CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:64
Arguments:36
Total Votes:73
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
  (37)

Debate Creator

joecavalry(40163) pic



"rights," "entitlement," and "morality" are just human concepts that are ...

human concepts

... defined by each individual.

What I consider "morally right" may differ from what you consider morally right.

Just because you feel "entitled" to something, doesn't mean you are entitled to it.

A "right" is only something granted to you by society through the government.

People don't like to ask because to ask means the possibility to be denied. So they demand. Making a demand carries more weight to it if you claim that it is "morally right" and that it is your "right" and therefore you are "entitled" to it.

But, does a zebra use the same logic with a lion? Does a lion use that same logic with other lions? Why must human insist on using this flawed logic? No one is entitled to anything that is not given to them, including rights. And morality is an illusion.

Add New Argument

The Greek philosophers came up with a pretty radical idea that shaped the creation of our nation: certain permanent moral and political truths are accessible to human reason.

This means, using reason, people can agree on certain morals. For example, things like killing or raping an innocent person is wrong. We can use logic to come up with a definition of what is "moral" in the most basic sense. The reason this idea was so significant a couple hundred years ago is because most people considered morality something that could only be attained from reading the bible. This new idea was that humans have capacity to figure out what should be moral and what natural rights people should have.

This is why we are able to have secular laws: because people can agree on certain laws based on reason. Obviously there will be disagreements, but discussions about these issues allow us to come to the best conclusion as to what are our "rights" "entitlements" and what is "moral".

Side: Use Reason

Yes, discussions about these issues allow us to come to the best conclusion as to what are our "rights" "entitlements" and what is "moral". But how do we resolve disagreements in order to move forward?

Side: Use Reason
1 point

Wow. Those all sounds like comments from me!?

=D

Who ever said that Joe Cavalry didn't make meaningful debates????

I am a person who is deeply rooted in morality. To me, morality is what sets us apart from the animals that are on the Earth... Without morals to guide our every step...What are we? Now, you must have reason. Your morals must be practical. Then again, isn't the term practical relative?

Side: morality is human

Well in the U.S. we elect people who vote and make those decisions, but even then you still don't get a consensus, just a majority. I guess the best we can do is figure out at the most basic sense what is moral (don't kill etc...) and then work your way up from their. So long as we go about the process rationally and try to learn from and correct mistakes in the past then we will at least be moving in the right direction.

Side: Use Reason
1 point

This is the tragedy in some countries that government spend very low upon science and research. The figures and statistics presented by you are very helpful for people to know about science budget. Now buy research papers on http://advanced-writer.com and prepare such statistics and figures without any difficulty.

Side: Use Reason
2 points

That's why the whole point if politics is making a system where there could be as many people happy as possible.

Words, such as morality came to exist to manipulate when some people felt entitled to have more than others.

We ALL know what we should act like. Morality is just a word used to make some feel like they should act whatever you attach the word to.

Basically, you are just suppose to get your happiness and let others get theirs.

Side: Use Reason
arnesen(44) Disputed
2 points

"We ALL know what we should act like," you say. It is a statement the supposes that we all acknowledge certain, universal actions or rules behind the concept of morality.

That is not so, at least not if I take point in your argument: Different people have a different understanding of how one should act. In some cultures, killing a person is very much acceptable, while in typical Western culture it is not.

The usage of morality has been widespread. To say that its only aim is to manipulate people, is nothing short of ignorant. I think that both Plato and Aristotle would oppose such an argument quite strongly.

However, you are at least somewhat right, when you remark that the aim of morality is to achieve happiness (if nothing, it is true generally speaking). For example, Aristotle spoke of eudaimonia - the good life - in his virtue ethics.

I think that morality is a word that tries to explain a concept, thus dismissing any initial manipulative aim. There's no denying, however, that the concept of morality has been misused as a means of reaching certain not-too-noble goals throughout history.

