Debate Info

install flash for graphs
Men Have A Say Men Have No Say
Debate Score:178
Arguments:2
Total Votes:243
Show More Stats

Argument Tags

side graph
Show All Tags
 
 a woman's right to choose (15)
 
 Men should have their say in abortion (15)
 
 euqal for both sexes (8)
 
 Abortion (7)
 
 men have no say (4)
 
 Unclear Definition (4)
 
 Men Have A Say (3)
 
 we sue the bastards (3)
 
 hugs (1)
 
 someone's whipped (1)

Debate Creator

altarion(1848) pic



Abortion: What About a Man's Choice?

With all this talk we hear about abortion and a woman's choice, I often wonder - What about a man's choice? The unborn child is just as much the man's baby as the woman's, so why is she in sole control of what happens to it? The child develops in her body, but this does not diminish the fact that this is also his child. What if the guy really wants his child to be born and is willing to take responsibility, but the girl decides to terminate the pregnancy? Is it not completely unfair that a male has absolutely no say in whether his child will be kept or aborted? Would he not be anguished about this for the rest of his life and feel just as a woman who deeply regrets having an abortion feels? To all you guys reading this, if you were stuck in the same situation (got a girl pregnant), how would you feel knowing that she is aborting your child and you can do nothing about it?


Men Have A Say

Side Score: 99
VS.

Men Have No Say

Side Score: 79

Arguments Tagged As: men have no say [clear]
No arguments found. Add one!
Vote Up Vote Down
3 points

The real reason that men should have no say is that until the child is born, it's a medical procedure and they have no right to tell anyone else what they can and can't have done medically. That's a matter for the patient and the doctor. Think about how a man would feel if he had, let's call it a tumor, growing inside him that may cause him some discomfort and annoyance but no serious health concerns. Say he wants his doctor to remove it. But his wife who has a say in his medical procedures due to her stake in his future (he will provide and provide for her future children) says no. Since it's not medically necessary and law allows her a say, he can't get it removed.

Further, your supposing the men want to stop women from having an abortion. What about men forcing women to have abortions for babies they don't want to be responsible for. If they have any say at all, that is a real possibility.

288 days ago | Tagged As: men have no say
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

That is a personal decision. If it were made a law that men have a say in the woman's abortion, it would be taking away a LOT of her freedom.

Say a woman is in an abusive relationship, and she gets impregnated by her husband. She's too afraid to leave her husband because she wont have any money or place to stay. She doesn't want to bring up a child in this lifestyle so she wants to get an abortion. But her husband wants to keep the child. They go to court, but since it's a LAW that the man has a say over the 'child' she has to have it.

This is ridiculous. It may be your sperm, but it's the woman's body. It may be hard for you- even devastating- but pregnancy shouldn't be taken so lightly!

If your girlfriend gets pregnant, you want to keep the child (for yourself, she doesn't), and she agrees: TADA! You now have a child for yourself, and the woman didn't have any of her rights violated.

This cannot be made a law. It would have SO MANY downfalls. It would do more bad than good, and violate the right a woman has over her body.

End of discussion.

88 days ago | Tagged As: men have no say
Popular Debates: I am the only normal person Abortion Humans are becoming lazy.



About CreateDebate
The CreateDebate Blog
Take a Tour
Help/FAQ
Newsletter Archive
Sharing Tools
Invite Your Friends
Bookmarklets
Partner Buttons
RSS & XML Feeds
Reach Out
Advertise
Contact Us
Report Abuse
Twitter
Basic Stuff
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Sitemap
Creative Commons



©2010 CreateDebate, LLC All Rights Reserved. User content, unless source quoted, licensed under a Creative Commons License.