear threats, ""We can not afford even one more day of ideological decision making, politicizing intelligence, bungling diplomacy, and obsolete thinking."

As a chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, Rockefeller has a particular stake in international relations as his campaign progresses towards the general election against his Republican rival, Jay Wolfe.

Supporting Evidence: Obama Support (www.wvgazette.com)
Side: Obama Support
BigIron(477) Disputed
2 points

At a Labor Day rally in Racine, WV, Jay Rockefeller had these statements to make regarding Sen. John McCain:

“You have to understand John McCain and how bad he would be for West Virginia. He’s a terrible person to have as president.”

“He’s a bully. He treats people terribly.

Granted, a Democratic Senate hopeful is going to attack McCain de facto but I would hope that a legitimate candidate could do a better job of attacking the Republican Presidential hopeful with more tact and evidence than vague, petty jabs like "terrible person" or "bully".

It serves to note, however, that Rockefeller did attach the GOP candidate's record on veteran benefits (a real kicker topic for McCain), children's health insurance, and clean coal technology (an issue that has substantial resonance with West Virginian voters.)

Supporting Evidence: Poor attacks (www.williamsondailynews.com)
Side: Poor attacks
2 points

Jay Wolfe is for making the Bush tax cuts permanent and for a cutting taxes and spending at "every opportunity"; thinks that market forces should be allowed to drive down healthcare and that "This can be accomplished with the purchase of high deductible health insurance and obtaining a Health Savings Account"; encourages more uses of coal--including liquidizing, drilling in ANWR, drilling on the coasts, drilling on federal land, and the building of new oil refineries; is against any sort of gay marriage or civil union and is staunchly pro-life; and finally in regards to the war in Iraq, his response is, "we win and they loose". For anyone who is thinks individuals have a right to choose who they love and what to do with their bodies, who cares about our environment, who wants more affordable healthcare that benefits all Americans and who wants a responsible end to the war in Iraq, Jay Wolf would be a disaster. Jay Rockefeller is the complete opposite and has a strong voting record to prove it.

Supporting Evidence: Rockefeller on the Issues (www.ontheissues.org)
Side: Jay Rockefeller
2 points

Yesterday Sen. Jay Rockefeller released a statement on the recent federal decision announced by U.S. Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson that the mortgage giants Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae will be placed "under conservatorship", which is similar to bankruptcy but oriented towards restructuring the organizations financially to help assist the crisis currently plaguing American homeowners.

He states, ""Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have a direct impact on the economic stability of West Virginia and we need them to remain strong. In the last decade, these two mortgage giants have helped tens of thousands of West Virginia families buy a home and hundreds more avoid foreclosure. Homeownership in our state is a lot higher than the national average thanks, in part, to the public mission of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. That's a good thing and leads to strong communities and a better quality of life for hard-working families. I will fight to maintain that."

The statement may frustrate more fiscally conservative voters in the state of West Virginia but, to a Democratic and disillusioned Independent block, Rockefeller's position exhibits a dedication to the hard-pressed citizens of West Virginia who may be facing foreclosures.

Supporting Evidence: Helping Homeowners (www.huntingtonnews.net)
Side: Helping Homeowners
2 points

This week, Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D) joined Jeff and Amy Dunford at the Angel in Adoption gala in Washington D.C. to congratulate the couple on behalf of their sharing their home to six adopted children.

"The Dunfords just amaze me," the Senator said, "They are such remarkable people who are an example to us all. They have opened their homes and their hearts and shown nothing but love and determination within their family and community, and now six children have a permanent and loving home.”

Adoption is one of Kennedy's more passionate talking points as the Senator is an active member in the Congressional Coalition on Adoption. He took the opportunity at the gala to praise the efficiency of the Adoption and Safe Family Act of 1997 to increase the number of adoptions across the nation and announced his current work in implementing a bipartisan expansion of adoption incentive programs.

