CreateDebate


Debate Info

6
7
Yes No
Debate Score:13
Arguments:14
Total Votes:17
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (5)
 
 No (8)

Debate Creator

shattermike(9) pic



Are women stronger than men?

Try to do this scientifically, try to find proof for your argument.

Yes

Side Score: 6
VS.

No

Side Score: 7
marcusmoon(576) Clarified
1 point

Hello, G.

It depends on the woman, and the man.

Obviously this is true.

However, what I think matters more is what sort of strength we are talking about.

Physical Strength

Physically, men are generally stronger. The extreme difference in natural muscle mass is a result of the extra testosterone.

That is why we have the prohibitions against men hitting women in Western society. We all saw the video of Ray Rice's fiancée hitting him repeatedly, but he was at fault when he finally hit her back because men are generally so much stronger physically than women.

Physical Courage

Generally, men are more willing to do physically dangerous things. Again, this is a result of the extra testosterone that increases the tendency toward aggression, ''rambunctiousness" and recklessness.

Most dangerous occupations are dominated by men. This is not a function of women being shut out of these occupations, but of there being so few women (compared to men) who want to do them. That is why men account for over 90% of workplace fatalities.

Social Strength

In general, women are much higher in agreeableness than are men. This makes it much easier to create and maintain social relationships. By the same token, women are naturally (biologically) more oriented toward people, (whereas men are more oriented toward things.)

This contributes to increased ability to successfully engage in socially challenging cooperative behaviors. It has also been correlated to longer life expectancy.

Emotional Strength

This is another weird one.

The corpus colostrum (which connects the hemispheres of the brain) is narrower in men than in women, which better enables men to compartmentalize our thinking. This means that in general, men are better able to focus our attention on the problem at hand, and literally forget everything else, including grave personal problems. This also means men are better able to obsess on the emotional issues.

Women have almost double the incidence of depression. In addition to this, women's hormone levels fluctuate to a greater degree than those of men, not just on a monthly basis, but over a lifetime, including pregnancy, post-partum depression, and menopause.

However, the male suicide rates are between 3 and 5 times that of female rates (depending on location).

Personally, I would count this as a win for women, but the depression rates make for a fair counter argument.

Pregnancy

I have heard women say, "If men had to give birth, the human race would die off because men could not handle crapping a watermelon."

Shows like Jackass and Ridiculousness demonstrate that to be an underestimation of the pain men would endure. We can look at all the hard, dangerous, and painful things men do (often for no reason other than that they are hard, dangerous, and painful) and know that giving birth would be no different.

Steve-O would dare Johnny Knoxville to have a kid by natural child birth, and we would be off and running.

Pregnancy, however is a completely different story. Pregnancy is among the most physically damaging experiences available to people during the course of a normal life.

It is obviously physically uncomfortable to have some little kid dancing on your bladder and kicking you in the lungs.

Add to that all the crap you cannot do, (smoke, drink, get out of a soft couch during the last trimester, etc.) I think most men would say screw it.

Side: Yes
chipcore2(12) Banned
0 points

men are strongr with the arms but wmen have legs so move those legs darlings oh yess

Side: Yes
chipcore2(12) Banned
0 points

wemen may be slightly weaker atleast we can threten and thats wy we are stronger mentaly

Side: Yes
Daegonius(329) Disputed
1 point

Women have lower IQs on average and very few women are in the "genius" category.

Side: No
1 point

Every world record in strength and speed for men is more than the same records for women.

Side: No
1 point

Clearly if they were stronger, the feminists wouldn't be bitching about the patriarchy.

You know, unless they were power hungry sadists or something.

Side: No
chipcore2(12) Disputed Banned
1 point

brah im a sadist so deal with it and atleast we mature faster than you ok

Side: Yes
1 point

Women are not stronger, just meaner. Fifty characters are not required to express this fact...................................

Side: No
Daegonius(329) Disputed
2 points

Women are not meaner, they can be mean but they can also be much nicer and more compassionate. There is a reason you can trust more women than men when it comes to children, men are more likely to rape their butt hole or leave them in a dark alley full of heroin needles.

Side: Yes
1 point

It depends, but usually, its the man, and no, I'm not saying women can't be strong.

Side: No
1 point

In general, men are physically stronger. It think the gap is closing a bit, but men are still on average, stronger than women. But it depends. These are just generalisations. If you picked ten men at random and ten women at random, and paired one to the other, I'm sure a few of the women would be stronger than their partners in the test.

Side: No
1 point

Age, nutrition, fitness, their upbringing and other factors also contribute a lot. An average, fit 20 year-old woman with a good diet, would probably be stronger than the average 70 year-old man for instance.

Side: No