CreateDebate


Debate Info

2
13
Yes, she gave him herpes No, hitting was uncalled for
Debate Score:15
Arguments:11
Total Votes:15
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes, she gave him herpes (2)
 
 No, hitting was uncalled for (9)

Debate Creator

JESSEMlover(121) pic



Did Chirs Brown have the right to hit Rihanna the way he did?

Recent reports say that the reason why Chris Brown and Rihanna got into a heated argument on Grammy-eve which even led to the black eye suffered by Rihanna was that the latter gave the former “herpes.”

According to CDC.gov, Genetal herpes is a sexually transmitted disease (STD) caused by the herpes simplex viruses type 1 (HSV-1) or type 2 (HSV-2)but in most cases, genital herpes is caused by HSV-2. Majority of individuals have no or only minimal signs or symptoms from HSV-1 or HSV-2 infection. When one starts to experience signs, they usually appear as one or more blisters on or around the genitals or rectum. The blisters break, leaving tender ulcers (sores) that may take two to four weeks to heal the first time they occur. Normally, another outbreak can appear weeks or months following the first, but it almost always is less severe and shorter than the first outbreak. Although the infection can remain in the body intermittently, the number of outbreaks tends to decrease over a period of years.

Reports from sites further state that the reason the pair were fighting was by reason of the recent breakup by the couple. Rihanna desires to continue the relationship but Chris Brown wants severance of the relationship. The story became more controversial when Tom Joyner, a nationally syndicated radio broadcast out of Atlanta’s Kiss 104.1, mentioned that the reason why Brown got mad is that the Barbados singer gave him an STD.

LAPD confirmed to PEOPLE that Chris Brown is under investigation for alleged domestic violence felony battery. Brown, after getting arrested, has been released on $50,000 bail and will be represented by high profile attorney Mark Geragos.

Yes, she gave him herpes

Side Score: 2
VS.

No, hitting was uncalled for

Side Score: 13

Not because of the herpes, but because she put out a song where she specifically requested a big, crazy "rude boy" to be rough with her. She probably should have seen this coming.

Side: Yes, she gave him herpes
3 points

Who in the world would say yes to this? I see a landslide debate.

Side: Of Course Not

Landslide Debate?...Explain Please!?! I am now suppose to have a minimum of fifty words so ignore the rest, it's nonesense: lkjdfklj kdjfkosdjflkj lkjdflkjasdfkljsdfklj dsfjklasdf dsfjskldjfskdfhddf sdjfjhdf jsdfh jo dofhi jfklj dfhls sdfjo ihfj kf

Side: No, hitting was uncalled for
2 points

All though Rihanna gave him the diease that keeps on giving he had no right to hit her. Rihanna DID cheat on him with Soulja Boy and she DID give him herpes. But one punch or one slap would have been acceptable. Now, I'm hearing there back together. O the joy of LOVE!

Side: No, hitting was uncalled for
2 points

You're a very young girl, no offense, and I'm glad you asked this because it's very important for you to understand.

Unless someone's life is in emminant danger, as in the woman is weilding a knife or gun, there is absolutely no excuse for a guy to ever, ever hit a girl.

Now, is this fair? I mean, there are plenty of situations where it's perfectly acceptable for me to get my ass kicked by another guy, or vice versa. And that's fine.

And it doesn't seem fair sometimes, almost universally any police responding to a domestic violence call will take a bruised and bleeding guy to jail, while they stay and comfort the girl with a scratch on her arm, and give her resources for battered women.

But there's a very good reason for this social reverse sexism, and the sexism within the law.

When a guy hits a girl, it's never ever "because he cares," it is because he is violent and emotionally unstable. Guys who hit girls rarely rarely only hit them once. He learns that he can get away with it, he'll start doing it more often, and for less and less reason. He'll say sorry every time, he'll even make the girl feel like he's the victim.

He's not. He is a pathetic person. And a very dangerous person to any girl he's with.

Now I hear all this bs from ditty and other rappers "you don't know what happened." blah blah.

That's part of the problem. No one has to know what happened, what the excuses are. The fact is he almost killed that girl. He's an asshole and should be in jail. End of story.

And Rhianna needs to get the hell away from him, or her life will be in serious danger.

I want to make if very very clear. Guys who hit girls do not love them, they hate themselves. They do not deserve pitty, girls should not stay with them because they feel bad for them, or really think deep down they love them. No, it's way way harder for a guy to just walk away than to hit a girl, it takes a lot more "love" to not hit a girl.

Side: Of Course Not

To be honest, I don't know what to say, um type. Wow, iamdavidh, that was very moving! Wow, wow! That was very powerful and interesting! You are dead right! WOW!!

Side: No, hitting was uncalled for
1 point

Such blatant sexism... And you call yourself a liberal? If a man gives a girl herpes, she will literally be given a medal if she eats the guy up.

Do you think women want to be babyed like this? I don't think so. It's insulting to think that women just can't handle themselves.

Side: Yes, she gave him herpes
iamdavidh(4856) Disputed
1 point

The same can happen to guys. The difference is physical size and aggression. Understanding the nature of humans as an animal isn't sexism you simpleton. Different isn't unequal.

Side: No, hitting was uncalled for
1 point

Hitting was really uncalled for... I still love himk and think he's amazing, but it was very wrong.

Side: No, hitting was uncalled for
1 point

Nobody has the right to punch someone else without good reason.

Side: No, hitting was uncalled for
1 point

How corrupt.

I can't believe he was allowed to pay bail. That's not even a punishment.

A person like that has so much money, such a small bail amount isn't worth a thing.

Perhaps if he had been stripped of everything he owned, except his name, that would be more fair.

That doesn't really match "eye for an eye", but in general, getting out of jail because you already have money is pretty corrupted.

Side: No, hitting was uncalled for