Debate Info

install flash for graphs
Of course I would! Are you kidding?
Debate Score:112
Arguments:67
Total Votes:120
Show More Stats

Argument Tags

side graph
 
 Of course I would! (72)
 
 Nihilism (28)
 
 Are you kidding? (7)

Debate Creator

johnbonham32(1699) pic



Would you die to save the human race?


Of course I would!

Side Score: 75
VS.

Are you kidding?

Side Score: 37

Only if I knew I would be successful and that people would know that it was me and then remember me for ever and ever and ever and build statues of me and give me my own holiday and force students to study my arguments on CD. That would be so awesome ;)

369 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
- frenchieak(1112) Supported
Vote Up Vote Down
4 points

They would be soooo confused. "How can a gay illegal immigrant terrorist woman abort a baby?!?" ;)

Yeah, I would quickly sacrifice myself for the Human race. Even if I don't succeed, people will be like, "Wow. That guy was awesome. So we should all think of him as we go out, too."

369 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
- joecavalry(10429) Supported
Vote Up Vote Down
4 points

I know, isn't that all screwed up? I guess I have learned to accept and embrace the chaos ;)

369 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
- johnbonham32(1699) Supported
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

I know. If I was a student studying your arguments, I think most of what I would learn about would be strange sex and Barack Obama. Then they would study this argument, and they would see mine and Frenchie's replies, and they would go 'Hey! What the hell? Why are we studying this! I thought this was real! I thought this was intelligence! I thought this was everything that matters! This is a load of shit!'

:P I think the world would be a very different place.

254 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
- joecavalry(10429) Supported
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

OMG, LOL you're responding to something I typed 115 days ago?!?!?! I guess my stuff is timeless ;)

253 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
Vote Up Vote Down
5 points

Considering how my family and my loved ones are part of the human race, yes. How could I be selfish enough to let them all die just because I don't want to?

367 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
Vote Up Vote Down
4 points

i would i would be a hero and people have to studdy me =) and make monuments of me oh mystical duncer unleash your butkicking wrath on joe

(p.s i thinks some one is making multiple accounts because even a good argument i get a -5 or so)

368 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
Vote Up Vote Down
3 points

Why wouldn't I? It wouldn't matter to me if I got great recognition just as long as what I did really did save the Human race. If what I did was just an attempt to save the human race and might not work I dont think so. Have some crazy people try it out first.

368 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
Vote Up Vote Down
3 points

Yes. As a general principle, the maximum amount of life should be preserved.

368 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
Vote Up Vote Down
2 points

If the human race is about to die that means I'm about to die. So if my choices are die with the rest of humanity or die and become the hero of the human race and be remembered by the rest of the human race for thousands of years then I would sacrifice myself for the human race.

353 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

Yeah i would. i mean saving ppl'z lives, thats just selflessness rite there

thats kool to find in ppl, admit it, u like superhero movieess!

367 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

of course i would y would i not.

if i did not die to save it, well then i will die any way lol

361 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

If I knew that the human race was going to have future success, than I would. But if I knew that they were going to die out within the next century, why should I?

357 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

Simply Yes. Think about it if you don't die then you and the whole world die. On the other hand if you do you save millions and then some.

332 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
Vote Up Vote Down
3 points

Nihilism.

Why would i die for something that's just a point in the Universe. Not logical at all.

Humans are merely organic machines, nothing more. And until you can prove otherwise (which you can't), it's pointless to die saving the human race. as pointless as dying to save a race of ants.

369 days ago | Tagged As: Nihilism
Vote Up Vote Down
5 points

Thank-you Mr. Spock! LOL!!! Even though we are but a speck of dust in the grand scheme of the universe and may only be "organic machines" I think that if the question were put to me, in all seriousness and with proof, I may just allow that to occur. I don't think saving the human race is pointless at all and especially not if they can be taught to continue to preserve themselves and the earth upon which they live. An Epiphany of this kind may very well be worth the cost of one life.

369 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
- ThePyg(3443) Disputed
Vote Up Vote Down
5 points

but what point is there, a provable point, in saving humans in order to "continue preserving" what ever. If we die we break down into other living cells. THAT'S IT. nothing "bad" results from all of us dying or living because "bad" doesn't even exist.

why doesn't bad exist? cause there's no way of proving that a certain action can be bad or good. so what's the point?

369 days ago | Tagged As: Nihilism
- jessald(1570) Disputed
Vote Up Vote Down
2 points

Well by the same logic, why not die? If humans are merely organic machines, then you are merely an organic machine, so your death would not matter.

