CreateDebate


Debate Info

10
8
Sometimes Never
Debate Score:18
Arguments:16
Total Votes:20
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Sometimes (8)
 
 Never (8)

Debate Creator

JamesBallew(72) pic



Do you think vigilante justice is ever justified?

Sometimes

Side Score: 10
VS.

Never

Side Score: 8

rarely - and they fully should expect to pay the price.

Side: Sometimes
0 points

rarely - and they fully should expect to pay the price.

You need some vigilante justice. Someone needs to sew your gums together. They flap nonstop.

We have a saying back home. Big mouth, small brain.

Side: Never
2 points

"Big mouth, small brain."

I've made 6765 posts in 10+ years.

You've made 6731 in 2 years with just one of your many alts.

Side: Sometimes
Jagaloon(86) Disputed
1 point

We have a saying back home. Big mouth, small brain.

You are on here all day. That's a very large mouth you have. You carry on like a gossipy woman.

Side: Sometimes
1 point

Do you think vigilante justice is ever justified?

Hello James:

In a word, YES..

I used to believe in the quaint notion that, in exchange for NOT murdering my neighbor, I'd GIVE up murder and let a "Justice System" act in my stead.. I BELIEVED the innocent would go free, and the guilty would be punished..

But, that ain't happening..

Through asset forfeiture, and the drug war, the cops STEAL our money and MURDER our people.. I could do a better job of dispensing justice my own damn self.

And, isn't that what vigilantism is, after all?

excon

Side: Sometimes
1 point

Through asset forfeiture, and the drug war, the cops STEAL our money and MURDER our people

Wait, are you a drug dealer now?

Why do you always try to associate yourself with every oppressed group in existence and act like every act of oppression has been committed against you personally? That's literally your shtick right there. You incessantly attempt to send people onto guilt trips for acts they didn't commit and you didn't suffer.

Side: Never
excon(18261) Disputed
1 point

Why do you always try to associate yourself with every oppressed group in existence

Hello hater:

Why??? Cause I'm a lib, and that's what LIB'S do.. How the fuck do you not know that?? If you weren't so neurotically OBSESSED with me, you'd agree with me..

excon, LIBERAL, Ashkenazi Jew

Side: Sometimes
Jagaloon(86) Disputed
1 point

Through asset forfeiture, and the drug war, the cops STEAL our money and MURDER our people.. I could do a better job of dispensing justice my own damn self.

Yet these systems are almost fully run by Democrats.

Side: Never
1 point

ONLY IF THE VIGILANTE DOESN'T BREAK THE LAW and COOPERATES WITH UNCORRUPTED POLICE.

COMPARE V FOR VENDETTA VS BATMAN. Vendetta kills all who gets in his way and yet he doesn't see that he is defending the wrong people such as that lesbian girl who rebelled against her family. Vendetta just wants anarchy and isn't a hero. He is an anti hero vigilante, a loose cannon, a very dangerous one. While Batman for instance, works with the cops, especially with the Commissioner, Jim Gordon. YOU MUST ALWAYS REMEMBER, NO ONE IS ABOVE THE LAW. THAT IS WHY BATMAN DOESN'T KILL.

WHEN THE SYSTEM FAILS, HEROES WILL RISE UP TO DEFEND THE LAW IN ORDER TO PREVENT ANARCHY.

Side: Sometimes

Only if they are wearing a super hero costume ;)

Side: Never
1 point

To entertain such a notion, no matter how seemingly justified, is to start down the slippery slope to anarchy.

Baltasar Gracian;- ''Never open the door to a lesser evil, for other greater ones invariably slink in after it''.

Side: Never