Supporting Evidence: Kennedy for Adoption (www.register-herald.com)
Side: Kennedy for Adoption
2 points

Rockefeller Supports Clean Coal

Sen. Jay Rockefeller attended a coal-to-liquids technology conference Aug. 15, 2007. His campaign website states that he supports the new, controversial technology in the name of energy independence. America does have a bountiful supply of coal, but critics have a host of critiques. First, coal is an unsustainable, nonrenewable resource. Second, coal-to-fuel technology is tremendously inefficient. Third, supporting this technology would exacerbate mountain top removal. This process is highly controversial, as the explosives and process used to excavate the coal causes severe pollution. The water cleanliness and health concerns are significant issues.

Youtube Video
Side: Energy
2 points

Rockefeller Wants to Overhaul the FCC

In the video below, Sen. Rockefeller criticizes the FCC. The FCC has come under scrutiny over the past few years while President Bush has been in office. Critics note that the FCC has become a more partisan, ineffective agency.

Rockefeller states, “I’m becoming increasing concerned that the FCC appears to be more concerned about making sure that the policies they advocate serves the needs of the companies that they regulate and their bottom lines, rather than the public interest. We cannot allow that to happen.”

Rockefeller want to develop a FCC reauthorization bill that would address

(1) the structure of the agency

(2) its mission

(3) the terms of commissioners

(4) how to make the agency a better regulator that advocates for consumers

Youtube Video
Side: FCC
2 points

Rockefeller Voted for FISA

Rockefeller voted for the controversial FISA bill that retroactively grants telecommunication industry amnesty. The bill allows the government and telecom companies to screen calls directed abroad. Critics argue that this is an invasion of civil liberties and freedom.

In his closing remarks he states, “I really hope that this will pass. I think it’s landmark legislation… There may be disagreements on immunity, but there can be no disagreement on the national security of the United States.”

Major AT&T;offices are in Wheeling, West Virginia.

Youtube Video
Side: FISA
2 points

Rockefeller Claims to Have Nurtured Large Corporations and Industry in West Virginia

Rockefeller takes credit for netting major corporations into West Virginia. Toyota, AT&T;, and Amazon are a few companies that the senator claims to have attracted to the state. His support of the FISA amendment notably curries favor with the telecommunications industry within the state. Appealing to the working class vote, Rockefeller also claims to have made lives easier by working with steel mills and coal producers and refiners across the state. Despite being the son of the founder of Standard Oil, Rockefeller's support of these industries should get the working family vote. Rockefeller seems to have covered all of his economic bases high and low.

Supporting Evidence: On the Issues (www.jay08.com)
Side: Jay Rockefeller
2 points

Rockefeller Supports Health Care for Everyone

The senator supports seniors. He helped lower prescription drug costs by allowing Canadian drugs into the country and by allowing Medicare to negotiate prices down from pharmaceutical companies. Rockefeller supports those living in rural areas. He introduced a $8.4 million grant to provide “telemedicine services” to these areas. The incumbent supports workers. If workers lose their jobs due to outsourcing, the will receive a Trade Adjustment Assistance tax credit to cover health care costs. The Clean Coal Act further supports industrial workers, contends Rockefeller. The bill would help the coal industry in West Virginia by stimulating growth. He supports children. Rockefeller co-authored the Children’s Health Insurance Program.

Supporting Evidence: On the Issues (www.jay08.com)
Side: Health care
2 points

Rockefeller Supports Working Families With Technology and Tax Credits

Rockefeller created the E-Rate program, which provisions grants for computer and internet equipment to schools and libraries in rural areas. 90% of schools and public libraries are wired due to the program.

Many believe that everyone in America should exercise personal responsibility. Rockefeller’s support of the Earned Income Tax Credit is a way to get the poor off of welfare and transition them into work. He claims that the tax credit has lifted 4 million Americans out of poverty. The credit allows to poor to pay for food, rent, and education. As the measure is essentially a tax break, Republicans and Democrats alike should support it.

Supporting Evidence: On the Issues (www.jay08.com)
Side: Jay Rockefeller
2 points

Rockefeller Supports Veterans’ Health

The senator supports the Keeping Our Promise to America’s Veterans Act, which guarantees veterans with health care access. Rockefeller also supported increasing funding for treating veterans with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and those with traumatic brain injuries. Through the Standing with Our Troops Act, he seeks to create a bill of rights for National Guard and Reserve members that would limit their deployment and give similar benefits to those who serve in the Army.

