CreateDebate


Debate Info

5
4
Yes, it is tyrannical No, everyone's voice is heard
Debate Score:9
Arguments:9
Total Votes:9
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes, it is tyrannical (5)
 
 No, everyone's voice is heard (4)

Debate Creator

FUNMUN(127) pic



Democracy: Hidden Tyranny, or a Just form of Government?

Questions to consider:  Is a democracy tyrannical? And if so how?  Should the majority rule? Is a democracy Just? If so then how? What are better forms of government if democracy is tyrannical? 

Yes, it is tyrannical

Side Score: 5
VS.

No, everyone's voice is heard

Side Score: 4

Whether democracy is tyranny or not is not something I really have an opinion on, however there are five principles to democracy.

Freedom

Integrity

Majority rules

Minority rights

Social equality

The US does not have social equality, and the majority doesnt necessarily rule. Whether or not this is good or bad is another discussion, but if you're asking whether the US qualifies as democracy the answer is; No!

Side: Yes, it is tyrannical
Jace(5222) Disputed
1 point

Can you identify a single government which actually satisfies those criteria? I sincerely doubt it. Like all forms of government, democracies in practice fail to live up to their ideal conception. That doesn't make them not democracies. It makes them failed democracies. It also doesn't make much sense to conceive of democracies as something else just because they fall short, because regardless of how well they accomplish their ends those are still the ends they ascribe to and which define their systems.

Side: No, everyone's voice is heard
1 point

The Nordic States satisfy all five principles .

Side: Yes, it is tyrannical
1 point

All government is tyranny. The question is more properly understood as an order of magnitude.

Side: Yes, it is tyrannical
No arguments found. Add one!