CreateDebate


Debate Info

56
13
I believe it should be legal I believe it should be legal
Debate Score:69
Arguments:65
Total Votes:72
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 I believe it should be legal (50)

Debate Creator

HTHAMES(46) pic



Abortion: Your stance

Use the arguments that come up in Roe v. Wade in your debate

I believe it should be legal

Side Score: 56
VS.

I believe it should be legal

Side Score: 13
3 points

I am for abortion. I am pro do whatever you please as long as you are doing the right thing. I feel like women are already so penalized by society as it is. If they feel like getting an abortion with the intention that it will be better for them then it should not matter. Why would we allow women to have children that they don’t want, can’t take care of in some instances, and won’t be able to just fully be there for. I also do not like how men are in charge of something that doesn’t even really involve them truly. This is a woman's body. Men are one of women’s biggest troubles. Why do they get the say so on whether or not a woman can do something with her body? Let’s just create a scenario. A woman goes to a party, a man rapes her, and she gets pregnant. She should be able to get an abortion if she wants because why should she continue to be reminded of such a traumatic experience. She didn’t want that baby, it was forced upon her. But to society she would be considered a whore who is going to hell, which is absurd. I feel like we should just have some better regulations when it comes to abortion but it should never be illegal because that is not going to ban it, it is just going to make women go and get unsafe abortions. There should be a reasonable time period for when a woman can get an abortion and we put abortion clinics in very safe environments so they won’t have the people who don’t know how to keep their opinions to themselves and go to the clinics with signs and horns to shame women who are trying to do what’s best for them. It is not like women are taking toddlers to these clinics and murdering them like everything envisions. It is a woman knowing that she will not be able to be the best mom to this baby and before having to give it up to child protective services, which is not in a very good spot as of right now, or have to just deal with it and give this child a terrible life that they did not ask for. Statistics show “In 2019, a study titled Maternal Suicide in Italy by Lega et al. was published in the journal Archives of Women’s Mental Health detailing suicide rates in Italian mothers. In the study, “maternal suicide” is defined as “women who died by suicide during pregnancy or within 1 year after giving birth, induced abortion or miscarriage.” The authors identified 67 cases of maternal suicide between 2006-2012, which corresponded with a maternal suicide ratio of 2.30/100,000 live births. Of the maternal suicides included in this study, the suicide rate of women who had abortions was more than double the suicide rate of women who gave birth.” That just shows that the abortion still effects the women. Women already have to deal with all the gruesome trials and tribulations that they have been bestowed at birth. Imagine you know that you can’t handle something and you know it is going to end horribly, so you don’t do it or you get rid of it and you have a big group of people judging you and telling you how your decision is going to send you to hell with a first class ticket. Crazy right?

Side: I believe it should be legal
2 points

I agree with this, I too believe it should be part of basic health care, and they should not be criticized for doing what they feel is best for them.

Side: I believe it should be legal
2 points

Amen brotherrrr. I agree with this response because abortion should just be a choice!! Not a debate and it is a woman's business on whether she wants an abortion or not. Privacy please???

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I like how you included that men in society have one of the biggest voices about this issue. Not only do they not go through pregnancy, but also cannot justify the idea of having a child and knowing you cannot support it. Abortion should not be looked upon as murdering a child because 9/10 abortions are done within the first 12 weeks which is before a baby becomes viable. The pain a woman has to endure to even get an abortion is already so straining and no one should be able to tear her down for it.

Side: I believe it should be legal
2 points

I am pro choice because I feel like women should be able to decide what happens to their bodies. Abortion should be a choice women get to make when they cannot financially support a baby, their health is not where it should be, or if they were sexually assualted. Some people might say you could put your baby up for adoption or to foster care. Who would want to go through pregnancy and give up their child to a random family that may not support their baby properly? If a girl is raped should she be forced to keep her rapist's kid? Society should not get to say what is right and what is wrong when it comes to our bodies. I do not see the harm in abortion when you catch it early and get one in the first trimester. I understand that if you are in the the third trimester of pregnancy and your baby is close to being fully grown that it is not okay. In any other situation, I support abortion fully. Also, I am a seventeen year old girl and I know if I became pregnant right now it would ruin my future of trying to get a degree or even going to college. As a matter of fact, age is a huge factor in abortions. A study in 2014 states that 60% of women that got abortions were in their early 20’s according to the Guttmacher Institute. It’s hard for young women to be able to support another life when they are figuring out how to start theirs. All in all, I feel that their are many circumstances that women should be able to choose abortion if it is the best option for their life.

Side: I believe it should be legal
clnorvell22(8) Disputed
1 point

"I understand that if you are in the the third trimester of pregnancy and your baby has a beating heart that it is not okay."

Fun Fact: The heartbeat of the child can be detected by an ultrasound after between 6.5-7 weeks after conception.

Side: I believe it should be legal
jtaylor23(13) Disputed
1 point

Even when a fetus's lungs are fully developed, it's impossible for the fetus to breathe until after birth. Developing babies are surrounded by amniotic fluid, and their lungs are filled with this fluid. By 10–12 weeks of gestation, developing babies begin taking “practice” breaths

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

Yes I did not do my research before I said this and I should have.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

Though I’m not religious, nor do I pretend to be so, I understand where people may base their opinion of abortion on religion. With that being said, a religious opinion is invalid in the case of prohibiting an individual’s rights, especially in the United States. After withdrawing from Great Britain, who enforced specific religion and tyranny, the founding fathers established the Constitution. In the 1st amendment of this Constitution, it is stated that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” It has been evident since the early beginnings of the U.S. that separation of church and state would be put into place. With this separation of church and state, it would be difficult, and shouldn’t be possible, to pass a law outlawing something along the lines of such morality. On top of this, citizens in the United States are allotted the unenumerated right to privacy. If someone’s private choice is infringed upon by jail time or scrutiny, it could cause serious issues. The final point to be made is on the matter of the Citizenship clause. This is found in Section 1 of the 14 amendment and it reads,"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside." If a child has yet to be born, and therefore yet to be naturalized, it is technically not subject to due process which was being argued in the original case of Roe v. Wade. The complete outlawing of abortion is shown to be difficult and improper on the basis of the Constitution.

