CreateDebate


Debate Info

0
2
Order supports a god Order does not support a god
Debate Score:2
Arguments:2
Total Votes:2
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Order does not support a god (2)

Debate Creator

EvenBetter(44) pic



Would order in the Universe support the notion of a god?

Right now, it is raining methane on Titan. The planet Uranus, apparently trying to live up to its name, is orbiting the sun sideways, while Venus spins backwards. There are stars exploding, black holes gorging, galaxies colliding.

And here we sit, on a planet pock-marked by collisions, rocked by earthquakes, shaken by storms. A planet doomed to be fried in radiation as its magnetic fields collapse, until finally the sun grows into a red giant and leaves nothing of the Earth but dust.

Here we sit, glasses on our noses, inhalers in our pockets, braces on our teeth, waiting to die as our heart muscle expires, our cells decide to grow forever, or a blood vessel just pops, and sometimes in unnatural ways, too.

Here we sit, and some of us say, behold, look at the order of it all.

But the argument is as follows; does the order observed in lifeforms and the planet act as supporting evidence for a deity.

Order supports a god

Side Score: 0
VS.

Order does not support a god

Side Score: 2
No arguments found. Add one!

A deity simply does not follow from order.

I could dissect a common argument I'm expecting on the other side, but I'll wait for it.

Side: Order does not support a god
1 point

It would support the notion of God created it all no more than it would support the notion that leprechauns created it all.

Side: Order does not support a god