Supporting Evidence: On the Issues (www.jay08.com)
Side: veterans
2 points

Rockefeller Says Bush Mislead Americans into War

As the Chairman of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, Sen. Rockefeller focused on the bad intelligence that led to the Iraq war. In the Phase II report on prewar intelligence, Rockefeller states that the President misled the American people into war with the apocryphal intelligence. Worse, Rockefeller claims “the Bush Administration was fixated on Iraq, and used the 9/11 attacks by al Qaeda as justification for overthrowing Saddam Hussein. To accomplish this, top Administration officials made repeated statements that falsely linked Iraq and al Qaeda as a single threat and insinuated that Iraq played a role in 9/11. Sadly, the Bush Administration led the nation into war under false pretenses.”

Supporting Evidence: U.S. Senate Select Committe on Intelligence (intelligence.senate.gov)
Side: Jay Rockefeller
1 point

Wolfe's conservative views on federal spending include dismembering the entire Department of Education and dispersing it's power back to state governments in order to save the government $68 billion a year.

Although one could see how making such a drastic cut in federal programming would present a surplus of funds for Congress to dedicate to other projects, e.g. green energy and children's health care, Wolfe's interest in promoting either of those options seems limited. He supports Bush's permanent tax cuts which many argue would do nothing to fix problems within the current health care and educational systems, but rather just inspire Americans to shop. Wolfe also says that the government shouldn't help with health care, and that rather people, with the help of a Health Insurance Savings Account, should be "empowered with the ownership of their health. The way to do this is to encourage people to purchase health insurance that pays catastrophic health expenses only and puts the first dollar responsibilities in the hands of people who are the end users of the product." Essentially, Wolfe says that the reason why people suffer under medical costs is because they cannot choose which insurance plan is right for them.

So, by eliminating federal funding and programming for public education and telling people that they have high medical bills because they don't know the difference between insurance plans, Wolfe thinks that the federal budget can be stabilized. But does that really solve problems, or just cut program funding to aid middle class Americans who need it most?

Supporting Evidence: Wolfe's strangely conservative answer to balancing the budget (www.jaywolfe2008.com)
Side: Jay Wolfe
1 point

Rockefeller Votes for Bailout

Arguing that passage of the bailout legislation would protect Americans from further economic damage, Rockefeller said yes to the bill. He has called the current crisis "the most serious financial crisis of our lifetime." After his vote he stated,

“Nothing matters more to me than helping West Virginia families hold on to their life savings, their jobs, their homes, their retirement, and their hopes for the future.

“I joined with my colleagues to pass a rescue plan that aims to shore up the economy and prevent West Virginians from becoming the next victims of the Wall Street fallout.

Supporting Evidence: Yes to Bailout (rockefeller.senate.gov)
Side: Jay Rockefeller
1 point

Sen. Jay Rockefeller released a statement this past Tuesday to back his support of the bailout package signed by President Bush last week hoping to woo West Virginia voters to keep his seat in the Senate in November.

Rockefeller's statement focuses on the benefits to the coal mining industry (which marks a major economic and voting contingent in West Virginia). Rockefeller promises the bailout plan "will help protect our coal miners by encouraging increased investment in mine rescue teams and state-of-the-art safety technology, while also keeping the Black Lung Trust Fund solvent."

Rockefeller's press secretary, Steven Broderick, elaborated on the statement noting that the tax incentives included in the more than $700 billion bailout include "billions of dollars in investments in clean coal technology and clean coal uses."

He continues: "Senator Rockefeller has fought hard to expand the use of clean West Virginia coal and help keep our coal miners safe. This legislation was the absolute right vehicle to keep investments in coal headed in the right direction."

An article in the Wall Street Journal details the coal mining initiatives included in the bailout:

- an expansion and extension of tax credits for clean coal technological advancement.

- introduce and establish "a carbon capture tax credit of $20 per ton for carbon dioxide stored in geologic formations and $10 per ton for carbon dioxide use to enhance oil well production."

- an extension of the alternative fuels credit.

- offer a 50 cent a gallon tax credit to jet fuel made from liquefied coal.

- maintain $10,000 tax credit for train mine rescue teams.

- extending the deductions targeted at mine safety equipment.

- improving the Black Lung Disability Trust Fund.