Side: I believe it should be legal
ManoloRolo(3) Disputed
1 point

I am aware of the religious themes in trying to argue something like abortion here as for many zealots may do it. There is still some moral argument to be made here outside of what specific religions we have here. Such as the many rights to life as well even if not naturalized by a birth certificate. Rights should still be applied even for those that aren't, like immigrants here yet still deserve life or can we execute them?

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

My position on abortion is that it should be legal but also not encouraged in every case. The decision on abortion should be considerate of every situation, for instance rape, people unfit to be mothers, and people that could get killed or have long lasting effects. Although, abortion should not be legal in every case. If abortions were easy to get for everyone, people may take advantage of it. When a person decides to have sex there is always a chance of pregnancy and the risk should be considered. My brother got married at a young age and they were not in the best place to have a child but they never considered aborting it. They had the baby and worked to give her a better life and now they have two kids, a house, two cars, and their lives are thriving. They recognized that they made the choice to have sex and they knew they could make it work with a child, so they had her. In 2017, the United States had a total of 862,300 induced abortions and most birth controls prevent pregnancy 99% of the time. Abortions can be avoided and should be at all costs, even if they are needed in some situations. Although, access to abortions should be a basic healthcare availability to women because having a child is a lot of responsibility and anyone having one should be able to provide for them. Women have to have the babies so their health and well being should be considered at all times. In all, having a child is a big duty and if a pregnant woman can’t take that responsibility then it should not be pressured on them, but if they can then having the baby should be encouraged.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I agree that some people can provide for a child, however that is often not the case. Pregnancy cannot always be controlled. There are so many factors that go into the decision of whether or not to keep a child. First of all, not everyone is able to safely deliver the baby due to prior medical problems. Others are not ready to take on this responsibility. Some women need to finish their education or keep their job in order to support themselves. Some women don't have a partner to help them take care of the baby and they feel very overwhelmed. Money is a large factor in making this decision. Even with the option of putting the baby up for adoption, it costs from $5,000 to $11,000 just to deliver the baby. In other cases there must be a necessary c-section in order to protect the baby or mother which can cost up to $14,500.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I agree that it should not be encouraged, but in some cases it should be an option.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I believe that women should have the right to choose whether or not they would like to have an abortion. Making abortions illegal will not stop abortions it will just make them unsafe and many women may die as a result. On the WHO website under the topic of abortion they state, “Legal restrictions, as well as social and cultural beliefs linked to abortion, can make women reluctant to seek timely medical care in case of abortion-related complications, which further puts women’s health and well-being at risk.” There is also the matter of privacy. Women should not have to explain their reasoning to anybody and there should not be circumstances put to limit it. Not all women are part of the same religion so they should not be put through pregnancy because of another religion. It costs $5,000-$11,000 just to push the baby out and then you have to financially support that child until they are 18. Some women are not able to pay that and give the child a good life so that child may end up abused (mentally and/or physically). Babies can also put the mother's life in danger. In those cases its choosing between a baby going without a mother or the mother living and having another baby.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I agree, even if they are illegal people will continue to have them, but in unsafe ways.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I agree with this, not everyone has the funding available and it should be taken into consideration.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I agree, one can't be told to do with their body from cultural/religious stand-points due to the fact that every women doesn't believe in the same thing.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

Site I used: https://adoptionnetwork.com/adoption-myths-facts/domestic-us-statistics/

I think that Abortion should not be as big of a deal as it is. There are a huge number of reasons why. Like, why is the government outlawing a medical procedure? That is what it is at its heart, a medical procedure. Christianity is a reason for personal belief against it, but religion should not be a reliable argument in law at any point. Like many things, I am in between, I don’t think that abortion should be completely banned, but I also don’t think it should be the main method of birth control, like it should be a later thing you try or it is an expensive procedure. Completely banning it is not the way to go, however. The argument can be made that you are killing a person, but in some cases it wouldn’t matter. Some people are raped, and will end up hating the baby, or they are in a horrible financial situation or broken homes, and won’t be able to care for the baby. The adoption process is not very good at all, and that sometimes is no better than the parent who hates or can’t care for the baby. Raising a child is a difficult and lengthy process, often lasting a lifetime, and children who don’t get what they need end up starving, or getting lost in a never-ending adoption process, or getting stuck in the jail system or debt. According to adoptionnetwork.com, only about half of children in the adoption system get adopted every year. My mother did not have the best childhood, her mom couldn’t care for her very often. She had to go from foster home to foster home to family to family to school to school and so much more. She had bad healthcare, bad relationships, and often people would be surprised at her childhood. She has told me that a few people and experiences were likely the only reason she got as well off as she did. If she took one wrong turn, she would have been in jail or debt and her life would have been miserable for as long as she lived, and she was very lucky. Not everyone is, which is why abortion should be legal, because some lives just aren’t worth living or being forced into.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I agree it shouldn't be completely encouraged as a method of birth control because there are so many better ways to go about it, but it shouldn't be taken away for people who really need it.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I agree that religion should not be a factor in this. Women doing what is healthy for their bodies and lives is what is important and I feel like God would not hold that against any good person.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I don't really care what women do with their bodies so I guess that means I'm pro choice. A fetus to me does not equate to a human in my mind so I cannot relate to those who see the fetus as a child until it is officially out of the woman's body developed. In Jane Roe's case, the child was one she could not afford to have as it was life threatening for her, therefore, instead of needing to have a child grow up in a terrible environment, it would be better to avoid having one at all. In some other cases, some cannot financially support a child, therefore having a child would only be troublesome for both the child's growth as well as the parent's well-being.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

