CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:19
Arguments:18
Total Votes:21
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Democrats say we can't break up illegal immigrant families. But it's ok to break up ours. (17)

Debate Creator

FromWithin(8241) pic



Democrats say we can't break up illegal immigrant families. But it's ok to break up ours.

Think about it, how many tmes do we hear these hypocritical Democrats scream of the horrors of breaking up illegal immigrant families when deporting them.

Hmmmmmmm, lets see, what happens to American familes when one of the parrents breaks the law? He or she goes to jail!!!!!
Last I knew, that is breaking up the family. HOW COULD THEY BE SO HORRIBLE AND UNCARING?

So lets get this straight. If you break our immigration laws, the wonderful caring Democrats let you off the hook so your families can stay together, but when legal citizens of America breaks some non political correct law, these same compassionate Democrats have no problem throwing you in jail no matter that it is breaking up the family.

As always, it's all about politics. Democrats want the illegal immigrant vote and as always will bend the laws however they must be bent in order to get maximum voter potencial. They will always do their best to paint the Republicans as those cold cruel evil white people. 

These hypocritical Democrats, who even lack the compassion to care for the lives of viable late term babies, have the nerve to dare speak to compassion and caring for others.
Add New Argument
2 points

Pack 'em up, and ship 'em out!

What a novel idea. Do you mean we should actually implement our immigration laws?

That's crazy uncaring thinking. You must be one of those deplorable irredeemable, xenophobic, white supremace type:)

Why do we feel for the families broken up for immigration policies, tending to act more on these feelings more than say someone who broke a different law and as a result has their family broken up? Simply put, illegal immigrants tend to be the victims rather than some terrible perpetrator. I'm sure their cause is something we can all sympathize with, to build a better life for them and their family. Since you make no distinction between the different kinds of illegal immigrants, I would like to ask you something. If an illegal immigrant serves in the military, is it then right to kick him/her out of the country after he/she fulfilled their service?

LichPotato(362) Disputed
2 points

The notion that illegal immigrants are generally, if not always, the victim in the situation is inherently flawed. Our country has a system for legal immigration, and those who disregard it in favor of illegal immigration are cheating both our law and all those who come here lawfully. Just because people want a better life doesn't mean they can disregard law to acquire it.

blueprint318(16) Disputed
1 point

So you admit that they are coming over here for a better life? And if so, is that not an illustration of a victim to you? Someone who attempts to escape a more grave reality for a better one but is punished for doing so? Although I can understand why we have immigration laws. Let me ask you, do you really believe that illegal immigration is becoming more and more prevalent as guys like Trump portray? If so, where do you get this information? As all the studies I have seen show that illegal immigration has been in decline since the 2008 stock market crash.

I knew there was some common sense in you :)...........................................

FromWithin(8241) Clarified
1 point

I want the same law applied to them as legal Americans who break the law and then go into the service.

If a theif is caught after joining the military, he would be brought to justice the same as any criminal.

The only reason illegl immigrants get special treatment is because Democrats want their future votes.

blueprint318(16) Disputed
1 point

So you think it is morally right to allow an illegal immigrant to fight our wars and then kick them out afterwards?

NicolasCage(505) Disputed
1 point

There's a difference between arresting someone and kicking them out of the country.

Yes, if a soldier/ex-soldier commits a crime they should be sent to prison.

And yes, if a immigrant soldier/ex-soldier commits a crime they should be sent to prison.

You act like we want to give immigrants legal immunity or something.

Lopilulu(286) Banned
1 point

If you are a natural born Caucasian American, you are the descendant of illegal immigrants who pillaged, tortured and massacred the natives of the land, then they brought in blacks by even worse means and treated them like they were beneath insects.

You then sit there and cry when Latinos play the game less effectively and less brutal in manner and expect sympathy and understanding. Stop whining and start accepting what a hypocrite you are.