CreateDebate


Debate Info

14
15
Because I don't trust it
Debate Score:29
Arguments:33
Total Votes:29
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Because (11)
 
 I don't trust it (13)

Debate Creator

brontoraptor(28599) pic



Why do you trust your brain?

If we are simply the result of random chemical reactions, why do you trust any of your thoughts? Would you trust a car that hadn't been intelligently designed?

  

Because

Side Score: 14
VS.

I don't trust it

Side Score: 15
2 points

I trust my brain because it was intelligently designed. It is the masterpiece of God's handiwork.

Side: Because
Grenache(6053) Clarified
1 point

All wrinkled up and looking like a scrotum?

He was omnipotent, right? He could have made any design work for the brain. Yet that's what he came up with?

He also designed our curved spine which gives so many people back aches all their lives, and unnecessary wisdom teeth which most people have to have surgically removed.

These are masterpieces?

Side: Because
1 point

Come now Grenache. You trust what it tells you but hate its design. You're committing cognitive dissonance.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitivedissonance

Why isn't this what a designer would come up with? What would you have come up with and why, and why would it be better?

Back aches, pain, and disabilities humble human beings and take them off of their high horses or cause them to lash out. It's a good way to weed out who is who.

Side: I don't trust it
outlaw60(15368) Disputed
1 point

Now look Moderate i know you dislike references to God but why is it you support a Religion of Peace that holds none of the values of Progressives ? To start Female Genital Mutilation and the killing of Gays !

Side: I don't trust it
BellaSmella(171) Clarified
1 point

Humans pass gas as they are designed to do, while Atheists mock the model and design. So what do Atheist inventors do? Create machines that pass gas.

Side: Because
1 point

Because if I don't trust my own brain then I have to trust yours instead.

No way man.

Side: Because
BellaSmella(171) Disputed
1 point

dupe*

Side: I don't trust it
1 point

Come now Grenache. This brain allowed me to make enough money to never work again.

Side: I don't trust it
1 point

Oh. So does that mean if I trust your brain I'll never have to work again either?

Nifty. Take it away then.

Side: I don't trust it
1 point

Distrust would be an effect taking place within the brain. Neither trust nor distrust will take place without it.

Do you denounce communication?

Side: I don't trust it
1 point

Who says it is good communication or communication at all? What if you are simply an alzheimer's patient in a nursing home in another dimension where the physical is imaginary?

Side: Because
Amarel(5669) Disputed
1 point

My question was rhetorical. To denounce is to communicate, just as to mistrust is to use your brain.

Side: I don't trust it