Can you really expect to change someones mind on this website
After seeing so many people continue ranting about their controdicting veiws, even when all reasoning is against them, i began to wonder
Can someone's mind be changed on Create Debate.
Do people come here to find the best reasoning or just to express their, sometimes unpopular, veiws.
Have any of you ever walked away from a debate with your mind changed.
yes, they are open minded
Side Score: 5
|
no, they are too stubborn
Side Score: 11
|
|
|
|
4
points
Most debates are based on subjective values and thus there is no objective 'right' and 'wrong'. I have changed people's minds and I have had my mind changed. Even when an opponent fails to convince me my view is illogical, debating with some who holds an opposing view helps me refine my understanding of what I think and why I think that way. It has also led me to do a lot of research to support my arguments or verify the claims of others. Side: yes, they are open minded
2
points
no my mind never changes with open debate because I do the research beforehand. for instance.. the ps3 and xbox debate on this site. I knew beforehand when I made the decision on buying either the 360 or ps3 that the ps3 had better in every way. This includes the internal hardware (most important). Higher hdmi output, blueray, etc. The 360 still uses dvd's ! so with other things I still do this kind've research. Now the stubborn ones you speak of, you can't change their mind. They DO come here just to rant and say whats on THEIR minds. Not that THEIR minds are right, because in most cases they are wrong. Even when others put proven facts and links before them, they can still be ignorant and talk about something else (or make fun of the poster at that point). That still shows that the OP was correct though Side: no, they are too stubborn
It depends on who that someone is. For example most Caucasians rarely admit their faults and African American are constantly forced to admit theirs. Whites are stubborn down to the bone. African Americans however are constantly changing their minds. That's why on this website if you really pay attention whites are firm on their position no matter how much evidence there is contrary to their position. On the other hand you will find blacks flip flopping from one point of view to the next. No matter where you look you will find this trend even..... in the white house. Side: no, they are too stubborn
|