CreateDebate



Welcome to CreateDebate!

CreateDebate is a social tool that democratizes the decision-making process through online debate. Join Now!
  • Find a debate you care about.
  • Read arguments and vote the best up and the worst down.
  • Earn points and become a thought leader!

To learn more, check out the FAQ or Tour.



Be Yourself

Your profile reflects your reputation, it will build itself as you create new debates, write arguments and form new relationships.

Make it even more personal by adding your own picture and updating your basics.


FB
Facebook addict? Check out our page and become a fan because you love us!


pic
Report This User
Permanent Delete

Allies
View All
None

Enemies
View All
pic


Hostiles
View All
pic
pic


RSS Peterc

Reward Points:39
Efficiency: Efficiency is a measure of the effectiveness of your arguments. It is the number of up votes divided by the total number of votes you have (percentage of votes that are positive).

Choose your words carefully so your efficiency score will remain high.
100%
Arguments:19
Debates:4
meter
Efficiency Monitor
Online:


Joined:
10 most recent arguments.
peterc(39) Clarified
1 point

A lame film I know, but it's one of the few rom-coms that has a philosophical bent and relates to what you're saying: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4u7akRLnGyk

1 point

Yes, as the saying goes, the only events we can be certain will occur in the future are death and taxes :P

1 point

Yes, this would be a more palatable way of looking at determinism. Causes and the laws of nature 'limit' the choices of action available to us at a given time, rather than restricting it to just one.

3 points

The intuition we all have that we can do whatever we like - that we do have free will - is so strong it is impossible to ignore. Surely this is a (reasonably) weighty reason for believing we do have free will.

1 point

Yes, perhaps our normal understanding of free will is nonsensical (the notion that we can freely select between two or more actions at a given time). How could an action be uncaused? How could I select between more than one action at a given moment? If the laws of nature play their role and a web of causes also play their role, surely my action is determined. The idea that I could 'freely' choose what to do independent of or despite these determining factors seems absurd.

2 points

Yes, so are you suggesting a kind of compatibilism, where causal determinism (including the chemistry of your brain being constrained by the laws of nature) is compatible with free will? Causes in our past and in our bodies determine our actions, but provided 'we' choose to perform the action, it was a free one? Chemical reactions in my body as well as external stimuli might lead me to go and make a sandwich, but provided no one forced me to do it, the action was 'free' and of my own choosing.

2 points

Like for a tbh..........................................................

1 point

Singer supports his view with the case of the drowning child; surely you have an obligation to jump into a shallow pond you are passing by if you see a small child fall into it (even if it meant ruining your expensive shoes). To simply walk on would be abhorrent. Equally, we have an obligation to jump online and give money using our credit cards to relieve death and suffering from poverty - you could save a life for the same cost as a pair of shoes. It doesn't matter that the dying child in Bangladesh is further away.

1 point

There is some merit to this. Perhaps by giving to relieve death and suffering from famine, we postpone the inevitable. Population growth is actually quite high in the third world. Our planet surely cannot sustain population growth at present rates. Maybe our giving ought to be directed at means to control population (education girls for example)?

1 point

I like your style. Yes, I suspect that those who support utilitarian ethics change their minds when they finds themselves in the minority who are being mistreated or abused for the 'greater good.'

About Me


I am probably a good person but I haven't taken the time to fill out my profile, so you'll never know!


Want an easy way to create new debates about cool web pages? Click Here