368 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
- ThePyg(3443) Disputed
Vote Up Vote Down
4 points

my death may not matter, but i can still enjoy the pleasures of life until i die. the fact is, I know that what i feel is either a positive or negative feeling. since there is no meaning in the Universe and since all we are are matter, i could either use the benefit of emotions and feelings to give my self euphoria or i could kill myself right away for no reason at all.

I like pleasures, so i'll stick with that.

368 days ago | Tagged As: Nihilism
- johnbonham32(1699) Supported
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

It's true. Yet here we are speaking of organic machines and what not, sounding a lot like the Borg :P Chris (Kukla) already referenced Mr. Spock. CD is turning into Dork mania! Hum hum hum!

254 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
Vote Up Vote Down
2 points

Although I agree that we are merely organic machines, and that we are infinitesimally small in the grand scheme of things, I think human beings are worth saving.

So far as we know humans are the only species that can think rationally and scientifically on earth. In addition, as far as we know earth is the only place with life. Therefore we are the only beings that understand the universe, and because we are made from parts of the universe, we are a way for the universe to understand itself. If the universe was an organism we'd be the brain. Do you think that is not worth preserving?

368 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
- ThePyg(3443) Disputed
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

why would it be worth saving though? in what way does anything "benefit" from human existing continuing. why is rationalizing and knowledge a "good" thing if good doesn't even exist?

368 days ago | Tagged As: Nihilism
- Cerin(180) Disputed
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

Animals with the instinct to sacrifice themselves for other animals would stand a greater chance of survival (as a species) against other animals without that instinct.

If there's no point to life, then you'd have to also agree there's no point not to life.

359 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
- ThePyg(3443) Disputed
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

what i'm saying is that there's no point to anything. so live or die, it doesn't matter.

359 days ago | Tagged As: Nihilism
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

I'm not gonna say that i would die to save the human race and the people saying yes are lying because its human to put yourself first, thats America for you! the people saying yes are merely saying it because it makes them look good. i doubt if faced with the challenge anyone would and thats normal, personally id probably be too scared. Yes there are a few people i would die (best friends, parents, etc). People stop worrying about your "reputation" and be truthful for once.

360 days ago | Tagged As: Are you kidding?
- MKIced(1933) Disputed
Vote Up Vote Down
2 points

Well I was being truthful. I'd rather let my loved ones live their lives and be happy with each other than let them all die and feel the guilt and loneliness every single day.

353 days ago | Tagged As: Of course I would!
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

"Save" is used somewhat ambiguously. Saved from what? Utter destruction? Inevitable pain? Minor annoyance? A bad pedicure?

On one hand, if the future existence of mankind depends upon the action of a single person, are the rest worth saving? Should billions of people be dependent on one person?

On the other hand, we've evolved the ability to sacrifice our lives for the greater good, since societies with that instinct stand greater chance of survival against societies without that instinct.

359 days ago | Tagged As: It depends
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

The only specific things on this life that don't change is the act of change itself. Meaning that I die of something, given few months and they come up with a new problem and just forget all about if you ever existed. The world will just go on whether you die today or not. But if you are going to live there's still a sheer chance that you can brought up change, and people would remember you while you are still living.

354 days ago | Tagged As: Are you kidding?
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

no lol screw the world it screwed me why the heck should i care so suck on that world

331 days ago | Tagged As: Are you kidding?
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

No there is no need for that, Jesus was the ultimmate sacrifice, but if i had to die for my beliefs or for a friend or even an enemy then i would

322 days ago | Tagged As: Are you kidding?
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

If there can be a situation that my death could save the human race, that would mean that the human race is pathetic and is not worth dying for

254 days ago | Tagged As: Are you kidding?
Popular Debates in World: Should the age to have sex be lowerd? Is Global Warming A Joke Or Fact? * Was global warming created to destroy America's free enterprise & economic stability?


bottomAd


About CreateDebate
The CreateDebate Blog
Take a Tour
Help/FAQ
Newsletter Archive
Sharing Tools
Invite Your Friends
Bookmarklets
Partner Buttons
RSS & XML Feeds
Reach Out
Advertise
Contact Us
Report Abuse
Twitter
Basic Stuff
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Sitemap
Creative Commons



©2010 CreateDebate, LLC All Rights Reserved. User content, unless source quoted, licensed under a Creative Commons License.