CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:11
Arguments:24
Total Votes:12
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Cloning Humans (9)

Debate Creator

daver(1771) pic



Cloning Humans

it is now possible to clone a human. If you believe that humans have immortal souls, would a human clone have a soul?

Add New Argument

Good question!

I think so. The clone would have the same substance (soul) that makes up an individual.

FoxNews Clarified
1 point

Lol*

1 point

I believe that a clone will posses a soul, however 'its' soul will be unique regardless of the genetic replication. In christianity, we believe that the soul is given by god to the individual, however in this case the soul would be handed down by the creator ...

The clone of a human has ALL the physical looks and appearances but does not have emotions as a normal human has..

Delta(1348) Disputed
2 points

Say what? A clone is a complete replica of a human being, so unless clones don't have a brain which is responsible for emotions then I don't know what does.

1 point

Read the disadvantages of cloning... There is a 99% chance of failure...

Supporting Evidence: CLONE FAILURE (learn.genetics.utah.edu)
1 point

This would be a bold step for medical science.

We still do not understand what a soul is etc etc so from what I have read though cloning reproduces the "physicality" of the original, I doubt if any other aspects would be passed on so the clone would develop its own as it would most likely just have the same basic instincts that we have when we are born like thirst, hunger, etc etc. the only difference would be that it would be a copy of someone else and that would be an interesting mind game.

1 point

I think of a clone as a retroactive twin.

1 point

The very thought of it should horrify all human beings to the core. There is noting moral or ethical about it. But lets suppose a person doesn't have bioethics or morals, but is yet still somehow smart enough to do such a thing. The next thing would be why? Just because we can? Just because technology exists? This world kills or prevents 1 in 3 people as it is. If we're so bent on having more people, instead of playing God and creating them in laboratories, how about we just stop killing our children, or preventing them by artificial means if we are married persons?

1 point

my theory is there is a finite amount of intelligence or soul in the universe and it gets distributed among all the life forms that exist.

.

we have been breeding too much and abusing the privilege ... that's why ppl are getting dumber.

.

its a theory that explains the facts.

.

Amarel(5669) Clarified
1 point

People are getting smarter. .

skyfish(276) Clarified
1 point

cite!

seriously, where do you see evidence of this?

at this point i'm ready to move "Idiocracy" from parody to documentary.