CreateDebate


Debate Info

6
9
saves lives dangerous and expensive!
Debate Score:15
Arguments:10
Total Votes:16
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 saves lives (4)
 
 dangerous and expensive! (6)

Debate Creator

101kakashi(381) pic



xenotransplantation

for those who don't know, xenotransplantaion is the transfer of animal organs to humans. 

the field of organ transplantation has advanced at an astonishing pace. but the technique is extremely expensive and potentially dangerous.

saves lives

Side Score: 6
VS.

dangerous and expensive!

Side Score: 9

I want a horse's [this part has been censored because this is a family site] ;)

Side: saves lives
2 points

Hey Joe would you like a baboon's ass to go with that?.......:)

Side: saves lives
1 point

phphphphphph hahahahahahahahahahahahahah HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA damn!!! i dnt think anyone can beat that!!!!!!!! hahahahahayy

Side: saves lives
1 point

hahahahahahhahahahahahhahahhahahhahaha im speechless hahahahahahha all i can do is laugh!

Side: saves lives
2 points

There's a hypothesis that the use of animal tissue for human use was what allowed HIV to cross the species barrier. To transplant the animal organ too, the person's immune system must also be suppressed to avoid rejection. Having the two together doesn't really make for a pretty picture.

Scientists are already very close to developing synthetic organs for the medical market. Xenotransplantation just seems a poor intermediary step.

Side: dangerous and expensive!
1 point

true! recommendations suggest that anyone who receives an animal organ should never have unprotected sex and should never have children because of the public health risk. opponents of the technology also maintain that any virus that could be transmitted from an animal to a human could spread to the rest of the population easily, noting that HIV was likely a cross species transfer.In addition, animal-rights activists are outraged that animals are being tested and cloned in order to possibly alleviate human medical conditions.

Side: dangerous and expensive!
2 points

People need to die, hasn't anyone realised how dangerously close we are to overpopulating the world?

Side: dangerous and expensive!
1 point

true...we are overpopulating the world! it might lead us to chaos! thts y people need to die! :D

Side: dangerous and expensive!

So are you saying you don't mind dying in order to free up space and resources?

Assuming the answer to be a resounding no, therein lies the the dichotomy;-)

Q.Why do we place such high value on the sanctity of human life?

A. Self Interest.

Side: dangerous and expensive!
1 point

this technique is extremely expensive and potentially dangerous. viruses are integrated into animal genes, and scientists do not yet know if people can become infected with those viruses if they receive an animal organ transplant. Also the health implications for organ recipients are not fully tested, and patients receiving animal organs could have severe restrictions placed on their lifestyles.

Side: dangerous and expensive!