CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
2

Steven Kagen (D)


John Gard (R)

Debate Score:6
Arguments:5
Total Votes:6
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 
Steven Kagen (D)
(3)
 
 
John Gard (R)
(2)

Debate Creator

CreateDebate(732) pic



Who should I vote for in the 2008 Wisconsin 8th District House of Representatives Race?


Steven Kagen (D)

Side Score: 4
VS.


John Gard (R)

Side Score: 2
2 points

Kagen has out raised his opponent by almost 3 to 2 on the strength of a lot of PAC money pouring into his coffers. Cash on hand is slightly closer as Gard has spent more of his nest egg.

Supporting Evidence: fund raising (www.opensecrets.org)
Side: Steven Kagen
1 point

Kagen Votes Against Bailout

A Democrat voting against his leaders, Kagen defends his "No" vote because of his support of families. After the vote, he stated, “I was elected to represent the best interests of families in Northeast Wisconsin - not Wall Street. We have seen so many people lose their jobs and struggle just to keep their heads above water. I am on their side and this bill does not help them.”

With many pundits and experts claiming the bailout neccessary to protect those same families and jobs, voters may find that his given reasons for opposition to the bailout insufficient. It is unclear what parts of the bill he opposed and what he would suggest to stem the crisis.

Supporting Evidence: No Bailout (kagen.house.gov)
Side: Bailout
1 point

Focused on helping America become energy independent, Kagen says that first the exact issue must be pinpointed before absolute progress can be made. He has four goals for Congress to reach with regard to renewable energy:

(1) emit less carbon dioxide, pollutants and greenhouse gases

(2) invest heavily in renewable energy

(3) enable existing utilities to become sources of renewable energy

(4) begin to decrease the effects of human activities on our environment.

As a green candidate, Kagen has the environmental and fiscal future of American in mind. He understands that new plans, such as geothermal and solar energies, which are expected to yield high results require adequate funding and research.

Supporting Evidence: Kagen for a renewable future (kagen.house.gov)
Side: Steven Kagen
1 point

Congressman Kagen's stay in office could be a rather brief one if he keeps up his hesitance to accept invitations to town hall debates. This will not help Kagen win this rematch against Gard after how close the last election was, and the seat is considered vulnerable. Gard can and should embrace his underdog status when it comes to fundraising.

Side:
John Gard (R)
1 point

Finally! A Republican Congressman who has never voted to raise the income taxes and has actually voted to cut many of the taxes and erase the marriage penalties face to many couples.

“John Gard voted to cut income taxes by $1.1 billion dollars. He voted to cut property taxes by $1.6 billion. He voted for the Property Tax Freeze. He voted to eliminate the Marriage Penalty.” It is very important that there are Republicans who still believe in fewer taxes because as Henry Hazlitt eloquently stated in his book Economics in One Lesson, “Taxes discourage production.”

Unfortunately on Mr. Gard’s website, he has not gone into detail on any other issues except the taxes. It is quite hard to discuss a man like Mr. Gard without knowing his stances on other positions.

Side: John Gard