CreateDebate


Debate Info

9
1
Guilty Not Guilty
Debate Score:10
Arguments:13
Total Votes:15
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Guilty (8)
 
 Not Guilty (5)

Debate Creator

NikkiHill11(154) pic



Clemens: Guilty or Not?

Liar, liar, pants on fire?

Guilty

Side Score: 9
VS.

Not Guilty

Side Score: 1
2 points
All signs point to -- GUILTY.
Side: Guilty
1 point
Absolutely guilty. As is a majority of Major League Baseball. People just care because, like Barry Bonds, he's better than most of the other players.
Side: Guilty
0 points
Not to mention, he's an arse. I'm thinking 'roid rage!
Side: Guilty
-2 points
Time2Golf(288) Disputed
0 points
That was Curt Schilling you dumbass, not Roger Clemens.
Side: Not Guilty
2 points
He is definitely guilty. There is no way that he hasn't used steroids during his career. Every other player that was named in the Mitchell Report has come back and admitted they used it "once or twice". Clemens still vehemently denies it, although his testimony was about the least convincing thing I've ever seen.
Side: Guilty
2 points
I would like to say I always take a man by his word, but RG has too many skeltons in the closet and they all seem to contradict what he is saying
Side: Guilty
1 point
Guilty. I don't see why the trainer would have any incentive to lie.
Side: Guilty
-1 points
I don't think there's any way that he's guilty. If he were guilty he would have just admitted it like the rest of the guilty people did. He knows there's no / little backlash if he said he was guilty off the bat, so why would he go to such lengths to defend himself if he was really guilty?
Side: Not Guilty
NikkiHill11(154) Disputed
1 point
hahahha your response is hilarious. Ever heard the expression "Deny 'til you die"?
Side: Guilty
1 point
Well Nikki obviously knows about 'deny til you die.' ;-)
Side: Not Guilty