CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
0
ewald heinrich von kleist philip freiherr von boeselager
Debate Score:3
Arguments:7
Total Votes:3
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 ewald heinrich von kleist (3)

Debate Creator

yiffyiff(8) pic



last surviving member of operation valkyrie?

so... i asked my teacher about the last surviving member and philip claims to be the last member but.... ewald died almost 4 years after philip.

ewald heinrich von kleist

Side Score: 3
VS.

philip freiherr von boeselager

Side Score: 0
1 point

Ewald died in 2013, philipp in 2008 .

Side: ewald heinrich von kleist
yiffyiff(8) Clarified
1 point

i know that, but i was looking at the book valkyrie and it says phillip was the last surviving member. confused and need more answers haha

Side: ewald heinrich von kleist
cruzaders(343) Clarified
1 point

Sorry, I havent read the book, cant help you on that one

Good luck!!!

Side: ewald heinrich von kleist
1 point

I think it was a mistake to claim he was the last. Philipp died before Ewald. It makes me kind of wonder if there was a mistake or is Philipp didn't think Ewald had much to do with it....at least not enough to rightfully claim he was a part of it.

Side: ewald heinrich von kleist
yiffyiff(8) Clarified
1 point

that's true. my teacher claimed it must have been for advertising purposes possibly?

Side: ewald heinrich von kleist
1 point

Also very possible. Seems to be odd to advertise when it's so easily proven wrong.

Side: ewald heinrich von kleist
No arguments found. Add one!