CreateDebate


Debate Info

58
60
books computers
Debate Score:118
Arguments:31
Total Votes:128
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 books (15)
 
 computers (16)

Debate Creator

MohamedAli(78) pic



Are books or computers better for learning?

books

Side Score: 58
VS.

computers

Side Score: 60
8 points

Books are better for deep focus and concentration. You don't get as distracted when reading a book as when you read something on a computer. Computers are good for doing broad searches. Sometimes I have found myself hyper linking around Wikipedia articles, doing random searches so that I may find something interesting to read.

On YouTube I can find lectures from world class teachers, I can download entire books on everything from physics to WW2 in .pdf format. The availability of primary sources is however, not the greatest strength of the internet; commentaries are literally permeating the entire structure of the internet. The amount of opinions and perceptions you can find on the internet is almost overwhelming.

But I have to concede that I always learn best when I am deeply concentrated. I might find lots and lots of things I can look at on the internet, but for me personally, this grandiose diversity of the internet is the biggest problem of the internet. There's always something related, that I may read in order to more fully understand what I am reading now. There's always the temptation to move on, find a different source. I become impatient with what I am reading much more quickly than when I am reading a book.

So learning while on the internet, for me, requires active restraint. I don't find it easy to delve into what I am reading. I do learn my best when I am concentrated; it doesn't stick if I am not. So despite all the obvious advantages of computers and the internet, I still prefer books.

Side: books
6 points

Books are ten time better in my opinion.

Please don't get me wrong the internet has helped many people, but nothing beats getting a brand new book or a really old one a flicking through the pages. A vast collection of works and words my god the words that you can find just by picking up an old book!

Side: books
6 points

it might take a longer while to find something very specific, but while you're at it, you learn a bunch of other stuff which can't hurt at all.

Side: books
DrawFour(2662) Disputed
5 points

Your argument is that you can learn more by accident, in the limited pages of books?

Do you see how that's a better argument in favor of computers and by way of them, the internet, with it's vast collection of articles, sites, quotes, pictures, etc that you could also look to while in search of the information you originally desired.

I know I've personally gotten side tracked while searching one thing and learned tons more than I expected to just googling something as simple as some song lyrics.

Side: computers
mitgag(1652) Disputed
2 points

Do you see how that's a better argument in favor of computers and by way of them, the internet, with it's vast collection of articles, sites, quotes, pictures, etc that you could also look to while in search of the information you originally desired.

and wasn't all the information on the internet initiially taken from a set of books and manuscripts?

I know I've personally gotten side tracked while searching one thing and learned tons more than I expected to just googling something as simple as some song lyrics.

agreeably. but you will also realise you've not learnt a tonne of other things which you could have while reading a book.

besides this, the internet can be misleading. there's so much information on it that may or may not do you good.

a book, whereas, will only speak on a specific topic and articles related to it.

Side: books
6 points

I prefer books for learning things. If I want to take a break from my electronics and had enough of it for the day, I would want to read from a book and not from a computer. I don't really learn all that much when I'm on the computer, only if it's something of my own interest.

Side: books
5 points

In my opinion books are the best way to learn any thing !

Side: books
5 points

i think that book is better than computer

to make your brain better

Side: books
MohamedAli(78) Disputed
1 point

I am agree with you :)

your thinking is same to me in this point

Side: computers
1 point

I say books because at my school out math program is ran online. I hate it. They let you owe at you "own" pace but if you fall behind because you are struggling you still get kicked out of sports even if you have a good grade. It also allows you to take a quiz up to four times to pass and you have to pass with an eighty or better to move on. The video to explain the math is time consuming and confusing. I enjoy the book because I can simply read how to do the problem them do them. This forces me to memorize how to do the problem when my current math class gives calculators and notes to use on every test. I struggle through more now then when I worked out of a book. Hand me a five hundred to a thousand page book and it will be read in one day. Have me listen to a horrible video with many mistakes and I will procrastinate. Honestly a book help with memory because you not only see the words but many people will refer back to them for help causing them to remember the words better then if they just see a video how to and then attempt to solve the problem without a reference sheet. The notes only go so far and they leave out formulas that could have been memorized if you had read them out of a book.

Side: books
1 point

When reading books you will focus but when using the computer sometimes you get tempted to play a game or go on Youtube. Though, computer give you answers in a click. But for books you have to go through many books to find a certain thing. Overall, they are both good but I prefer books.

Side: books
5 points

computers are better than books because it gives us all the info which are not available in books

Side: computers
MohamedAli(78) Disputed
4 points

but there are many cons in using computer

lika harm your eyes .....

Side: books
DrawFour(2662) Disputed
5 points

Ever heard that reading in the dark harms your eyes?

