Debate Info

agree your list is wrong
Debate Score:14
Total Votes:15
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 agree (1)
 your list is wrong (4)

Debate Creator

WankJuicer(43) pic

All 10 currently released Star Wars films ranked

10: Solo
It was a steaming pile of severed whale bollocks.

9: Rogue One
It was ok.

8: The Last Jedi
It was poorly executed but it was interesting.

7: Force Awakens
It was good but too similar to a new hope.

6: Return of the Jedi
The end was particularly cool and it has the same classic Star Wars material but at the same time you could tell Lucas' creative juices where running out in many aspects of the film.

5: Phantom Menace
It was good except for the corny shit

4: A New Hope
Classic and original

3:Empire strikes back
It was honestly great and defined SW just as much as episode 4.

2: Attack of the Clones
A lot of people don't understand how intricately designed the plot was and it is the second best in terms of action.

1: Revenge of the Sith
Hands down the best SW film. It is probably one of the top 5 movies in human history.


Side Score: 1

your list is wrong

Side Score: 13

You're mentally insane. Return of the Jedi was thr best one.

Side: agree
2 points

I know your list is wrong when you put Revenge of the Sith and Attack of the Clones as the top two, then said Phantom Menace was good.

Side: your list is wrong
9 points

I agree with MintTea, and the OP is a deranged lunatic.

Side: your list is wrong

Hands down the best SW film. It is probably one of the top 5 movies in human history.

You are a crack addict.

Side: your list is wrong
1 point

You make me sick.

I haven't actually seen Solo yet, but the other nine, from best to worst:

1. Empire Strikes Sack; easily the greatest sequel in movie history and near flawless in every respect, 9.5/10

2. New Hope; just a classic story, 8.5/10

3. Force awakens; it did steal a lot from the original film, but all in all a good experience, 7/10

4. Return of the Jedi, Ewoks ruined star wars and much of the film was dull, but the duel at the end was good enough to salvage this movie for me, 6.9/10

5. Last Jedi, better than I expected, but not very compelling. I've forgotten most of it already. The casino scene in the middle was horrible. 6.75/10

6. Attack of the clones; it did alright I guess, Dooku was underdeveloped, if he'd had a presence in the previous film he could have been quite interesting. Obi wan was the saving grace of this movie and the other prequels. 6.5/10

7. Revenge of the Sith; there were at least 5 light-saber duels in this movie, which was ridiculous. Again, Grevious was underdeveloped. Barely a 6/10

8. Rogue one. Just boring. Characters were all awful. A couple good Vader scenes, but that's it. 6/10

9. Phantom menace. Jar Jar Binks plagues my nightmares. Enough said. 5/10

Side: your list is wrong
Mint_tea(4382) Clarified
1 point

I agree with most of this but I'd say 7 and 8 need to be switched. Rogue one was boring but I liked the characters better.

Side: agree