My final thought on this matter, for now, is that morality can be understood quite differently by different people or cultures. At the same time, there is something inherently moral that all human beings are subject to. It is a concept within human nature, in which morality is a way defining and understanding that concept - much more than "just a word".

And as a side-note: Although I have stated that morality may differ, such relativism is dangerous, and I do believe there are certain fixed values within the concept of morality that in the end will appeal to all human beings. That is, of course, a different discussion - but I had to address it as part of my overall argument.

Side: Use Reason

Yes, exactly. one up vote.

Side: Use Reason
2 points

You fundamentally misunderstand the word "right" if you say that it is conveyed by government.

A "right" is that to which you are entitled and NO one can take it away: "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights".

That is, the right is bestowed by God and not man, therefore man cannot take the right away.

A right is not something arbitrary. I do not have a "right" to chocolate ice cream on Thursdays, for instance. But I have a right to free speech, equal treatment under the law, etc.

"Entitlement" is something specifically granted by a law or regulation.

"Morality" is something usually imposed on others by self righteous types whose own morality is subject to some serious flaws. Larry Craig is a perfect example, and so is Newt Gingrich.

Sen. Craig fought tooth and nail against gay rights his entire political career, while doing things in public places that most gay men would find abhorrent. Gingrich decries gay rights and specifically denounced gay protesters as "fascists", while he abandoned his wife for an adulterous relationship while the poor woman was in the hospital as a cancer patient.

Side: Use Reason

Well, if (for example) gay marriage is a right, then it is bestowed by God and no one can take it away or give it to them. If they have a right to get married then they should just get married and not bother asking anyone.

On the other hand, if gay marriage is an entitlement, then they have to go through the long, arduous process of getting the government to grant them that entitlement.

Finally if the gay community says that it is morally wrong to keep them from getting married, aren't they being self righteous for imposing their views on others? Especially when their own morality is subject to some serious flaws like vandalizing churches? I mean, the gay community has even denounced the religious right of hatred and bigotry. A lot of people find these actions to be abhorrent.

Side: Use Reason
chg9389(111) Disputed
1 point

Uh, we DID have that right under the California constitution. Remember the California Supreme Court decision in June? Equal protection? That one. It was ripped away from us by a popular vote. Since when are constitutional rights EVER removed by popular vote? That isn't constitutional because the constitution - both state and federal - guarantees equal protection, even if the minority is one single person.

You had better believe we're denouncing the religious right as bigoted and hate filled. What on earth else would you call it?

They spent $35 million denying rights of millions of people in California, Arizona, and Florida this past election. Self-proclaimed "RELIGIOUS" people did that. Can you honestly find a single instance of Jesus asking for his followers to hurt anyone? Not in my Bible you can't.

This orgy of spending by the "religious" on pure, unabased hatred of people they don't even know comes at a time when food banks and other worth while charities go begging. Where's the great call from these EXACT same religious groups? Where is call from the Mormons to send their member's millions flooding into projects that feed the hungry in a time when government assistance is unavailable, when jobs are being lost, when even bankruptcy has been removed as an option for millions to escape being crushed by debt?

Where is the great compassion of the Baptists? Where is help from the mega churches? WHERE?!

THAT is what Jesus asks of his followers, not this freaking hate and oppression.

Don't think for one minute you're going to impress me with your religion when you can't even follow it yourself. That, Sir, I find "abhorrent."

To hell with these people. Bigots all.

Side: Use Reason

An argument whose foundation is based on "rights, "entitlement," and/or "morality" is flawed, even though it will sway a large group of people. The reason it is flawed is because these are human concepts that change over time as society changes.

Side: Use Reason
1 point

Early readers of Montaigne noticed the subjective investment his essays enact and invite

custom essay http://www.bestessayhelp.com

Side: Use Reason

By the creator of this debates logic the only real right one has is the right to impose his will on some or everyone else, hence getting his entitlements through force or cunning. Sounds like an apt example of human evolution!

