CreateDebate


Debate Info

33
33
It so is It so Isn't
Debate Score:66
Arguments:33
Total Votes:122
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 It so is (16)
 
 It so Isn't (17)

Debate Creator

a1686988(4) pic



iPod = Disruptive Technology

It so is

Side Score: 33
VS.

It so Isn't

Side Score: 33
2 points

You greatly increase your chance of accidental death when submitting your mind to your devices.

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2012/jan/16/headphones-can-endanger-life-study

Side: It so is
emmagrieger Disputed
0 points

More than half of the victims were struck by trains! Therefore the fact they were walking across a train track proves it was their own silly thinking, no the ipods fault. People shouldn't be crossing train tracks in the first place!

Side: It so Isn't
1 point

iPods are more than iPods. Smartphones are a bundle of constant visual and aural stimulation.

Side: It so is
emmagrieger Disputed
2 points

In this debate though we are discussing ipods, not smart phones.

Side: It so Isn't
a1686988(4) Disputed
1 point

I'll give you some aural stimulation mate, the iPod is the biggest fascination of the noughties and a dedicate listening device is far superior.

Side: It so Isn't
1 point

Digital devices like iPods give you cancer!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N--l3120D4s

Radiation isn't good for you and is therefore disruptive.

Side: It so is
1 point

It's on the internet so it must be true!_

Side: It so is
emmagrieger Disputed
1 point

Oh Joe.....never trust the internet. You know it's not a reliable source

Side: It so Isn't
1 point

If I wanted to constantly bombard my brain with disruptive sensory stimuli, I'll listen to Southern Cross Austereo.

Side: It so is
0 points

The iPod is deliberately disruptive. That's the point. We use it to disrupt our lives with music or podcasts or youtube or mobile games as an escape from the daily grind.

Side: It so is
Antrim(1287) Disputed
2 points

Any such device as an iPod is, or at least should be designed to improve the efficiency of our business affairs and enhance our social lives.

The accepted meaning of disruptive is to be troublesome but I guess in the context of the iPod you're referring to it's adopted definition as being innovative and avant-garde.

Even so, this so called disruptive technology does not necessarily achieve the enhancement of our leisure time nor assist us in our business commitments unless used properly and we don't let ourselves become slaves to it's use.

Indeed, when the ipod is overused, which it regularly is, it becomes a hinderance to our lives.

Side: It so Isn't
Cocopops(347) Disputed
1 point

This is another classic case where the original meaning of a word, such as gay, has been changed to mean more or less the exact opposite.

Even so, the technology may be disruptive, as in ' breaking the mould' but it's not intended to 'disrupt' our lives in the way most people interpret the word.

Side: It so Isn't
emmagrieger Disputed
0 points

Actually, the iPod is used to assist us with our daily grind. We are able to multitask and use music as an aid for motivation and focus.

Side: It so Isn't
a1686988(4) Disputed
0 points

Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not Is not

Side: It so Isn't
0 points

Our eyes and ears are too consumed with what is on our devices and not where our attention should really be.

Side: It so is
emmagrieger Disputed
1 point

Yes devices - such as smartphones and tablets. Ipods simply can be put in your pocket and left alone if you choose to do so.

Side: It so Isn't
0 points

'Physical' disturbance: NO

The iPod is small, compact and easy to take anywhere with you. As well as an inbuilt speaker, it also has the ability to plug in earphones in order to not disturb anyone else around you. There are no social disturbances with the iPod.

Side: It so Isn't
Debatefam Disputed
1 point

That speaker though, we all know those dickheads who get on public transport an blast there heckin doof music out loud. The worst.

Side: It so is
a1627317(1) Disputed
0 points

There are no social disturbances with the iPod... so long as everyone is part of same social media thread.

Side: It so is
0 points

I don't believe that iPods are disruptive, I believe they are a handy little device that are easily portable.

Side: It so Isn't
a1627317(1) Disputed
2 points

Based on what evidence?

It's not about what you believe. It's about what you can prove.

Side: It so is
a1688332 Disputed
1 point

I'd rather carry an iPod in my pocket instead of lugging around a boom box breaking my shoulders

Side: It so Isn't
emmagrieger Disputed
1 point

Actually debates are all about opinions, therefore if we firmly believe one thing, it's good to make that point.

Side: It so Isn't
M4ssD3b8R Disputed
0 points

Handy little devices indeed, but the rise in policing of text-driving and the increase of penalties handed out for such offences speak for themselves. People have become addicted to technology to a point where they are incapable of paying full attention to tasks such as driving, which has been responsible for numerous deaths on the road. How often to do see a car swerve on the road, only to look into the car and see the driver gazing down into their lap.

Side: It so is
emmagrieger Disputed
0 points

That is the fault of the driver, not the technology. Addictions to technology far surpasses the ipod. This is reflective of smart phones.

Side: It so Isn't
0 points

The ability to surround yourself with your own personal favourite music is in no way a bad thing, and we as a society really benefit in many ways from using them.

bananaphone

ipods are not good.............................................................

........................................................................................

........................................................................................

.........................................................................................

.................................................................................

they are bloody FANTASTIC!!!!

they are the coolest things ever

i have a 10GB 3rd generation - you can get them from under $100 on ebay. http://www.frihost.com/forums/vt-15681.html

Productivity and the ability to tune out unecessary world noise is useful in all facets of life!

Side: It so Isn't
-1 points

The iPod has been proclaimed one of the most successful portable media and gaming devices on the market, and for good reason. Powered by iOS, the iPod touch has virtually all the features of an iPhone in a relatively inexpensive and equally pocketable form.

Side: It so Isn't
Debatefam Disputed
1 point

Let's be honest, "relatively inexpensive" is being pretty generous.

Side: It so is
emmagrieger Disputed
0 points

Well, we are generous people - fam. Being generous is nice

Side: It so Isn't
M4ssD3b8R Disputed
1 point

But this is irrelevant to the argument at hand. Affordability isn't what we're debating. It is a distraction from the world around us. Play loud music and you might not hear a car screeching towards you or a friend calling out to you not standing in your direct vision.

Side: It so is