CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:19
Arguments:13
Total Votes:20
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Crazy .. but kinda cool thing to think about ? or what ? (13)

Debate Creator

giverupper(247) pic



Crazy .. but kinda cool thing to think about ? or what ?

Okay, I have recently read in an article, that scientists have succed in making sperm from a woman.

You have to know, that I don't know if this is true - but let's say it is, let's pretend, that scientists could make sperm from a woman.

Then two women could get pregnant right? And if two women have a child, the child would 100% sure be female too, because a women only carry the XX gender (the female gender). XY does not exist in a female body, therefore if two women had a baby, it wasn't possible to make a boy.

 

Therfore, if we pretend that women could make their own sperm - women could techincally take over the world.

If all women agreed to never sleep with men, and only reproduce with women, the male gender would die out.

 

Think about it ?!? :D

Add New Argument

But..., who's going to kill the spiders?

Who's going to take out the trash?

Who's going to mow the lawn?

There are some serious flaws in your scenario ;)

You forgot to ask the most important question of all: Who's going to eat all those sandwiches?

2 points

But the children that the women have might be male.

I suppose you could alter that too, but this is such an unrealistic and silly scenario that I'm not going to type anymo-

giverupper(247) Disputed
1 point

No - If it was possible that a woman could get pregnant with another woman's sperm, they couldn't make a boy.

Becuase the XY gene doesn't exist in the female body. It is only the male gender that can pass the male gene.

1 point

Huh. I thought the sperm from the females would have XY, but I guess if it doesn't... then you're right.

2 points

I don't believe all women would agree to that, though if I were a woman I'd certainly agree to it.

Sports would officially suck and I'd never be able to watch basketball with a straight face again, but whatever :p

1 point

Ummmm? I'm pretty sure sperm are already for women? I mean... I have no use for them? I'll give mine away for free.

then who would you make sandwiches for? lets be logical here xD

If all women agreed to never sleep with men, and only reproduce with women, the male gender would die out.

This is where it would fail.

Plus asexual species are usually on the way to extinction, besides one fortunate example of bdelloid rotifers.

The concentration of genes would increase instead of spread out, this would lead to all manner of defects, and bring our evolution to a halt. It is the combination of genes that makes sexual reproduction so successful.

1 point

"If all women agreed to never sleep with men, and only reproduce with women, the male gender would die out."

For that to happen, it would take a female leader like Hitler or something. Plus, there are always hookers that need to make money and being lesbian is not something a woman can just convert into. And don't forget rape. It would be such a big issue if this were to happen.

I forgot to add, women is already the majority of the population without these sperms anyway.

0 points

And if electricity should for some reason fail? All technology rendered useless...

1 point