CreateDebate


Debate Info

17
11
Good Bad
Debate Score:28
Arguments:19
Total Votes:38
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Good (12)
 
 Bad (7)

Debate Creator

TERMINATOR(6781) pic



Animal Rights.

Should animals have as many, or nearly as many, rights as humans?

Good

Side Score: 17
VS.

Bad

Side Score: 11
3 points

Animals fell pain and the way humans are treating them is inhumane. Apparently the little amount of animal rights we have now are not enough. We need to do more. Some animals are proven to be of equal to or close to humans intelligence so shouldn't they have the same rights. Arguing that others don't doesn't stop that they do. Should they lose out on rights because others aren't at there intelligence level yet.

Side: Good
2 points

By giving animals rights you dont give them the same rights as humans but different rights just to protect there well being. They cant speak for themselves!

Side: Good
1 point

I say...Yes, animals should be granted animal rights because they are creatures that live on this world, not only us. Don't we forget we are animals too, in a higher level than them. They constitute also with world balance. Without them how would the world live? If we are the highest form of animals, why would we abuse them? The problem is with the people..abusive people lurking everywhere. Why do they intend to kill animals? They are lower level than us. It looks your the fool, exchanging your money with a smaller amount of money. Your money won't be a whole without your centavo. It's like we wouldn't be in this world without the help of animals!

Side: Good
1 point

it helps scientists make a new discoveries actually in medicine. We are living in quickly development world and people are meeting new illnesses every year and sometimes preparation is not helpful. In this case scientists are researching ways to try treating illnesses as a cancer – disease before what scientists are still powerless. . Anyway I against when testing comes to beauty, trying to see if your make-up will cause an allergic reaction , I think its foolish to harm an animal for that purpose, I saw how they make testing perfume, detergent on animals; they do it without any anesthesia and animals feel a powerful pain and is horrible and shouldn't be done ever! Testing must be for a good reason like finding a cure for cancer and all kinds of different diseases or illnesses

Side: Good
1 point

Human are also animals. But in different features and species. Human also are more developed and more intelligent than some of other animal species. But we depends on them. Without these animals will medicine be invented? Without them will we know that human has close genetic between chimps or apes? Without them will 'Dogs and Cat' and other movies be created?

For sure the answer would be no. Human can live and stand on our own because of these animals. But people still treat them horribly. Kill them for skin, fur, head or for only some of their parts.

We should gave them rights to the animals for people to become more afraid of them so lesser animals will be harm and also give them chance to developed their own species to become more intelligent and can cope with the environment which are changing everyday.

Side: Good
1 point

Humans are animals. It's time we got rid of this superiority complex.

Side: Good
1 point

Of course they should. We are all sentient. We all have beating hearts, functioning brains and breathe the same air. We are all earthlings.

Side: Good

Absolutely. Animals can feel pain, depression, loneliness, starvation, and neglected. They shouldn't be able to be mistreated just because they can't say their hurt. They shouldn't be hid away in a small space, isolated, just because they can't say they are uncomfortable or lonely. Just because a being can't talk, doesn't mean it doesn't have feeling.

Side: Good
1 point

humans and animals all come in the same kingdom.. so everybody should have equal rights :)

Side: Good

Animals should be protected from any cruelty administered to them.

Side: Good
0 points

why should animals be treated differently than humans? they feel pain like humans. just because they are different doesn't mean they should be treated inhumanely.

Side: Good
2 points

Considering having 'as many, or nearly as many' rights as humans would give animals the right to vote, enroll in school, get married, take a driver's test, and so on, I would say no. They're not capable of understanding the privileges or responsibilities attached to those. I also don't think they are capable of suffering from the absence of these rights.

But I do think they should be afforded rights that prevent the types of suffering they are capable of. For instance, if an animal is capable of suffering if it is kept in too small a space, then it should not be kept in too small a space. If an animal is capable of suffering if it kept alone, then it should not be kept alone. If an animal is capable of suffering without adequate mental stimulation, then it should not be deprived of adequate mental stimulation.

Side: Bad

Ehhhh... I don't know. We do need the meat for our strength and health. Besides, I bet we will all eat them without the police noticing.

Side: Bad

No, animals are animals. If animals are granted rights as humans, who is going to representative the monkey for killing the human, his counterpart the lion or maybe the buffalo.

Side: Bad
1 point

Animals are not equal. By brining animals to our level we are making an unjust rule for humans by stating they can no longer use animals for utalitarin puproses period!

Side: Bad
1 point

When I am hungry, they have no rights.

As the Hulk famously, and rightly said: "Don't make me [hungry], you won't like me when I'm [hungry]"

Side: Bad
0 points

It is a part of nature and evolution for the most powerful species of animal to dominate the lower species. We are that most powerful species... to give them the same rights as us, in a way, is to actually treat them unfairly. What's fair is that we got to where we are through honest mutation. I'm sure we'll start treating animals with the same 'rights' as us once they get to where we are through honest mutation.

Side: Bad
0 points

but that doesn't mean they should be physically abused .....................................................................

Side: Good
chatturgha(1631) Disputed
1 point

They shouldn't, you're right. That's not animal rights though. That's just you refusing to be a sadist.

Side: Bad