Supporting Evidence: Bailing Out Coal Miners (www.dailymail.com)
Side: Bailing out Coal Miners
4 points

Rockefeller should be voted out of office for endorsing Obama and not seeing past the superficiality of his 2002 speech. Jay Wolfe may be going along with Bush's agenda for right now, but it is not too late for voters to warn him to stop supporting the war on terror. Another disadvantage for Rockefeller is that he endorsed Obama against the will of the people as shown in his state's Democratic presidential primary back in May.

Side:
Jay Wolfe (R)
2 points

This will be the second time that Jay Rockefeller and Jay Wolfe have sparred off in the state of West Virginia for a seat in the Senate.

In 2002, Wolfe came within 13% of the votes needed to defeat Rockefeller despite being outspent by a margin of 20 to 1 by the Democratic candidate.

Again, with this election campaign we see the opposing arguments relating the hike in gas prices between the Republican, who favors offshore drilling, and the Democrat, who opposes.

Wolfe holds Rockefeller's legislation against lifting the ban on offshore drilling as evidence to the extent to which the Democratic Senator has moved to the left and forgotten about the economic frustrations and concerns of the people of West Virginia. Wolfe supports the case for tapping into America's oil supply as a necessary means to hasten our independence on foreign oil markets. Lifting the ban, he argues, will provide a significant boost to the national economy and allow for the financial elbow room for investing in alternative and renewable energy initiatives.

https://www.jaywolfe2008.com/https://www.jaywolfe2008.com/jayvsjay/

Side:
Jay Wolfe (R)
2 points

Wolfe Supports Radical Change on Education

“I support the abolishment of the unconstitutional Department of Education and return its functions to the states,” states the Republican candidate. In keeping with his party’s ideology, Wolfe wants to decentralize education to states and local control. This means that federal programs like President Bush’s No Child Left Behind program would be thrown out the window. However, this isn’t to say that Wolfe devalues some of the programs core principles. He wants to give parents choices in their childrens’ schooling. Parents would be allowed to send their children to any private, public, or home schooling program they want. It appears that Wolfe advocates a competitive, performance-based pay program in order to give teachers incentives to improve.

Supporting Evidence: On the Issues (www.jaywolfe2008.com)
Side: Education
2 points

Wolfe Supports an Environmentally Unsound Energy Policy

The Republican candidate advocates an energy policy that would supposedly make the nation more secure and reduce fuel prices. Wolfe supports drilling in ANWR, offshore, and on federal land. He wants to build new oil refineries and nuclear facilities. Further, the candidate advocates, as does his opponent Sen. Rockefeller, coal-to-fuel technology.

His promises and plans, however, may prove difficult to justify. More drilling would not have any effect on prices until 8-10 years due to the time it takes to explore, build, and drill. Continuing to use petroleum would still indirectly fund authoritarian petro-nations due to increased demand from developing countries. Building new nuclear plants would be immensely expensive and a national security concern. Coal-to-fuel technology at this stage is highly inefficient and could lead to worsen domestic pollution.

Supporting Evidence: On the Issues (www.jaywolfe2008.com)
Side: Environment
2 points

Wolfe Advocates a Radical Departure on Taxes

Wolfe proposes a tax scheme that strives towards a quasi-anarchic state. He wants to eliminate all taxes and replace them all with a consumption tax, euphemistically called the Fair Tax. What does this mean?

No income tax

No corporate tax

No estate tax

No self-employment tax

No capital gains tax

No pay roll tax

No alternative minimum tax

No pay roll withholding tax

Critics argue that the consumption tax favors the rich over the poor since a flat tax rate would not affect the wealth of a high income earner as much as a low or middle income earner. It remains to be seen whether the tax would cause a retrenchment in the size of government or it the tax would deter consumption and endanger economic growth.

Supporting Evidence: On the Issues (www.jaywolfe2008.com)
Side: Economy
1 point

Senator Rockefeller has voted for the revised Wall Street bailout bill and thereby given in to the Bush administration's whims. This is not surprising when one looks at higher taxes and more spending as being among the core principles that liberal Democrats embrace. Wolfe's stances sound good for voters who want to get this under control, but it's their responsibility to see that he follows through on these.

Side:
Jay Wolfe (R)