CreateDebate


Debate Info

48
20
of course they should no, absolutely not.
Debate Score:68
Arguments:37
Total Votes:94
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 of course they should (25)
 
 no, absolutely not. (12)

Debate Creator

matt7901(8) pic



should elementary school kids have cell phones?

of course they should

Side Score: 48
VS.

no, absolutely not.

Side Score: 20
5 points

They have their right to have cell phones. They can make calls to friends, teachers and parents. Also, when they have nothing to do, they can play games.

Side: of course they should

Any person who can afford a cell phone has the right to own.

Side: Of course they should
laurjohn(97) Disputed
2 points

young kids can't afford a cell phone. If they can, then they're spoilt brats.

Side: no, absolutely not.
3 points

If they are spoiled, that is besides the point, if their mom and dad choice to pay, then they should have cell phones.

Side: Of course they should
Tschmergel(1) Disputed
3 points

If kids can raise the money themselves or help around the house of course they have the responsibly and if they go around the country a lot then that could let them contact any relatives if they get lost

Side: of course they should
3 points

i mean why not having a cell phone in an elementery school??

what would harm them havong it? if parents are not affording it now then theyll never be able to..

Side: Of course they should
2 points

Yes! of course they should have a cell phone!! it is a good way to stay in touch with friends, play games and most of all, they can go out on their own, because they can call their parents if needed, or text (which is what i do) Im in grade 8 and i just god a phone last year! many kida have them and it is a good thing to have :)

Side: Of course they should
aveskde(1935) Disputed
3 points

Yes! of course they should have a cell phone!! it is a good way to stay in touch with friends, play games

These aren't school activities, and they are distracting.

they can go out on their own, because they can call their parents if needed, or text (which is what i do)

This is what telephone booths are for. Cellphones aren't required for this.

Im in grade 8 and i just god a phone last year! many kida have them and it is a good thing to have :)

Not for school. In your private life, go ahead.

Side: no, absolutely not.
AZ33(1) Disputed
0 points

Hi, I don't agree, but I don't know how I got here. See ya

Side: no, absolutely not.
2 points

Yes, of course, why not? If they're responsible enough, I don't see a problem with that.

Side: Of course they should
2 points

well first of all im 10 and i have a cellphone and i do need it because what if im in a emergency or a friend i can call for help or call a parent

Side: Of course they should
2 points

yes. In this decade Elementary aged kids have the biggest risks involving kidknapper, by having a cell phone they would have the abilty to contact higher athourity, with out it, i hate to say it, but they are simply screwed.

Side: of course they should
2 points

what if the parent has something important to tell thier child while at school my mom did that and well my grandma died

Side: of course they should
2 points

because phones are cool

and you could be listening to music while you do your test

Side: of course they should
2 points

I think kids should have cell phones in their backpack but not be able to use it unless if there is an emergency or the teacher says so. If not the case, they should simply not use it.

Side: of course they should
2 points

REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

Side: of course they should
2 points

YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEET

Side: of course they should
1 point

Kids should have phones because then they can make calls, download games/music, and they can send texts and surf the web. I think kids in elementary school and up should have phones.

Side: of course they should
1 point

There's no in between, but I think every case is different. For instance, I think that most kids don't really NEED one. They would mostly just use it to play candy crush or something. I think the kids that DO need one are the ones that play sports or have stuff to do after school. They might need a phone to call their parents if they need it. In this case, they might do well with a phone that will only call their parents and 911, if such a phone even exists.

Side: of course they should
1 point

I think Elementary student aged kids should NOT, bring cellphones to school.

Why?

I have many reasons: Here are my pros and cons:'

Pros:

-Memories

-Fieldtrip

Cons: Big distraction in Class!

- Bulling

- Cyber bulling

- Cheat in class- taking a picture of exam or test.

