CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:9
Arguments:10
Total Votes:9
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Do animals feel pain (8)

Debate Creator

samuel000(5) pic



Do animals feel pain

Although it may seem that the simple and instinctive answer is that they do have this capability, but if you want to give animals the feeling of pain your saying that they can feel in general which must lead to the conclusion that there must be a personality and a self which is feeling the pain .The bigger question is what exactly is the level of an animals  consciousness, you might be feel quite confident to say that a animal is only a physical body with out a so called deeper self and unique personality (more likeness to  robot than Homo sapiens although certainly not a robot) and there will be little chance that a animal will have Descartes felling of cogito ergo sum but by saying that you are automatically leaning to the opinion that a animal can't feel pain simple because it lacks the faculty to sense and feel and any symptoms of pain which it gives is of instinctive sort (maybe rooted from the struggle to survival)

Add New Argument
2 points

Duh

1 point

If not than there should be nothing like a animal abuse laws.

1 point

but if you want to give animals the feeling of pain your saying that they can feel in general which must lead to the conclusion that there must be a personality and a self which is feeling the pain .

Pain has nothing to do with personality.

Stay in school.

goodmale(1459) Clarified
1 point

It can because some people like pain and that is part of there personality.

flewk(1193) Disputed
1 point

He is talking about the ability to feel pain. That should be obvious.

1 point

It can because some people like pain and that is part of there personality.

Then the pain is not a part of the personality, it's the opinion on pain.

Animals do feel pain and I never like to see them suffer. I can deduct that dogs have souls because they are loyal to their owner, and if the owner should be away for a long time, the doggie will come up running to the owner crying and very emotional with jumping up and down.

1 point

All species that have a nervous system feel pain

Humans and animals have a nervous system

Both feel pain

1 point

yes certainly they to feel pain cause they too are living creatures but cant express pain by speaking.