CreateDebate


Debate Info

8
9
YES NO
Debate Score:17
Arguments:15
Total Votes:17
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 YES (7)
 
 NO (8)

Debate Creator

amberwriter(125) pic



Do you think that natural talent is unfair to some people ?

Do you think that natural talent is unfair to some people ?

some people who have many talents all in one....

but,others don't have any bit of it !

Unfair ?

hard to survive without a talent ?

Do you think any one can be successful without any talent ?

for example: published author - writer,painter,artist,and doctor ?

can you learn how to be a celebrated writer or artist without talent ? 

 

YES

Side Score: 8
VS.

NO

Side Score: 9
2 points

When it's not used to harm the opportunities of the untalented, no, it's not unfair.

When it IS used to harm the opportunities of the untalented, yes, it is very unfair.

Side: YES

YES ! life is unfair ....and it just persist!

no mater how you complain ,cry out for justice and fairness ....

it just won't work for you !

accept the truth!

or,you can always find that suicidal the best and easy solution !

Side: YES

Some people can't even draw and it seems that talents aren't distributed fairly.

Side: YES

I wish that I could draw because I see some people where drawing comes naturally.

Side: YES

The trust you required to think everyone is talented isn't real, in my opinion! | house painters hamilton

Side: YES

Its not a problem since everyone is talented therefore everyone is equal in skills. It is just a matter of finding where you are good at. Gifted children were`t born with skills, they practiced it and honed their skills to a keen precision. It is inappropriate that one would be called untalented, you just have`t seen yours.

Side: NO
amberwriter(125) Disputed
1 point

I don't think that the faith you required to believe everyone has a talent is genuine !

Those babies with birth defects: for example,A disease which skins fall easily;

And someone has pituitary gland malfunction or being amputated.

How can they have any talent ? Although they do have a talent,do you think our world can give them any opportunity to practice and develop?

It is unfair !

Side: YES
Cambriel(711) Disputed
1 point

Um, those babies with birth defects, as you say, like the ones amputated, yes they are given opportunities in our world. In our country, blind people earn a living by massaging in some places. People who are amputated, also earn a living by playing in paralympic tournaments here. As we see, there is also a paralympics that happens every after the olympic season. They are also given the opportunities to show their talents to the world, and to be able practice and develop their talents.

Side: NO
1 point

It is not. It may slow them up a bit but does not necessarily term them useless. There are people who have multiple birth defects who are still successful. A good example would be Ludwig Van Beethoven. Who had a problem in hearing and eventually became completely deaf but found his talent in music and dominated it.

There are also multiple icons who have deficiencies in their life but managed to be successful. Those who joined the Paralympics are living testaments of people who found their talent and a mind over matter attitude.

What you are implying may also come in a degree of external proportions. It would also be said that financial capabilities would pose a disadvantage to other`s talents since they are born poor. Then again, that state of mind and argument has been proven wrong since the poor have triumphed over the rich in multiple ways.

It is in the state of mind of the people if they will succeed of not. If they have the passion to look for their talents and hone it, then they may be as famous as any other person. Probably even more. Mind over matter!

Side: NO

But....

why worries ?

you are going to die sooner or later anyway !

no mater how much talents you process,you are going to fill in that dusty crematorium !

life last just a short moment !

in some way,life is fair......

death is the universe most fairest event !

see, many successful people don't live long enough !

enjoy your life is the most important thing to consider...

how can I enjoy my life ? if I'm so limited ?

so ,enjoy your limitedness !

laugh in the crematorium !

LIVE IT OR DIE ....!

that's it .

it is so simple !

don't make life too complicated.

Side: NO
1 point

No because god made all us diffrent he has a plan for all of us..... dont worry about sports and such non sense that means absolutely nothing in the end....

Side: NO
1 point

Do you think that natural talent is unfair to some people ?

I don't understand this very well. I believe everyone has a talent.

But every talent needs to be taught. If your talent is playing football, you need trainers and stuff, you need to practice to be good.

No one is born a piano player, no one is born a doctor - you have to practice.

Unfair ?

Talent is not unfair. Everyone has talent, if you're willing to work on it then you'll become good. Those who claim they have no talent, are lazy and unmotivated to work to be good at something.

Do you think any one can be successful without any talent ?

Like I said before, everyone has talent. But no, if there were a person who was born without talent then he would not be very successful in this world.

can you learn how to be a celebrated writer or artist without talent ?

I suck at writing, I would never sell a million copies of my book. So no I would never be a celebrated a writer nor artist.

But I am a good musician, I have a good ear and I play several instruments, I wouldn't be a celebrated musician but I still got the talent.

You just need to find what you are good at, and then work for it.

Don't think you're without talent just because someone is better than you.

If someone is better than you, it means they worked harder than you did.

Side: NO

Natural talent doesn't exist because we are born into this world naked, and in a free society, nurture and practice is what matters.

Side: NO
1 point

Why should be it unfair? Since God gives everyone equal opportunity, why should natural talents not given everyone?

Side: NO
amberwriter(125) Disputed
1 point

I am the person who has no talent of any type !

can't write well.

can't read well.

can't study well.

can't draw or paint !

can't play any music instrument.

can't do any sport or exercise.

no girlfriend.

with serious birth defect that will last all life long.

GOD is joking on me !!!

I hate him ......for all eternity if he does exist !

Side: YES