CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:19
Arguments:15
Total Votes:21
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Why do people care so much about the Haitians when there are homeless Americans? (15)

Debate Creator

TERMINATOR(6781) pic



Why do people care so much about the Haitians when there are homeless Americans?

Add New Argument
2 points

Because the homeless haven't been hit by a huge earthquake and their country is not in a state of anarchy.

Side: Haitians need it more
TERMINATOR(6781) Disputed
2 points

Before we can help others, oughtn't we help ourselves? The homeless Americans are in a freezing country, can't they get some help?

Side: Haitians need it more

Agreed. We are have this altruistic and paternalistic attitude towards the rest of the world, yet we often are dismissive towards our fellow Americans.

Side: Haitians need it more
wolfbite(432) Disputed
0 points

To an extent, but seeing as people in America suffering in the cold is nowhere near as dire as people in Haiti stuck under collapsed buildings they take priority.

Though I do have to wonder how a country that has no money can possibly donate to another country.

Side: Haitians need it more
2 points

The issue is not whether or not our county could benifit from this, it is instead an issue of humanity. There is rampant chaos and death in massive numbers in Haiti. The economy can wait, politics can wait, God can wait.

Side: Haitians need it more
1 point

Because the North American hobo is a lazy specimen. All of them. =)

Side: Haitians need it more

I agree that they are lazy (and often high or drunkards), they are still close to home. People the world over are suffering tremendously (child sex slaves in Eastern Europe, prostitutes in Thailand, just to name a few). American's complain about 1 in 16,000,000 odds of a terrorist bombing, the Israelis live under the threat of suicide bombers daily. In an effot for a religious debate, Haitians, some say, made a pact with the devil 200 years ago. I, myself, have never heard corroborating evidence and thus I do not believe that, but I should like to see some of that on here. What I am saying is this: Why is everything about Haiti these last 2 weeks. CNN still is talking about it - hasn't anything else happened the world over?

Side: Haitians need it more
1 point

Because THOUSANDS of Haitians may die whereas in the worst scenario a dozen Americans may die.

I think the answer is obvious. Extremely obvious. Why would you ask such a question?

Side: Haitians need it more
TERMINATOR(6781) Disputed
1 point

How about this: why help the Haitians when the Americans could be helping Africans? Average age in Swaziland is 31.99. People die every day at very low ages. The average infant mortality rate in Niger is 11.7%. Literacy rate in Ethiopia is 42.7%. America is just as capable of sending aid to Niger where they could save infants; Swaziland, where they could help the starving; or Ethiopia, where they could teach them basic educational skills. You can count on their country never getting on it's feet if the people never learn to read and write.

What I'm saying is this: millions and millions of people are living in conditions little better than those in port-au-prince - and they have been living in it for decades. Did anybody give them a second thought? But now a Western country gets affected and everybody stops where they are and rushes to help. In a few years, Americans will be saying 'Hey, you remember that bad ol' 'quake somewhere in the Caribbean?' and the response 'Yeah, I think it was Grenada or some other place like that.' Meanwhile, in Africa, thousands of people will be dying everyday.

Side: Haitians need it more
1 point

most of the americans that are homeless can help it in some way. they can get an actual job. most are just too lazy. the people in haiti could not control what happened to them.

Side: Haitians need it more