Side: Use Reason
1 point

Waw. He used to actually do proper debating :S

Side: Use Reason

What happened that changed me into the person I am today? ;)

Side: Use Reason
1 point

I don't know :( but I wish you'd go back and try debating sometimes...

Side: Use Reason
1 point

Once I had to write an essay on this topic. An essay writer write my essay quickly)

Side: Use Reason

You dug up this 6 year old debate for an essay? I'm going to be famous ;)

Side: Use Reason
1 point

There are so many different aspects when it comes to this topic. Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge on this particular aspect. buy custom papers online

Side: Use Reason

You are probably a good person but you haven't taken the time to fill out your profile, so I'll never know! ;)

Side: Use Reason
1 point

Many new ways of education are introduced which are more effective. New definitions of students and teachers are mentioned. Multiple means of education are used now a days which are not only confined to the classes like for essay is available. I used to cooperate with professional paper writing service . Now, I think, writing will be much easier.

Side: Use Reason
1 point

Once students turn to professional writers http://www.perfectessaysonline.com, they get qualified help in any college question or any written task! So they don't need to waste your precious time! You can think about it!

Side: Use Reason
1 point

Greetings! I want to say, that rights, entitlment are human concepts that are very important in our life. All people have to be fair to each other and have to respect the rights of other people. I had a task at college top write an essay on the topic: "Human concepts". I was busy, so I ordered it online here - http://best-essays-writers.com/! From these arguments one might conclude that all of us need to remember about rights, entitlement, morality and respect others!

Side: Use Reason
1 point

When students need help related with essay writing they turn to professional writers. Every research paper written by our writers http://www.perfectessaysonline.com is newly written, not recycled. We don't recycle papers or pull papers off the Internet and disguise them as new work. Instead, every paper work is written from scratch.

Side: Use Reason
1 point

Hi! If you are a student and you found it hard to write a good essay, I offer you to use a service of professionals who can rapidly research and write an essay on the necessary subject for you, meeting your deadlines and whatever academic level you need! Do not lose your chance to have the best writing help http://www.express-essays.com right now!

Supporting Evidence: online writing help (www.express-essays.com)
Side: Use Reason
KylieJensen(2) Disputed
1 point

Thanks for sharing, you can also try advanced-writer.com to get your education on next level

Side: Use Reason
1 point

There is a point.I agree with author.By the way,if you have to write an essay ,but don`t know where start from,I recommend you this http://essays-shark.net team of professionals who are always ready to help

Side: Use Reason
1 point

I agree that motality plays a very important role. However, not everyone pays attention to it. As I am a tsduent, I study alot of courses. Once I had to write a paper on Morality. So I ordered it at http://best-custom-essays.com. My essay was superior :)

Side: Use Reason
1 point

Yes, animals don't use the same logic with other animals, but humans are not animals. There must be morality in our society, otherwise everyone would do what they want and ignore other people's feelings, thoughts and values. Nevertheless, this is very deep topic to research and if you need excellent writing assistance http://www.grand-essays.com/ team of professionals will help you cope with any task.

Side: Use Reason
khabib(3) Banned
1 point

Streaming a film or watching your number one series is a standout amongst other approaches to keep your eyes off work and stress. Be that as it may, doesn't it sound more invigorating to impart a bowl of popcorn to your loved ones while doing it? Presently you're likely considering approaches to intensify your video show for everybody to appreciate it. HDMI 2.0 Port Laptops

https://techydiy.com/best-laptop-with-hdmi-2-0-port/

Side: Use Reason
ZakBolton(1) Banned
1 point

Many of your papers would be improved by narrowing in on one specific part of the assignment writing services—for example, you might highlight and attack or defend a key premise. Many of you made very high-altitude and general criticisms but struggled (especially given the space constraints) to grapple with specific aspects of an argument.

Supporting Evidence: assignment writing services (perfectessaywriting.com)
Side: Use Reason