CreateDebate


Debate Info

11
15
NO! yes
Debate Score:26
Arguments:17
Total Votes:34
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 NO! (7)
 
 yes (8)

Debate Creator

123456789101(86) pic



Did the big bang really happen

NO!

Side Score: 11
VS.

yes

Side Score: 15
3 points

The universe couldn't have just gone pop and then boom everything there. Apparently it started as a dot spinning around super fast. and then it exploded into our universe.

What caused the spinning? how did the dot get there. there really isn't any logical about the big bang. on the other hand there is plenty logical evidence on god. I mean the earth isn't just the perfect distance form the sun on accident. our living conditions are literally perfect. that cant be by chance. think about that

Side: NO!
pastafarian(79) Disputed
3 points

The universe almost certainly started with the Big Bang, whether it wasn't god that caused it or not, the physical act of the beginning of the universe was the Big Bang. Physics says before the Big Bang all matter was condensed into an unimaginably small and immeasurably dense point called a "singularity". What else in the known universe causes singularities? Black holes. Matter is sucked into a black hole and condensed to a minuscule, dense singularity. Nobody knows where the matter goes once it is pulled past the event horizon of a black hole. It's likely that our "Big Bang" was simply a black hole on the other side of an event horizon. Matter goes in, gets condensed and explodes out the other side (as if you binged on Taco Bell). Yes that means that there are other universes such as the one that contained the black hole that caused our Big Bang. Yes that means that black holes link one universe with another. In regards to the question I feel I've answered it appropriately but on the deeper subject of who or what created all the universes I'll simply say "who knows"? If the length of time the universe has existed were scaled down to that of a calendar year then intelligent life has only existed for the last second of the last second of the last minute of the last day of the last month of that year. It would be naive and arrogant to think we have it all figured out or that we will any time soon, but that's the fun. The purpose of life is discovery.

Side: yes
Cartman(18192) Disputed
2 points

The universe couldn't have just gone pop and then boom everything there.

Why? What's the alternative? God went pop and then boom everything there.

Apparently it started as a dot spinning around super fast. and then it exploded into our universe.

Not really an explosion. Just a fast expansion.

on the other hand there is plenty logical evidence on god.

Sadly, there is only logical evidence of God. The only evidence ever presented for God are a series of logical statements that end with "therefore, God"

I mean the earth isn't just the perfect distance form the sun on accident.

You mean that God designed a tiny window for life to exist inside the insanely massive universe on purpose?

our living conditions are literally perfect.

They have been sculpted by other living creatures over millions of years to become perfect.

Side: yes
123456789101(86) Clarified
2 points

well cartman what i mean is that nothing is nothing and it cant create anything so something, (ominous music plays) or SOMEONE must have started the universe

Side: NO!

Yes, it boils down to scientists asking us to believe that something, i.e, the minute atom, not to mention all the enormity of space, came from nothing. The constants necessary for the existence of earth and the life thereon are much too great for them all to be simply by random chance.

Side: NO!
3 points

According to the theory itself, there is no point at which one can say "time" itself began. That would require a point in time. Mathematics brings us within milliseconds of the theoretical beginning but this cannot be taken to an actual point in time. So no, at no point did the Big Bang happen.

Side: NO!
0 points

I really enjoyed this answer. Thank you.

Side: NO!
outlaw60(15495) Disputed
2 points

The big bang is good if you got more cushion for the pushin ! You disagree ?

Side: yes
2 points

I will have to say yes and it was more cushion for the pushin and alot of fun !

Side: yes
2 points

Although the theory doesn't allow for a specific "point", as it defies time, the Big Bang Theory very well could have "happened". Although there is no solid, unarguable proof for it, there is nothing to disprove it either. So, as a matter of my opinion, I do chose to believe the Big Bang Theory.

Side: yes