CreateDebate is a social debate community built around ideas, discussion and democracy.
If this is your first time checking out a debate, here are some quick tips to help get you started:
Arguments with the highest score are displayed first.
Argument replies (both in favor and in opposition) are displayed below the original argument.
To follow along, you may find it helpful to show and hide the replies displayed below each argument.
To vote for an argument, use these icons:
You have the power to cast exactly one vote (either up or down) for each argument.
Once you vote, the icon will become grayed out and the argument's score will change.
Yes, you can change your vote.
Debate scores, side scores and tag scores are automatically calculated by an algorithm that primarily takes argument scores into account.
All scores are updated in real-time.
To learn more about the CreateDebate scoring system, check out the FAQ.
When you are ready to voice your opinion, use the Add Argument button to create an argument.
If you would like to address an existing argument, use the Support and Dispute link within that argument to create a new reply.
I got a link. But there is another thing you forgot informed consent. I don't think it is necessary. I don't inform my guy on informed consent. And I think alot of other people wouldn't care about informed consent either. My guy knows that he is taking a risk but he does not care.
Because it a puppy. And a adult is adult. You can look this up. puppies are little dogs that are slowly growing and learning and maturing. A adult I don't get what kind of adult your talking about.
I will give example because you have no link against me. It is sample no matter what the dog is not adult. There for by law it not 18. There for it illegal to have sex with a under age person. Example young dog are still learning life. Adult dog is not, It has fully matured and fully grown and ready to restart the cycle.
Human society is deeply anthropocentric because it is... well, human. It makes no sense to label actions that cause no human harm whatsoever as crimes, though I suppose it could be considered animal cruelty, if we were to look at the moral side of bestiality and the fact that animals probably don't enjoy it either.
If I cut my brain apart to get at equal level so there would be no taking advantage of. Then would you allow it or would you still come up with another lame excuse.
You don't need to. I'd say your intelligence is already quite in line with a lower primate if your counter-argument is whether 'cutting your brain apart', if that even makes sense, would somehow influence my opinion. Losing one's rationality would be considered the utmost form of insanity, the loss of all morality and, therefore, one couldn't be held responsible for one's actions. So no, even if I would cut my brain apart, specially if would I cut my brain apart, bestiality couldn't still be a crime.
If you are sufficiently clairvoyant to state beyond any doubt that animals consent, and that they like sex, then I need not argue anymore. Unless you can produce an animal which is able to show consent besides the human specie, these claims are speculative at best. And I will treat them that way. As for animals enjoying sexual intercourse, I sincerely don't know how that's relevant at all.
The burden of proof lies in you, for you are the person claiming that animals can consent. I've provided some evidence for my words in the form of an essay. Other statements made by me are also accountable for. The principle of harm is explained in http://www.princeton.edu/~achaney/tmve/wiki100k/docs/John StuartMill.html.
As for the analogy between a child and an animal, I most vehemently dispute it. Having a pet or a flower would be considered slavery if non-human species had the same rights to life and freedom as humans do.
That said, I believe I covered most bases. You are welcome to dispute my last arguments, but I won't reply. This topic has, for me, outlived its importance and I shall participate no more. Goodbye.
Why is it okay to have sex with an adult dog but nit a younger one? What change happens? When can you tell when they stop being young and start being adult?
I can't remember that. I just noted scientists say it 2 year just like everybody else. The difference between a adult dog and a young dog is. There more mature to handle things.
This is what he cannot do, show you proof. What he can, and will do if you keep trying, is tell you he's right, no longer even trying to give proof. Tell you about his alleged accolades and scientific achievements. Then when that has run it's course, attempt to silence you by banning.
To be perfectly honest I'm almost certain goodmlae is a troll, who's looking for attention. Hence the reason he chose an topic most would disagree with, as his favorite topic, and has at least two alt accounts. One to agree with the unpopular opinion, one to disagree so boldly as to make various debates about it.
Dude if I did that it would have to show sex in it.
If you are trying to say that the only way to show consent it to first have sex with the creature then you can't really count that as unquestionable consent. If you have to first have sex with a person to know if they are okay with it, you don't know what their thoughts are. If you're having sex with a person or animal and you have no way of knowing if they approve of it yet then that could definitely be considered rape.
Dude I can show you a video. On a human and animal consenting sex. It just that your going to have to watch it. And I don't want to get ban from andy posting video on sex.
If you want to be stupid. I will ban you. example if I consented to my dog then it up to him to consent back. So if the dog makes the choice to do the act then it consenting.
God Damn It!!! EVERYBODY SHUT-THE-FUCK UP!!!!! Stop calling each other disgusting!!!! I AM FUCKING TIRED OF ALL OF YOU GUYS SPAMMING THE DEBATES WITH THESE POINTLESS ARGUMENTS!!!! Get over each other and leave the topic alone!!! It is really that simple, this is frustrating me and other people too and if you can't stop get off the site!!
Okay look goodmale my opinion is that he is your dog you go have the time of you life but don't make it interfere with mine and I am happy. Also my opinion is that it is kind-of nasty but who cares it doesn't affect me so do what you want.
