CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
8
Agree Disagree
Debate Score:11
Arguments:12
Total Votes:12
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Agree (2)
 
 Disagree (7)

Debate Creator

DrawFour(2662) pic



Arming Students As Early As Primary School Agree or Disagree

While laxing outon some youtube videos that just make you say "why do humans exist" I stumbled across this gem from The Young Turks, of an 11 yeard old child who was given a gun to take to school for his protection.

I won't voice my opinion in favor of impartialness but I will offer two potential defenses that may be disputed.

Agree

Side Score: 3
VS.

Disagree

Side Score: 8
2 points

If more children were armed, kidnappings would decrease, since kidnappers would fear being shot.

Side: Agree

This is on my list with abortion, because there are two very equal valid sides to this debate. But I will say I agree only because I was raised around guns. I new what they did and how they did it. Times have changed though, and kids are so consumed with video games they often don't even go out side anymore. I can remember as young as 7 going target shooting, learning how to hold a gun the right way, not to point at anything I don't plan to shoot and kill. How to clean a gun, how to dislodge a bullet if need be. .

But then we are talking about kids "today" and we'll I just don't think that to many people in the city do allot of hunting and taking the time to show there kids what a gun can do and that we should respect them. It is not a toy. If all kids grew up like me, we would have a safe country.

Side: Agree
2 points

Giving kids guns? No, that's generally a bad idea. It'd get stolen in a cinch. Considering the extremely narrow likelihood of a shooting happening in any given public or private school (1 in 100,000?), kids bringing guns would probably cause shootings to happen where they otherwise wouldn't, and we'd have a much bigger problem on our hands

If we're talking about arming them with pepper spray, I can understand that. My county code of conduct (and I believe the entire district) allows students to carry a 2 oz container of pepper spray. Nothing stops sexual harassment like a good bottle of mace. It's also a decent repellent against kidnapping, although I would not call it surefire.

Side: Disagree
1 point

They are not mature enough to handle the responsibility, and don't fully understand the repercussions of using the weapon.

Side: Disagree

I am all for guns rights for adults, but minors should not be able to use guns because they dont understand responsibility yet.

Side: Disagree
Stickers(1037) Clarified
2 points

You do realize that nothing magical happens at the age of 18, and it only exists as a bench mark, right? Also, I really hope that you don't mean to say that anyone past 18 is an adult...

Side: Agree
1 point

Having a gun is a big responsibility and people should have to prove that they can handle that. Conservative gun laws dont help the situation any. I support background checks.

Side: Agree
DevinSeay(1120) Clarified
1 point

Yep and they are some dumb people of all ages. But I get her point. Their minds are not fully developed yet. They don't know right from wrong yet. They don't know the world yet.

Side: Agree
1 point

I believe in teaching a kid how to use and respect a gun at an early age... but carrying it... come on.

Nothing needs to be said.

Side: Disagree
1 point

If every child handle a gun then there will be more murder cases specially in schools.

Side: Disagree

I would say that every kid is not responsible enough to be trusted with guns in school. How would we ever know which kid comes from a bad home. We have many bad parents who would teach their kids to hate others for merely being Christians, etc. such as is going on in Arab nations.

I believe teachers & principles should most definitely have the right's to protect our children with guns.

Side: Disagree

Not wise at all. Children will be tempted to use a gun on a bully at school.

Side: Disagree