CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
4
Black hole, I say! No, They are black stars!
Debate Score:8
Arguments:7
Total Votes:9
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Black hole, I say! (3)
 
 No, They are black stars! (4)

Debate Creator

alstars(739) pic



Black holes or black stars?

i read a very recent article in a scienc magazine that says that quantum effects during the cooling of the collapsed star forms a black star that, instead of radiating energy, absorbes radiated energy and matter, since energy and mass relations are true!

And the event horizon arises as a solution of the Einstien's equations that are at the heart of his theory!

So, is there a possibility of this theory to be true!

Black hole, I say!

Side Score: 4
VS.

No, They are black stars!

Side Score: 4
1 point

The effects of this so called quatum theory doesn't hold treu or has failed to explain the still unknown particles that are supposed to be very simple as a photon!

It has even failed to bring out the particles of energy other that light's!

then how the damn can i believe that this is a true one! It is a pity that the author of that article is not a fairy tale writer!

Side: Black hole, I say!
paradox(208) Disputed
1 point

If quantum theory is not correct, then why did the world accept it, fool? do you think that we are idiots?

Side: No, They are black stars!
1 point

asshole black holes are formed from stars only

since it is forming a black thing

you can refer it to a black star

(this one is a fairy tale!)

(now lets get serious)

if it was a black star then why the fu__ would it absorb matter!

Side: No, They are black stars!
alstars(739) Disputed
1 point

This is what i too don't get< you see, i don't understand why it should absorb matter! and you wanna know what this foolish theory says, read the above introduction and you will understand that it is truly a fairy tale!

Side: Black hole, I say!
1 point

Black Holes/"Black Stars" are just a theory -- There is no actual proof that they even exist. So I say neither.

Side: Nobody knows
alstars(739) Disputed
1 point

It is proved that black holes do form after the super condensation of the collapsed stars,its gravity field depending on the magnitude of condensation states and explosive nature(i mean, nova, supernova etc!)

Side: Black hole, I say!
1 point

I think block-holes are due totally to gravity and not quantum. Quantum Theory only become significant at the very small in accordance with the correspondence principle (wikipedia that). But I difference with meaning the spacial theory relativity (see my debate: "Does Time Really Change?" this would spill over into the general theory of relativity as well. So the that black-holes are really black stars but not because of quantum theory.

Side: No, They are black stars!