CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:22
Arguments:20
Total Votes:23
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Archaeologists find Jesus's Cross in Turkey. Your thoughts on this? (18)

Debate Creator

Srom(12206) pic



Archaeologists find Jesus's Cross in Turkey. Your thoughts on this?

Add New Argument
2 points

I've never had issue with the person of Jesus existing, and if they actually found proof that he did that would be snazzy. Once we find an old bottle of his wine and we can start talking about the possibility that he had magic powers.

Even if this was the cross of Jesus Christ it does not help prove his works and miracles. That is what many people are yearning to find. Many people accept the existence of Jesus, but they doubt he had any special "capabilities".

lolzors93(3225) Disputed
2 points

Oh, but it does prove a lot. Why do I say this? Because the Romans have recorded historical documents of Jesus being seen after His supposed death. That is why many believed that He never died. So if we have proof that He did die on the cross, then we have established that He did rise from the dead.

2 points

In a practical sense it does not. Many people have reported seeing Elvis Presley (after death of course). Proof that he died on the cross does not prove a miracle to be true in any sense especially since the miracle itself has not been proven. Writting something down is one thing. Proving the miracle occured is another. Unless you wishing to provide me with non scriptural or literary works of Jesus' revival I do not with to hear any more senseless talk.

trumpet_guy(503) Clarified
1 point

Then why else would the thousands of Jews convert to following Christ if he hadn't performed miracles prove who he said he was? Both the person Jesus and the conversions are recorded in history.

1 point

Well then it disproves all the " I have a piece of the cross relic" bullshits I've hear. it also disproves all the other cross finds there's been, all the other testaments that say what happened to the cross e.t.c. Are we supposed to completely disregard this just because they found another cross??

How do we know it isn't just a practical joke by some guy in the middle ages? How do we know it isn't just some randomers cross? Crucifixions were very common back then..!

A load of unbelievable bullshit if you ask me.

1 point

If you piece together all the fragments of cross there supposedly are, you'd have enough to build Noah's ark.

1 point

If you piece together all the fragments of cross there supposedly are, you'd have enough to build Noah's ark. Not like that ever existed either..!

Jungelson(3959) Clarified
1 point

Oops, my edit went wrong..!

1 point

There are millions of so called cross fragments.

1 point

Right. But like I found this really old spaghetti sauce and so obviously the only explanation is the Flying Spaghetti monster pooped it.

I mean, what other possible explanation for old spaghetti sauce could there be?

Certainly no more explanations than where a piece of fucking wood might have come from.