CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
7
Guilty Not guilty
Debate Score:11
Arguments:8
Total Votes:11
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Guilty (3)
 
 Not guilty (5)

Debate Creator

lawnman(1106) pic



Adultery or not Adultery

An Irish man confessed to his priest that he had lain with another man’s wife, but all they did was rub against one another. He then asked his priest if that was adultery, and the priest answered, “Yes, rubbing is the same as putting it in; you have committed adultery.”

The Irishman responded: “What then shall I do for forgiveness?”  

The priest answered: “Say “Hail Mary” ten times and then put $50 dollars into the offering plate.”

And so the Irishman, seeking forgiveness for his sin, did as the priest said.  He lowered his head, rubbed his rosary and shouted obeisance to Mary ten times. He then arose, withdrew $50 from his pocket and proceeded to the exit of the sanctuary. And while exiting the sanctuary, he paused, rubbed the $50 against the offering plate and placed the money back into his pocket. Then afterwards, while he was walking through the double doors, the priest shouted, “Hey, you did not put the money into the offering plate!”.  The Irishman replied:

“What, you told me that rubbing was the same thing as putting it in!”

Now, apart from the joke, is the Irishman guilty of adultery?

Guilty

Side Score: 4
VS.

Not guilty

Side Score: 7
2 points

Guilty as charged.

Adultery is essentially betraying your partner and acting upon lust. Unable to overcome temptation.

It's not whether or not you 'technically had intercourse'. It's participating in sexual activities that counts.

There will be people who say it's not technically adultery. Let's face it. It is.

Side: GUILTY
brycer2012(1002) Disputed
1 point

It's not technically adultery...

Adultery is when you have sex with someone other than your spouse. Sex is when you actually go in. Therefore, he didn't commit a crime. ;)

Side: Not guilty
2 points

Would her husband have the same opinion? Or does he have just grounds to accuse both his wife and Irishman of adultery?

Side: GUILTY
Kinda(1649) Disputed
1 point

Did you read what I just wrote or were you too busy playing with yourself...........

....or laughing at JC's post?

Side: GUILTY

Sex is just a more inconvenient, messy, time consuming way of shaking hands and saying, "How ya doing?" ;)

Side: Not guilty
1 point

Haven't made me lol like that in ages.

Just had the perfect picture when I read that.

Side: GUILTY