Abortion is a method or practice in which women who have unwanted fetuses, termenate their pregnancy. This method has been widely used across the country by many women. Although this method is highly known, it is a very controversial topic discussed by a variety of groups and/or individuals. Some believe the method to be cruel and unusual, whilst others see it as a convenient choice being offered to females who may not desire to go through with their pregnancies, for whatever reason.

In my opinion, abortion is a choice that should be made by the women or couple that were involved in the intercourse that created the fetus. The choice should not be made or debated by people who had no purpose in the making of the child. Firstly, these people are not aware of the experiences of the women/couple, nor do they understand the circumstances she/they are in. These circumstances/experiences can include low income, abuse, rape, or even religion/family beliefs. I am pro-choice due to the fact that there are so many factors that can go into a big decision such as this. I feel that people do not consider the factors or circumstances that go into this sensitive subject. Usually, significant/life changing choices such as this, include important reasons/concerns for the conclusion to have an abortion.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I believe you should do whatever you feel is best for you. I also feel women should be able to do what they want with their bodies. You never know the reasons behind someone's decisions, they may not be able to afford a baby, or they just are not ready to care for a child, or a variety of other reasons. Research shows that 75% of women who obtain abortions are low-income, with nearly half living below the federal poverty level. Almost 30% of women who get abortions stated that having a kid would interfere with their education or their job, and another 30% said they just simply were not mature enough to care for a child. Why should women have to have a child that they do not want or can not care for to the best of their ability? If abortions become illegal they will just become more unsafe and will not stop. Women should be able to do what they feel is in their best interest with their body and have no one throw their opinion into it.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

Abortion should remain legal because, the government has no right to infringe on individual rights of the pregnant mother. It is an invasion of privacy and at the very least just plain rude to tell a woman what to do with her body. And to those who would argue the same of the baby growing inside of her, I say that that baby does not have rights. It has not been born yet so it cannot have rights as a citizen. It is still a part of the mother's body, so it's her rights that are at question here. It should be the woman’s choice on what she does with her body. No one person or governing body should tell her how to live her life. And if she can't get an abortion, there's no guarantee the child will be better off. If the mother can't abort, or find someone else to care for the child there's only one other option. Adoption and foster care. And both of these things are far from the saving grace that some think they are. A 2017 study states that 12 to 14 percent of adopted children in the United States between the ages of 8 and 18 are diagnosed with a mental health disorder each year, and adopted children are almost twice as likely as children brought up with their biological parents to suffer from mood disorders like anxiety, depression, and behavioral issues. One could argue that the baby would suffer more to live away from its biological family than if it had been aborted. This is why it should be up to the mother to decide what is best for her child. And her decision alone.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

Women should have the right to make decisions for their own body. Pregnancy is not always a woman’s decision, and many different factors can lead to pregnancy. 65 out of 1,000 pregnancies are unintentional. More effective ways to lower abortion rate include providing better ways to help prevent pregnancy. This includes easier access to affordable birth control. Completely outlawing abortion would not stop it. It would just lead to unsafe methods of abortion. Of all abortions, approximately 45% are done unsafely. With stronger restrictions, this percentage will only rise. It is important to consider the factors that go into the decision to have an abortion. Raising a child is very expensive, and even considering adoption, there is a high price to deliver the baby that not everyone can afford. The average cost of giving birth to the baby can range from $5,000 to $11,000 in the United States. If complications lead to a necessary C-section, the delivery can cost up to 14,500. Some women are rape victims and mentally cannot take care of the baby that emerged from that traumatic event. Prior health issues also play a big part in the ability of a woman to have a baby. In some cases, delivering a baby can lead to death for the mother. In other cases, a woman is simply not ready to have a baby. Teen pregnancies become more common and it is important for these woman to continue their education. A teenagers body might not be able to handle the delivery. Some women lack a partner and are afraid to raise the baby with no support. All these factors must be considered before telling a woman what she can or can't do with her own body.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

Personally, I believe that abortion should be available to all women who want it. I do understand that at some point a fetus becomes a baby, but I think people use the term too loosely when it comes to abortion. A lot of the time prolife people want to say a fetus is a baby or it is alive when there is a “heartbeat” when in fact it’s not even a heartbeat its electrical signals passing through the cell. In life, if someone’s heart stops, that does not mean that they are deceased. However, when someone’s brain activity stops, they are declared dead. So why are people saying the heartbeat matters? I do not see abortion as murder as the fetus does not develop signs of life until later in the pregnancy.

Abortion, I feel, should be treated as if its any other kind of health care. It should be treated with as much respect as going into your local pharmacy to get a flu shot. It's an understood fact that not EVERYONE gets a flu shot, but most of the time no one criticizes someone else for getting the shot. They respect that this is something the person wants to do for their body and they let them do so peacefully. If someone is unhappy with or does not trust the flu vaccine, they simply do not get one. Most people that don’t want it don’t try to push their opinion onto others.

