CreateDebate


Debate Info

5
4
No. Yes.
Debate Score:9
Arguments:7
Total Votes:11
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 No. (4)
 
 Yes. (2)

Debate Creator

Sitar(3680) pic



Are Republicans truely prolife?

No.

Side Score: 5
VS.

Yes.

Side Score: 4
2 points

Hello S:

Nahhh... To me, pro life means ALL life, not just the pre-born.. Pro lifers don't give a shit about life AFTER a baby is born..

excon

Side: No.
1 point

Absolutely NOT! Once you pass through the birth canal, you are ON YOUR OWN! And .... you OWE them and their "contributors" for the RIGHT to live. You don't pay up, you can die! You get a disease, you can die! You get paralyzed, you can die! You can't afford enough education to support yourself in their "profit taking world", you can die. You get pregnant and unable, for some reason to carry, you can die!

(Opening purposely left for FW).

Nope, once you take a breath, you're a lazy liberal until you get a job, or can continue ripping people off with your daddy's money ... then you can join their "prolife" group.

Side: No.
1 point

The short answer is that it depends on which Republican and whose life.

If by prolife you mean against killing anybody ever, the answer is no.

If by prolife you mean in favor of people in general being alive, then answer is yes.

The long answer follows.

First, NEITHER the Republican nor the Democrat party is composed of all war hawks or doves regarding any war. Both parties favor killing people in war as a part of the package of diplomatic realities.

Bear in mind that there has always been a big difference between what various voters who identify as Republicans (or Democrats) believe and what the "Party Leadership" and the politicians declare to be the party platform, especially regarding issues like abortion and the death penalty.

For example, close to half of the Republicans I have ever known are fine with abortions prior to 20 weeks, and think that the choice should be left to the mother, without government interference.

By the same token, at least half of the Republicans I know are against the death penalty.

This obviously does not address the conflict between the positions regarding the death penalty and abortion. The inconsistency of both parties in their valuation of life has always bothered me as philosophically untenable.

Side: No.
1 point

Abortion debates created by Sitar:

• Are Republicans truely prolife?

• Let me give you some analogies to call prolife Republicans.

• No Banning: Do Democrats ever favor restrictions on abortion? I do. Last resort only.

• An open letter to FromWithin regarding abortion.

• Should abortion be safe legal, and rare?

• Should abortion be abolished?

• Abortion for rape victims.

• Not one proabort has any shame.

• Does Plan B cause abortion?

• Prolife or prochoice?

• Is the fetus a human being?

• Should prolifers be allowed to show dead baby pictures?

• The government should force proabortion women to have their tubes removed.

• When does pregnancy begin?

• This is what proaborts support.

• It is hypocritical for proaborts to oppose the death penalty.

• Liberals support rape culture when they allow a 1rst degree rapist to live, but not a baby

• Usecontraception or don't have sex. Abortion is MURDER!

• I am antiabortion, not prolife.

• Should abortion be safe, legal, and rare?

• When does pregnancy begin?

• Is prochoice proabortion?

• Life begins when the baby has brainwaves.

• A zygote is not a baby with rights.Abortion for medical reasons is justifiable homicide.

• Should abortion be allowed for the health of the mother?

• My position on abortion.

• Contraception doesn't cause abortion. DUH!

• Have you ever noticed that alleged prolifers care more about the fetus than born humans?

• Is forced birth violence against women?

• Should abortion be legal for any reason?

• Can I be personally opposed to, but prochoice about abortion?

• What do you think about the concept that life begins when the fetus has brainwaves?

• Abortion is murder unless there is a valid medical reason.

• Is abortion child abuse?

• Unborn women also have the right to choose.

• Do all females have the right to choose what to with their bodies?

• Dear prochoicers, what would it take for you to be prolife?

• Real feminists support the unborn woman's right to choose.

• Can liberals be prolife?

• Are you prolife or prochoice?

• I am a prolife liberal.

• Sitara's ethics series: Mental illness and abortion.

• Is abortion murder unless there is a valid medical reason?

• Under what circumstances should abortion be allowed?

• Is abortion ever justified?

• Should abortion be safe, legal, annd rare?

• Is abortion a black or white issue?

• Abortion: Do you have to pick a side?

• I am neither prochoice nor prolife.

• Am I prolife or prochoice?

• If abortion was a number.

• When does life begin?

• Should it be legal to kill a 20 week fetus?

• When does the human fetus have brainwaves?

• What do you think about the opinion that life begins when the fetus has brainwaves?

• Are you prolife or prochoice?

• Can someone oppose abortion without using religion?

• Do I have to agree with abortion to be prochoice?

• Have both sides of the abortion debate gone wrong?

• Can I be prolife and prochoice?

• When will "prolifers" admit that they are really just forced birthers?

• When does life begin?

• What do you think of the belief that life begins with the first brainwaves?

• Do I have to believe that a zygote is a baby to be prolife?

• When does the human fetus have brain waves?

• Everyone who is prochoice has already been born.

• Are you prolife or prochoice?

• Abortion is the worst form of age discrimination.

• Does the proabortion activists respect the unborn child's right to choose?

• Is the organism in this picture a person with rights?

• Do you have to be prochoice to support Planned Parenthood?

• Does epigenetics prove that life begins at birth?

• Can libertarians be prolife.

• Saying that libertarians can't be prolife is the no true Scotsman fallacy.

• Can libertarians be prolife

• Can liberals be prolife?

• Is prochoice proabortion?

• Does hormonal contraception cause abortion?

• Can liberals be prolife?

• When does life begin?

Side: Yes.
Sitar(3680) Disputed
1 point

You don't have the right to my debates if you want to ban me from yours. Permabanned, you cunt.

Side: No.
Atrag(5666) Clarified Banned
1 point

He has never made a debate crazy lady:

http://www.createdebate.com/user/viewprofile/FromWithnBot

Side: No.
1 point

• Democrats support no restriction abortions!

• ...but her emails!

• Hogwash!

• Jesus loves you...you're going to burn in hell!

• You fools!

• You spew lies and deception as always!

• Anti-Christian bigots!

• Republicans can do no wrong!

• Democrats can do no right!

• I masturbate to Donald Trump!

• I like to talk to myself as NowASaint.

• Banned!

-FromWithin

--------------------------

• I'm the ultimate troll!

• Check out how I trolled so-in-so!

• Aren't I cool for having no life.

• I live in my mom's basement.

-Brontoraptor, Prodigee, Outlaw60

--------------------------

• All of your answers can be found by clicking on this link to my website.

• Commas are from the devil.....so I use...elipsis instead. . ..I love them so much...I just randomly...insert them into my sentences..

-Dadman

Side: Yes.