Sounds like the two are even.

Side: computers

Computers, because they include the overwhelming majority of books, including many of those that are no longer in circulation.

These range from published e-books, to scanned books, to ones that have been transcribed by hand.

If you can find it in a library, you can most likely find it on the internet. If you can't find it on the internet, it most likely only exists in private collections, if at all.

Side: computers
auyeungyat(72) Disputed
6 points

But with the addition of the disadvantages of using computers to learn,

some setbacks which have been identified by us are like:sore eyes,shortsighted,etc...

Side: books
5 points

Old news- those issues were specifically linked to the flickering present in CRT Televisions and Computer Monitors. Modern LCD/LED/Plasma Displays does not have the same issue- though they can still cause eyestrain when the display is the only source of illumination.

Side: computers
5 points

Computers. Just remember to block all porn,gaming,and social networking sites and your good to go.

Side: computers
MohamedAli(78) Disputed
3 points

but if you used it too much it can harm your eyes and effect on you body

Side: books
Kenleyso(234) Disputed
4 points

Only if its too bright and you don't take a break using it. Also some people might find learning better by watching a video about it rather than reading it. If they find it easier reading it than they can just simply download an Ebook about the topic.

Side: computers
4 points

With a computer, you can do almost anything. Literally.

Side: computers
MohamedAli(78) Disputed
3 points

but the book can improve your thinking !!

and support your level in studying

Side: books
Jace(5222) Disputed
4 points

So can the computer.

Side: computers
4 points

I think it has to be computers and, to be honest, I don't think there's really much room for debate. Maybe that's a bit of a strong statement, and I suppose I could be wrong, but I just can't think of any benefit specific to books that cannot also be applied to modern computers, and no disadvantage specific to modern computers that cannot also be applied to books.

Eye strain? Shouldn't be an issue on a properly calibrated and positioned monitor. Sure, if you spend like 8 non-stop hours at a time staring at small text, you will certainly experience eye strain. But, the same is true with a book printed in small print, read for hours at a time in less than optimal lighting conditions. Use a well calibrated monitor and take occasional breaks and you'll have no issues here. Most modern browsers even allow you to zoom in when reading documents with smaller print. I could make it so I could read the arguments on this page from across the room if I wanted to.

Ability to stay focused? I think this depends largly on the user. I know that, for myself, I find books to be a much more intimate and enjoyable experience when it comes to something like a novel for sure. My imagination tends to get more deeply involved when reading a good novel on paper than it ever does when listening to an audio book, or just reading the text on a screen. But this is just for entertainment purposes. I find I have no such issues when I'm in "learning mode."

Let me give a specific example of why I feel the modern computer is the superior learning medium.

First, let me make it clear that I am no mechanic, and I'm most certainly not a "car guy." I'm not mechanically incompetent by any means, but I don't have much experience in the field at all. Anyway, I was recently approaching the mileage on my vehicle in which a Timing Belt change was recommended. This procedure on this particular vehicle can be very involved, takes quite a bit of time, even for a professional, and can easily cost upwards of $800 USD to have done.

I could have purchased a Haynes or Chilton repair manual and maybe worked up enough confidence to attempt the procedure myself. But I'm not sure information from a single source would have been sufficient to overcome my apprehension. Enter: the internet.

With my computer, I was able to access many, many sources of information concerning the procedure. From the factory repair manual, to various car forums where I could hear from and speak directly to others knowledgeable in the procedure, to actual step-by-step videos detailing the process. And it's not just the vast amount of information I was able to access that's so significant; but rather, it was the sheer ease and convenience with which it was available and accessible.

Armed with this much detailed information from a multitude of sources, I was confident enough to make the attempt myself. I borrowed a few tools, and spent a whole Saturday, and was able to successfully change not only the timing belt, but also the tensioner, the water pump, and all of the engine mounts. Saved nearly a thousand bucks, and felt a sense of accomplishment and pride as well as being personally enriched by the process.

That's just a recent personal example. I've heard of others who have done far greater things utilizing the modern accessibility of information the internet provides.

Side: computers
4 points

computer is better because from it we find more and more information than books.....For getting information,we need only one computer than a lots of books...it is also wastage of money...

Side: computers
3 points

These sides are not exclusive. A computer could include trillions of books, and with internet connection, easily will.

Also the idea of learning is too vague. People learn in different ways, look for different information, or use parts of the same information. Using a computer one could quickly search for the book on the subject they wish to learn about, or they could look for just the phrase pertaining to the bit of information they require.

Side: computers

I believe that a proper balance of books and internet sources is the best way. Why choose one when you have both at your disposal. However, while books may have their own specific advantages, the internet offers a larger variety of information in a quicker, easier, more convenient way.

Side: computers