Women face a lack of protection everyday, and taking away their abortion rights only makes life more dangerous for them.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

"It should be treated with as much respect as going into your local pharmacy to get a flu shot. It's an understood fact that not EVERYONE gets a flu shot, but most of the time no one criticizes someone else for getting the shot."

I agree, some people don't get flu shots because of religious reasons, health reasons, etc. and people still respect them because its their body, but when it comes to abortions somehow these ideas get lost.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I strongly believe that abortion should be left up to the woman contemplating having one, or already intending to have one. However, many people may argue on the side of "Women have abortions for selfish or frivolous reasons," according to ProChoice.org. I believe that women have abortions for many different reasons, but frivolous wouldn't be the word to describe these reasons. Owing to the fact, people or women in this case come from all walks of life. The reason for stating this is because some women may not want to bring another life into an already dreadful situation. Whether these dreadful situations come from health, or socioeconomic problems. As stated by ProChoice.org, "66% plan to have children when they are older, financially able to provide necessities for them..." In addition to this, it's in a way selfish to bring a child into the world knowing these factors are prevalent in one's life. In avoiding this, having an abortion typically provides the woman a sense of comfort and reassurance that they didn't bring a child into a situation that wasn't fit for a child. As stated by Corinne Rocca, PhD, MPH, even is it was difficult decision to make, majority of women who have had an abortion believe that it was the right decision for them, in the long run.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

Women face a lack of protection everyday, and taking away their abortion rights only makes life more dangerous for them. Everyday women are raped, sexually assaulted, taken into sex trafficking, and more. Taking away a facility that would carefully take care of their abortion will only lead to more unsafe alternatives. The concept of abortion has always been around whether people like it or not. Granted, they were very unsafe and very secretive. Women already have to be so secretive when it comes to their menstruation cycles as if that is something to sexualize or make them feel bad about. Women are often embarrassed of basic human functions and they don’t want to be seen or treated any differently. Women are taught to always take precautions from men, whether it be to cover their drink, go with friends to places, never walk alone at night, always check their car when getting in, the list goes on and on. A woman wanting an abortion could be another case of her having to account for the actions of a man. Though abortions should be granted for women who physically need it, it should also be offered to women who just want it for their own best interests regarding their situation. It is HER own business not some random guy who’s screaming at her that she is a bad person while she’s going into the clinic. What that random guy doesn’t know is that she works 3 jobs, is in an abusive relationship, suffers from several mental illnesses and is not financially stable enough to bear a child and to care for it after roughly 10 months. You wouldn’t know this however as everyone’s privacy should be respected under the 9th amendment.

Oftentimes the people who claim to be “pro life” are people who bring their religion into the mix. Religion is great but in a nation where it was supposed to be based on freedom, its key is to be open minded for other people who may not have the same beliefs. I feel as if these people are so quick to assume the situations of the people that get abortions. They may think it's out of malicious intent or that they are simply being lazy or doing society a disservice. But I feel as if this all goes back to the right of privacy.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I support every word in this. Women have to have their guard up 24/7 and that is looked down on as if it is a woman's issue when in reality it is a man issue. Society tends to bestow women with all of these trial and tribulations that they just have to deal with and no man will ever be able to fully understand that, so when it comes to serious issues about the challenges and choices a woman makes with her a body a man should have little to NO say so.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

"Women already have to be so secretive when it comes to their menstruation cycles as if that is something to sexualize or make them feel bad about." I agree with this, a lot of basic human functions are considered taboo or it is a secretive topic. I think that if we looked from a biological viewpoint the abortion debate in general would be a lot more productive.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

this was my statement from second block lol: I believe that abortion should be illegal to a certain extent. Abortion should be illegal after 28 weeks from conception. To begin, a fetus becomes viable after approximately 24 weeks of gestational age; viability means that a fetus has the ability to survive outside of the womb. According to the “Aid to Women Center,” it says that in the second trimester (13-24 weeks) “the fetus’s body is too large to be broken up by suction and will not pass through the suction tubing easily.” In a second trimester abortion, the cervix has to be dilated even more and can be very dangerous. To add, BCM Women’s Health says that, “Complications of clandestine abortions increase with gestational age.” After the fetus hits the viable gestational age, it not only becomes somewhat unethical, but it can be potentially dangerous to the carrier as well. Given certain circumstances such as rape, not being able to provide proper care for the baby, a hostile womb, or even PTSD from previous pregnancies, having abortions legal until 28 weeks is a long enough time to make the personal decision regarding abortions.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

Ryan G.-

This is very uncomfortable for me. I absolutely hate talking about this. It is such an uncomfortable thing for me. Like I have no strong opinions on either side like it’s just a thing that people do and I’m no authority and I have no opinion. For a lot of people this is huge but to me at this moment in time I’m just in the middle/ I don’t care well. I do it’s a big thing but I don’t care in the sense that it has nothing to do with me therefore I have no real feelings. This type of stuff like the human body and what happens to it on a surgical, child, sexual side all of it makes me uncomfortable. Maybe it’s because I have no connection nor reason to be comfortable but this is the type of thing I avidly avoid because my opinion is neutral and I just don’t like talking about it. I love people and I don’t want to see them in pain therefore I’m neutral because this affects everyone at some point and it’s just a thing that happens and everyone has different opinions.

Against

Immoral

Goes against their religion

Murder, and the process of abortion espicially in a 2 month trimester is cruel

If it’s the 3rd trimester it’s terrible

For

Woman’s body is her own therefore her own decisions

Right to privacy

PTSD if raped and or sexual assualted the child is a daily reminder of it.