Supporting Evidence: Don't Gossip Girl- STOP bullining, now (www.youtube.com)
Side: of course they should
1 point

Yes way kids always has technology like computers or cellphones

Side: of course they should
1 point

Fortnite is good Every kid should have a phone people need them

Side: of course they should
1 point

They have their right to have cell phones. They can make calls to friends, teachers and parents. Also, when they have nothing to do, they can play games.

Side: of course they should
1 point

i love burritos fortnite is good poop is smelly joaans ipod is coming for u

Side: of course they should
0 points

what what do you call an alligator wearing an invest a gator

Fortntie
Side: of course they should
3 points

Well they shouldn't have them, not that they don't or couldn't.

When I was in elementary school I did not own a cell phone. I didn't need one, now I go anywhere and see a 8 year old texting and totally spaced out. Starting a bad habit early.

Parents these days give their kids to much leniency.

Side: no, absolutely not.
2 points

No way in hell.

Kids are growing up too fast these days. Sure, parents do what they think is best for their kids, but they shouldn't have cell phones because they don't need them at this age. If something happens at school, they should know to get the teacher to ring Mom. If something happens out of school, well, kids this age shouldn't even leave home on their own, or maybe within walking distance.

What do kids this age even use cell phones for, anyway? Kids should be studying or reading, not wasting their childhoods texting away on an expensive cell phone.

Parents have to actually pay for the phone and it's plan (any kid who has enough poclet money to pay for it themselves is downright spoilt), and some parents spoil their kids in this regard. The number of times I've seen 7 year olds playing with iPhones is crazy. This treatment by parents is likely to turn the kids into fat snobs.

I'm a high school student and have the cheapest phone available. No camera, no games, no internet, nothing. I barely use it, and am surviving. I even know some adults who hate cell phones and only have one in case of emergency.

If older people can live without cell phones, why can't school kids?

Side: no, absolutely not.
mythic(14) Disputed
1 point

thats Because older people are like "back in the old days, it took 2 hours to download a movie on a kilobyte computer.

Side: of course they should
1 point

Cell phones are distracting for children and teenagers. They can message and play games. In a classroom concentration and focus are important things.

Cell phones make teachers' jobs that much more challenging.

Side: no, absolutely not.
1 point

Also not in the slightest HELL. If kids get an expensive phone they could drop it or damage it. They could also do very inappropriate things on the internet. Or download violent games like five nights a Freddy's.

Side: no, absolutely not.
1 point

It depends on the kind of phone. If it is an old phone that can only do basic calling and texting, it might be fine. More likely, the child will receive a smart phone. It is too much responsibility to allow kids to handle a relatively expensive device that is, most of the time, not used responsibly. I'm currently in school, and most of my peers easily use phones to cheat during tests, and get away with it. Elementary school is too early for technological responsibilities. Once you give children free access to the Internet without supervision, you cannot control what they find. The risks of giving an elementary school kid a cell phone outweigh the safety benefits.

Side: no, absolutely not.

They are too young to be having a cell phone. Some of them would not even know how to use one.

Side: no, absolutely not.
0 points

Why would a kindergarten or anybody with a higher grade want to have a cell phone in school? Where I live students in the elementary school have strict policies about cell phones. Plus these kids are too young to be texting or calling people or be using them in class.

Side: no, absolutely not.
0 points

The only reason they would need a cell phone is if they were without someone who had one (for this argument I'm pretending that only 8th grade and up have cell phones). I believe that children who are in elementary school shouldn't be without someone who has a phone anyway. They should be at a friend's house (where there is a house phone, or parent with cell phone) or at the movies with family, or friends with adult supervision. Or anywhere, but they should be with someone responsible (like 8th grade and up). How often do you see a bunch of 10 and 11 year olds walking through the mall alone? If you do, I believe they shouldn't be out alone anyway, with or without cell phones. I'm in 9th grade and I only just got a phone. Although I've always know younger kids who had phones, I always wondered why they needed them. Now I know, they don't.

Side: I don't think so