Debate Info

6
8
obvssss,... no
Debate Score:14
Arguments:14
Total Votes:14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 obvssss,... (6)
 
 no (8)

Debate Creator

vandebater(441) pic



This is a private debate. See the FAQ for more info.

Challenge Debate: aliens exist and they are probably hostile

do they exist?  i say yes

is it more likely they are hostile or peaceful? i say hostile

vandebater(441)

obvssss,...

Side Score: 6
VS.
Oiden(390)

no

Side Score: 8
1 point  

We can not prove aliens exist and have been watching us and we can't prove that picture is real. My theory is this: Earth is a young planet and its inhabitants have had a short existence. we have used a lot of resources but not as much as aliens on a much older planet would have. If aliens are desperate enough to send a long journey of many thousands of lightyears to explore space and find us, they obviously have a reason to come here. That reason based on the above statements i believe would be lack of resources. if they need resources and we have them and they are more advanced than us (since they are older and are also capable of deep space travel) they will attack. tthats what I believe. I also think it is unlikely they would want to watch us because there would be no point for that, and coming this far to earth MUST have point, more than just exploration and education.

366 days ago | Side: obvssss,...
Oiden(390) Disputed
1 point  

That picture was taken and the Battle of LA was documented in WW2. No Japenese planes spotted but a unidentified object was seen flying above the city.

Your theory that a advanced socity would need reasources and if desperate enough they could attack us for our reasources. I belive that a socity that has been around long enough would have alternate power. I'm not saying there are solar ships or things like that. I am saying that a socity could use the radiation from a star or nucelar fission/fusion for power.

I think that they could easily prefect the processes that we can't.

There could be aliens out there that would kill us for our fossle fules but there are also could be aliens that won't kill us. One of my Extra Terestal theroies is that a socity evolved enough, with a big understanding of the universe would use us as an experment and observe us on our path.

OR they could be useing us to create a race better than them. A species that would evolve to somthing better than us by killing off the weak links. There is evidence, not the kind that can not be totaly proven, but there is evidence out there.

365 days ago | Side: no
vandebater(441) Disputed
1 point  

what about resources like metal and say trees? what about water contamination from all their potential pollution. All I'm saying is if aliens were here they would have to be desperate for something. The nearest planet old enough to support advanced life while also being in the "habitable Zone" (distance from star were it is not to cold or hot for life) of their solar system is 130 light years away. This means if they are so incredibly intelligent that they can travel at light speed our planet is still 130 years away.

based on most likeliness, it is most likely our alien friends are not THAT intelligent and it would take even longer to get here. And so it is more likely coming to earth would be desperate measures. what do you do when your desperate and you find something you can take advantage of? You take advantage of it.

365 days ago | Side: obvssss,...
1 point  

They could be hostile.

But i belive that if they wanted to kill us they allready would have.

There have been thousands of alien sightings, they are observing us till we are ready.

I can't remember the exact date but this is a story from World War II

In Los Angles the military set up A-air defenses in fear of Japenese attack. At night they started shooting at somthing, a unidentifyed flying aircraft. It is unknown if we hit the thing or not. Seven people died, two or three from falling shrapnel and the rest from car crashes....

366 days ago | Side: no
1 point  

There is a picture, caught inbetween two search lights is a circular craft.

Did it attack us when we attacked it? No.

366 days ago | Side: no
Popular Debates: Is it okay to eat weed? The burden of proof is on the one making the claim. Can a stupid painting be worth $43.8 million?



About CreateDebate
The CreateDebate Blog
Take a Tour
Help/FAQ
Newsletter Archive
Sharing Tools
Invite Your Friends
Bookmarklets
Partner Buttons
RSS & XML Feeds
Reach Out
Advertise
Contact Us
Report Abuse
Twitter
Basic Stuff
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Sitemap
Creative Commons



©2013 TidyLife, Inc. All Rights Reserved. User content, unless source quoted, licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Debate Forum | Big shout-outs to The Bloggess and Andy Cohen.