Foster System is broken due to parent using it mainly for money from the foster children so would be parents don’t want that for their if kids

Separation of church and state everyone has different religions

Even if banned it could harm way more women than imagined

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

Yes abortion should be legal because its women body they can do whatever they want with their body , also the population of human on earth is quiet big why we need more humans if we can not provide the good facilities to orphans which already living. Some person saying killing of life is not good thing yet we eat around 2 million animals every day . Thus a chicken have less life then a fetus ? also some are arguing that he/she if alive can became next Albert Einstein or Mother Teresa well he/she have more probability of becoming Hitler then Einstein due to harsh condition and lack of love .

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I believe abortion should be legal. It is against the constitution for the federal government to infringe so severely onto the rights of individuals. As decided in Roe v. Wade, a ban on abortion would be an infringement of a person's privacy protected by the 14th Amendment's Due Process Clause. On a personal level, I feel as if it should not be in the government's power to control someone's healthcare decisions, but rather to provide accessible healthcare to everyone in need. There are many cases in which mothers would not be able to take care of a child, why should they be forced to carry a baby they have no intentions or ability to provide for? Maybe the war on abortion should be changed to a war to education people on such topics so if necessary, they are able to make well thought out and informed decisions.

Side: I believe it should be legal
0 points

If I really did define my position on abortion right now then tommorrow I would probably look at it like heresy. My opinion on it depends so greatly on whatever was just said that it’s almost disappointing. Obviously, parents shouldn’t legally be able to kill their baby. Right? Like when I baby is inside someone’s womb it’s the same baby that could come out the next day or-- if it had been borne before its due date-- the week prior. Its position outside of your body when you’re holding it versus one foot away inside your belly should not be the factor between it being a person versus a process that can be aborted. For this reason maybe it would be helpful to imagine the fetus as a baby. Take the fetus outside of the belly, conceptually, and think about when it would be logically okay to take a knife to it. I mean we’re allowed to take a kidney out of our bodies and cut it up and eat it, right? In fact forty-nine of the fifty states have no laws against cannibalism. But-- like-- you could consume your own epidermis, so why not some little blob of your own cells in the middle of your belly. Well you can’t cut up the living breathing child, but it would be pretty insane to state that you can’t cut up a blob of cells. So when do we allow it. Right. I feel like basing it off of some arbitrary heart-starts-beating or could-survive-without-motherly-nutrients bullshit is pretty stupid in a perfect world. In a perfect world we know all of these facts to a T, but none of them really get to the core of the issue. So like, you’ve got a fully functional, walking, talking, breathing… teething robot, right? It’s made of steel and its got a computer for a brain. Can you cut that thing up? Hell yeah, you can unscrew every bolt and writhe in its insides if you’d like. Now throw a sheet of human skin on top of it… still cool, right? Okay, then make its body identical to that of a human’s with lab grown cells’n’shit, but its got a computer brain. Still fine. But a brain is just a computer. It uses little electrical impulses to store and retrieve information. So you make a brain out of flesh and neurons and shit-- but it uses the same methods to function just under a different medium. See my point? That robot-- and I feel most people would agree (unless we’re talking can a robot derive consciousness from logical reason alone)-- would still be pretty okay to kill and, I guess, consume. Well, an abortion’s pretty similar. The robot would only be not okay to dice if it were an actual person who would experience said diceage. If it can’t then it’s the same exact thing as cutting up a ball of copper and silicone and lead and steel, just maybe a bit more intricately designed. I feel like it’s only reasonable to say that the only point in which it’s okay to cut up a baby is once it’s conscious. Conscious and viable are two completely different things, and any justice worth their seat should realize that. But that’s in a perfect world. In a perfect world abortion wouldn’t even be a concept, so we’re obviously not there. We have no clue what consciousness is. Some popular ideas are that an all-powerful human-esque being created a near-infinite universe for a handful of hairless apes to explore one-fucking-septillionth of-- and that’s consciousness (also the most popular theory… somehow); that reason is the ‘language of the universe’ and we happen to be the only creatures capable of ‘speaking’ it-- and speaking it is consciousness (thanks Mr. Thames, stoicism’s pretty cool); or that consciousness is a plane of existence, and using reason pulls down on that plane-- similar to mass pulling on space-time (and that’s the most convincing one, to me, which is saying a lot); you get the point: we’ve got no clue worth basing something as important as abortion off of. So what do we do? We’ve got to figure that out, maybe? Can we? I feel like the closest study to it is philosophy, which is, with all due respect, spitting out baseless concepts on life, reason, and reality until they make some sense at first glance. Maybe we need philosophy 2.0-- philosophy and the scientific process, combined at last. I mean I really don’t think we’ll be figuring it out anytime soon, there’s literally no place to start. What, poke the brain until your finger slips into the consciousness dimension? So what can we do about abortion? I say we stay on the safe side-- god-forbid we spend the next millennia putting babies through torture every few times some pregnant woman wanted to practice unsafe sex-- or some fucked up guy wanted to practice nonconsensual sex. I mean we’re all pretty sure you can’t feel pain or think without functional nerves and neurons, right? Dead people would agree. To me those are the features that would cause a baby to undergo negative emotions if they were to be aborted. So maybe we should do further research into when those parts of the brain begin development, or when those nerves start having a full connection to the brain. If we can’t find a definite point, we should err on the side of caution and ban abortion a little bit before it. Anyhow this is my opinion right now, it’ll probably be different in a few hours, so maybe I’m wrong about this ‘point at which babies would be disposed towards being slaughtered.’ In fact I’m pretty sure I’m probably wrong, this is the point in the discussion where a medical professional’s opinion would be a lot better than mine. Either way I think you get the thought process behind it. The idea for when we should consider it okay: when a baby would prefer not to be dead (obviously this is sarcasm but I hope you do understand what I’m getting at.) There’s always the argument of morals, but I think that’s a very clouded term in this case. Whether killing is okay is a moral issue. Maybe you decide it is okay to cease someone’s experience of life in extreme situations, maybe you don’t. The point is you’re ceasing someone’s experience of life. A little blob of a mother’s cells that is in no way conscious-- I hope we can agree-- is not ceasing someone’s experience of life. If you have a problem with ceasing an entire potential life, then I think you should reconsider. The sperm and eggs inside of every healthy and young individual are direct predecessors to a fully functional man or woman. Fetuses and babies are just intermediate steps between cell and coffin. If you have a problem with ending a life that could happen than you should, if you think it through to any reasonable extent, have a problem with people not putting all of their sperm into all of the eggs in the world before each sperm dies. I know that sounds exaggeratory and rude, but unless you can refute it I’m inclined to think it’s a realistic statement. By not having sex at all times we are ending potential lives. Moral is an ambiguous word, it’s kind of like a religious problem with something but without the part where it’s based on something you believe to be true. By saying you have a moral problem with it you’re saying that at first glance it puts you in discomfort and that you’re going to stick with that assessment without further thought as to its validity. I get it, that’s probably not wholly true, and probably a rude way of putting it, but I think there’re better ways of arguing your point than you have a moral problem with it. That’s like the least powerful form of validation. Also… religion. Listen, I get that you wholeheartedly believe it to be true, and only want good upon the other people of the world by acting based on your religion, but there’re a lot of other people that feel that way for different belief-sets. As a humanity we’ve got to just accept that no one thing that can’t be factually proven, or at least the closest thing circumstantially to it, should be applied to everyone as a whole. Also animals. I mean maybe this detracts from my point and points out some hypocrisy in me, but we’re animals. We kill fucking every fucking thing under the moon. But the second it applies to humans we act like it’s the most sacrilegious thing fucking ever. A fucking fetus is less important to the world, will care fucking infinitely less, has done nothing to contribute to anything, and is uglier and dumber than any living animal under the sun, and has one person that has ever interacted with it in any direct way, and we’re not okay with it going through a little discomfort. I mean I’m no vegetarian but what the hell are we thinking? This is the most self-centered way of any living population conducting itself, yet we have the gall to go and act like our ‘moral’, or ‘religious,’ or ‘logical’ fucking beliefs are at all deserved. We’ve got one perspective on any one issue: a human perspective. The perspective that the human brain comes up with. Yet we’re going to go and decide the fate of everything else with it. Ever fucking heard of science, y’know, where you get more than one viewpoint. Our science is unscientific, because we only look at things through human senses and human thought. Kill all the fucking fetuses for all I care, they’ll go through as much pain from it as any single human/animal on earth goes through in maybe a day. Whatever underlying problem you’ve got with that stance is just some evolutionarily advantageous way of looking at things; it’s self-benefitting in nature. I fucking hate talking about things like abortion. Mr. Thames, I hope you didn’t have to endure the pain of reading this whole thing, maybe then you’d’ve felt more pain than a fetus would fucking feel from its entire future life being stripped away from it: very fucking little.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I am not sure how people do end up doing it but the concept of killing something that could have such potential would not sit right with me. Something I couldn’t comprehend. Even if you yourself cannot care for the baby there are people in the world who can and he/she deserves a chance to make the best of their life not see it end before it starts. 135,000 children are adopted each year so 99.999% of the time there is always a better option than death. Having this ability to create precious life is not something that everyone has and as a firm believer in the bible I simply could not agree with any of the circumstances in which it would be okay to end a life because you simply don’t want to have to deal with it or claim to not financially afford it. I understand the rape point of view and it is a terrible thing that happens to women but what good does it do to end another life because of it. In my viewpoint, and this may seem harsh, but abortion is on the same level as murder no matter what argument you try to make on it, the woman is still deciding to give up and let get destroyed something that could potentially go on to be the next athletic star or rocket scientist. The baby should be considered a person from the first point it is conceived and should deserve equal protection under the law. Furthermore I would ponder the question to think about if the baby makes your life better in the end? Look at the glass half full.

