CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
8
Yes No
Debate Score:11
Arguments:6
Total Votes:14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (3)
 
 No (3)

Debate Creator

nootjie(38) pic



Can the Quraan help scientist?

Many scientist is studying the quraan that was revealed 1400 years ago.In the quraan it explains about the planets, how a human gets developed and born and alot more.The theory was given and still available in the same form as it was revealed.

Yes

Side Score: 3
VS.

No

Side Score: 8
1 point

If you have time.Research on google.Maybe just type in scientist and the quran. You will be amazed what the top scientist in the world has to say about the quraan the Hadeeth of Prophet Mogammad(S.A.W).Its not about what we think its about the truth.So if the top people is saying about the miracles they have experience with the quran then who are we that dont know much to say its not possible.I guess we are allowed to view opinions.neverthless just about the comment about the man writing that someone mentioned. The Prophet was a person that could not write or read.So the wording that is in the quran must have come from someone isnt?Scientist admitted themselves how powerfull it is.There was so many people that tried to change the quran but couldnt.if they did they were caught and the copies is get destroyed.Thats how protected it is.Allah promised to protect the quran.Al-Hijr 15: 9.The Quran is amazing do research on it and you will find how powerfull the Quran is.

Side: yes
1 point

Please click on the following link to see the science of the Quraan http://www.islam-guide.com/

Side: yes
4 points

I feel that it may be a bad idea to post an argument on this debate, but here goes.

I think it is the other way around. The Quraan didn't appear out of thin air, it was written by someone. This person/group of people who wrote the Quraan had knowledge of the ways of the world, and therefore expressed these facts through the writings. The fact that the Quraan came from the Middle East, a very educationally advanced society, doesn't help the opposing argument. It is very possible that scientists of the day had a hand in developing the Quraan and expressed their findings and knowledge in it.

I am not familiar with the Quraan and therefore I don't know what it says about issues of science, but that's my guess.

Side: No
1 point

"Many scientist is [sic] studying the quraan that was revealed 1400 years ago."

No they're not, and any that are can hardly call themselves scientists. The Quran does indeed contain many scientific explinations and facts, however these are often wrong and entirely consistent with the scientific understanding of the time. [1][2]

The Quran, for example, incorrectly details how skin and bone develop, and does so in a way entirely consistent with the proposed scientific method of skin and bone formation at the time. [3]

Side: No
hibba(50) Disputed
1 point

May be present science is wrong or you have learned wrong method related to quran.when Quran was revealed there was no machine to inspect the skin and bone formation.but some very definite process was revealed.I request you to again learn bone and skin formation method according to Islam and according to present science.

Side: Yes
1 point

It all depends on what the person interpreting the Quaraan thinks. It can mean many different things.

Side: No