Side: I believe it should be legal
jtaylor23(13) Disputed
1 point

"The baby should be considered a person from the first point it is conceived and should deserve equal protection under the law." Fetuses don't even breathe until the 10th week. There are so many instances where a woman can not have a baby and abortion will be the best way out.

Side: I believe it should be legal
clnorvell22(8) Disputed
1 point

"Fetuses don't even breathe until the 10th week."

People on a ventilator don't breathe either, should they not have protection as well?

Side: I believe it should be legal
Lil-Strapped(3) Disputed
1 point

I disagree. I do not think the baby has rights from the moment it's conceived, but from the moment it's born. While still in the womb, it is a part of the mother and the mother's body. If she or a family member can't care for it, then she will look to either put it up for adoption or abort. Adoption isn't always the better alternative. A lot of children in foster care/adoption have mental issues later in life. Adopted children also have higher suicide rates than those in biological families. Adoptees could suffer more than abortees.

Side: I believe it should be legal
HTHAMES(46) Clarified
1 point

I think if you carried out the idea that life starts at conception and should be legally protected you'd have to be in favor of banning "the pill": https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/drugs/3977-birth-control-the-pill#:~:text=How soon does the pill,months to see true benefits. That measure would apply to 70 million+ U.S. women.

Side: I believe it should be legal
dawsonhall(9) Disputed
1 point

If women are taking the pill then they are understanding that they will potentially be having sexual intercourse in the near future. Birth control options that could stop conception and take the biological debate out of it could be an IUD or a shot. It makes the conception argument invalid because then conception would not be a point to make.

Side: I believe it should be legal
Dayton(7) Disputed
1 point

"135,000 children are adopted each year so 99.999% of the time there is always a better option than death"

This statistic is just wrong. Currently in foster care are 400,000 kids. Of these kids about 52% are likely to be lucky, or unlucky enough, to get to go back to their family. Only 26% get adopted. This leaves an entire quarter of this foster care system unaccounted for. I understand that this viewpoint may be easy for you to comprehend, but the fact of the matter is, it's not easy. In foster care, you are without a mother, a father, siblings, grandparents, etc.. Things such as this is what leads to the significant increase in risk of foster care children obtaining mental and physical health issues. If one can claim that taking an unborn being out of this world is immoral, they must also account for the immoralities of putting them in.

Side: I believe it should be legal
dawsonhall(9) Disputed
1 point

So hypothetically if you went and asked if all of those children in foster care would rather be dead then alive they would state they would rather be dead. While this may be true for very little most would likely cling on to the idea that something good will happen to them one day. There are non profit organizations that are made from the improvement of children's lives who are in foster care. And understanding that mental health is a big point of today's society, there are several outlets children can reach to potentially get through their struggles and I understand it simply does not vanish but if killing them from the start is the solution then I simply will not back that idea. It is just the ethics I have set for myself.

Side: I believe it should be legal
jlwright23(5) Disputed
1 point

" Having this ability to create precious life is not something that everyone has and as a firm believer in the bible I simply could not agree with any of the circumstances in which it would be okay to end a life because you simply don’t want to have to deal with it or claim to not financially afford it." I do understand that it goes against your religion so you don't support it but not everyone has the same views as you. There are cases where children are sexually assaulted or that baby could harm/kill the mother. Women should not have to justify their reasons and banning abortion does not stop abortion

Side: I believe it should be legal
dawsonhall(9) Disputed
1 point

Religious beliefs is just a moral stand point of certain issues but is not the singular point in which I do not back abortion. There are cases of sexually assaulted children but there are also cases in which those babies go to live perfectly normal lives. Women have several rights but understanding it is another's rights that are potentially being violated as well.

Side: I believe it should be legal
kang23(2) Disputed
1 point

I agree that there's a lot of good potential with every child that could be born however that does not mean that they could end up growing up bad. Although 135,000 children are adopted each year, not each and every one is guaranteed to go into a good family. What if the child grows up to be a criminal? As for financially unstable parents, it's most likely that the child would end up growing up struggling to develop in an environment where the parent struggles to even care for his/herself. Some parents may see it's better to spare the potential child from suffering all their lives rather than struggling to stay afloat.

Side: I believe it should be legal
dawsonhall(9) Disputed
1 point

Those are all good points but whose to say the opposite. It's not worth the risk of ending a life just to assume that it will go on to live one of crime and suffering.

Side: I believe it should be legal
madgenius(9) Disputed
1 point

"What if the child grows up to be a criminal" this could be true for any child. For every child there is good and bad potential, not just ones who get aborted. You argue that the child could grow up to be a criminal, but this is an invalid argument because any child could grow up to be a criminal, it has nothing to do with the fact that the child would have potentially been aborted. If they grow up to be a criminal it would be based on the fact that they were raised in a bad environment, not the fact that they might have been aborted. It is taking someones life either way, it doesn't matter what "potential" the child has, the only fact of the matter is that is HAS a potential because it has a LIFE.

Side: I believe it should be legal
lillygrace(4) Disputed
1 point

The average cost of giving birth to the baby can range from $5,000 to $11,000 in the United States. If complications lead to a necessary C-section to protect the baby or the mother, the delivery can cost up to 14,500. Even with adoption as an option, not all women can even afford to give birth to the baby.

Side: I believe it should be legal
WickedSpecia(8) Disputed
1 point

Before the 24 week mark a fetus is considered nonviable. Meaning that if that baby were to be born at that point it would not survive, it would barley be alive to start with. The what if statement that surrounds abortion such as what if the baby becomes a star athlete or rocket scientist, is almost contradictory to the concept of abortion. In the state in which the fetus would be terminated it would be nonviable while the mother is a human with a future. What if that mother could go on to also be an incredible member of society and she was prevented by a baby she can not support? The wondering around what that person could have become applies to many unfortunate circumstances and doesn't prevent things from happening then. So why should it stop a woman from attempting to better her situation?

Side: I believe it should be legal
blahblah2023(5) Disputed
1 point

I believe we should keep religion out of this argument. We all have our freedoms to religion and speech: however cases like these are best when argued over science versus faith. Even if abortion was to be banned: so many women are going to die trying to abort their own baby or end up in serious condition because of trying to abort their own child. And sometimes: money isn't the reason for abortion. Sometimes its health reasons, or genetic reasons. Some women don't have the genetics to give birth, and maybe some women don't want to pass on certain disorders or health defects. Some women's bodies aren't able to support carrying a child(even though we are all taught we should be able to, believe it or not). Imagine your wife finding out that if she gives birth to a child she is going to die- and potentially the baby too. Sometimes abortion isn't based on just MORALS, but the women's health as well.

Side: I believe it should be legal
Dreamer333(5) Disputed
1 point

You make a lot of sharp and hard to argue points in this argument. your right abortion is killing something that could be something amazing. But to be honest, it's just not always logical to have a baby, even dispute the rape angle. I think its important to recognize that people sometimes aren't even capable of giving the child that they probably want to have deep down, a good and caring life. Some people don't have the time, money, or resources to spend on a child. It's not always about what morally, most people would probably agree with if the world was fair, and everybody gets equal chance to take care of their baby. Abortion is horrible for both the baby and the mom. No woman finds joy in having an abortion.

Side: I believe it should be legal
Amb_Arrogant(4) Disputed
1 point

I understand your viewpoint of the value of life and its future potential but that thanks to abortion crime rates have plummeted. These possible kids that parents do not want would have grown up mostly in broken homes, unloved, or in the foster care system, abandoned and suffering. These kids have potential but in the childcare system we have, their future is not cultivated. Also you said 135 thousand children are adopted each year, 400 thousand are put into the system. That is a horrible ratio. Not only is the adoption rate awful but the effect these forced children have on the parents is terrible. The mother has to deal with the physical and mental burden of having a child that I'm pretty sure any male will never understand. You supporting the abortion ban is you supporting the forced pregnancies that lead to mental trauma and physical tolls, the financial burden that the mothers might not be able to carry, and the sacrificing of time to raise a kid, or hey, she deals with the fact she has to give birth to this kid because people said "oh but the kid could cure cancer". Statistically and way more likely, the kid will become a criminal, not a productive member of society. That kid is going to grow up knowing they were put up for adoption and know they were unwanted. The mental toll is so great for the kid and the parents and that is horrible to force onto somebody.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

Abortions should be either severely limited or completely outlawed. I am a teenager, and I am around teenagers all of the time. I am as aware as anyone that teenagers aren’t the best at planning their actions and don’t usually think about the long term ramifications of what they do. I would say that teenagers are the most impulsive people on the planet, but even most teenagers know how to not get pregnant. It's not hard. There are lots of ways to avoid pregnancy and ways to protect yourself against it. How then, do people justify that them getting pregnant isn’t their fault. It is true that there are very rare situations where a woman gets pregnant against her will, but there is no real way to prove it conclusively. To remove a human life from the world due to hearsay seems like a ridiculous decision, no matter how old the person is. Trying to say that a woman getting pregnant isn’t her fault is like saying that if a person jumps into a pit of rattlesnakes, spraining their ankle when they land isn’t their fault. Most people have enough sense to realize that they shouldn’t become inseminated if they don’t want to be pregnant, and there are tons of ways to avoid it, from birth control to contraception to abstinence to just not putting themselves in dangerous situations. Honestly, to remove a life from the world that did nothing wrong because of the actions of its parents is depressing at best and detestable at worst. People seem to forget that once the egg gets a full set of DNA, it is no longer just the woman’s body. Suddenly, a fully new life form is created that also has a right to the protection of its body. A pregnant woman isn’t just a woman, it is a woman with a life living inside of them. The problem of abortion isn’t whether or not the woman has a right to control her body, it is whether or not she has the right to destroy the body of another person that just happens to rely on her to survive.

Side: I believe it should be legal
jtaylor23(13) Disputed
1 point

I just don't get this one line. "It is true that there are very rare situations where a woman gets pregnant against her will, but there is no real way to prove it conclusively." I wouldn't say rape is rare... Also "there are tons of ways to avoid it, from birth control to contraception to abstinence to just not putting themselves in dangerous situations." Women do not purposely put themselves in dangerous situations. No one would just put themselves in a dangerous situation on purpose.

Side: I believe it should be legal
clnorvell22(8) Disputed
1 point

"I wouldn't say rape is rare..."

Only about 1-2% of abortions are obtained because they became pregnant through rape. I would consider 1-2 fairly rare.

Side: I believe it should be legal
Dayton(7) Disputed
1 point

I just have a question. Do you believe in life at conception or birth? Because if you agree with life at conception then they would terminate your stance on preventatives such as plan B and birth control. If you believed in life at birth, however, that would terminate your stance on the unborn's rights. In the 14th amendment it states that rights are given to those born and naturalized in the United States. Though I believe that the words born and naturalized are very concrete, I will provide the fluctuation of belief of life at conception. All I am saying is, is that both can not be present in the same argument.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I am not as completely heartless to outlaw it completely and there really are complications that can happen. Science is way too far behind still to try and define abstract concepts like sentience. Like it’s the after death concept where we can certainly see what happens to our bodies, but is there something like a soul where we pass on to an after life? Who’s to say when we’re fully alive yet when nobody remembers the exact moment they were alive in the womb. Nor will anybody’s definition be concrete yet, if it’s the exact moment we have a heartbeat or brain pulse nobody has a right to say. Another conversation I feel is to not take the father completely out of the equation if he wants to genuinely care for the child as well as possibly adoption should we make that whole system better. After all as it is now the father has to pay child support if he doesn't want the baby yet the mother does, so what about equality there? I truly do believe that there are good reasons to not want a child. But then the internet came and sped everything up to where society can’t handle it. Along with it came such a very many groups. I see women now that see abortion as a thing to play with now if they’ve had three abortions and are laughing about having another one. It really does make my blood boil even if I don’t want to. While I don’t want the few bad apples to ruin it for every women, it can’t be ignored either that there are some who take advantage of it. So depends on the person and the complications where I ethically find it wrong, but it is how society is and there really is some greater good.

Side: I believe it should be legal
1 point

I do agree that the decision should not just be a joke. I think that those people would be a minority in the group of women's view on abortion. I do think most women think that abortion and deciding it is a huge deal, but I don't support women who use abortion as casual birth control. That is why birth control is a thing.

Side: I believe it should be legal