CreateDebate


Debate Info

17
38
Yes No
Debate Score:55
Arguments:30
Total Votes:63
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (14)
 
 No (16)

Debate Creator

ChuckHades(3197) pic



Does age matter when considering intelligence?

After a brief conversation with Apollo, I was wondering whether or not age matters in terms of wisdom, intelligence, knowledge, etc. For example: would you talk down to someone younger than you, even if they have equal intelligence? Are you any more impressed by a smart 10 year old than you are by a smart 30 year old? Is age relevant to the amount one can know?

Oh, and by "age", I'm talking about the different groups mainly, i.e., Adults:Teenagers, Teenagers:Pre-teens, etc.

Yes

Side Score: 17
VS.

No

Side Score: 38
2 points

With age comes more experience, more learning, more time to become intelligent. I've never met someone who claims to be less intelligent than they were when they were 10. Personally, I can see the differences in how I approach different questions over time, more than simply a change in perspective, it's a change in my ability to answer the question.

That's not to say that the younger you are, the less intelligent you are. All people have different levels of intelligence throughout their life, one persons 12 is another's 60. In comparison between people, it's but a small factor. But I still feel there is a general trend throughout someone's life of an increase of intelligence.

Side: Yes
BlackSheep(203) Disputed
1 point

Experience and learning are not intelligence. You can learn to use your intelligence better, but you do not become smarter.

Side: No
1 point

An intelligent child should not be looked down on, but a high IQ can make you ignore the level of emotional intelligence in the child. In short, most people gain more maturity through age, whether from time, experience, greater exposure to various beliefs, etc. There are exceptions to every rule of course, a child who might experience a traumatic experience at ten is most likely more mature than a teen with a rosy life, but in general it follows that age bestows wisdom and youth, curiosity, or perhaps a more open outlook.

There's also types of intelligence to consider. A fifteen year old brilliant analytically predisposed thinker may have quite a lot to learn about nature from an older farmer. Therefore, I think it can be expressed like this: age should only be considered in relative to experience. And as older people usually have more experience, than I guess it should matter.

Side: Yes
1 point

it is a factor that should be considered but there are definitely younger people who are smarter than older people. good example with apollo if he is 15. I'm only 14 and i know I'm smarter than my math teacher. she is extremely stupid. on the other side compare me now with a future version of myself. i couldn't compare. why? because he knows all the things i know plus all that extra knowledge capacity that come with age. basically it should be a considered factor because, yes theoretically older people are smarter, however we know that does not always prove true.

Side: Yes
1 point

Of course.

a 5 year old is more intelligent than a 2 year old

a 10 year old is more intelligent than a 5 year old

15 is more inteligent than 10

and i would say this applies up till around the age of 22

and at a much greater age you start to lose intelligence

this applies to most people

of course there are geniuses and random kids that mature faster than others, but for the most part i think age matters

Side: Yes
SwastikaNein(1) Disputed
1 point

What you said is true but age does not matter when comparing to others. It is possible that some kids are more intelligent than us. If age mattered then no kid would be intellectually superior compared to us. Age therefore does not matter as it has been shown that there are some "gifted" children that appear to be more intelligent than us. Being gifted is not an excuse to the fact that age indeed does not matter when considering intelligence as they are different. Just like we are different from everybody as we have our own different levels of intelligence.

Side: No

Yes!!! I've waited all my life just so that I can talk down to teenagers..., bwahaha ;)

Side: Yes

I find it funny how teens think they are so smart ;)

Side: Yes

There's a lot to be said for life experience and common sense. Sometimes, book sense makes no sense. Especially since any idiot can write a book and publish it. ;)

Side: Yes

As people get older they become well rounded. No only in physical form, but also in knowledge gained ;)

Side: Yes

If teens are so smart, how come you don't see many of them as CEO's or brain surgeons or as rocket scientists ;)

Side: Yes
SwastikaNein(1) Disputed
1 point

It is due to the fact that teens are probably still studying to get qualifications of such. We are discussing about intelligence not knowledge. Intelligence is how one gets knowledge quickly. Therefore, you cannot assume that younger groups are less intelligent than us as they may be able to gain more knowledge within the same amount of time as we do. Although it is seen that older age groups are more accomplished, it just does not correlate with intelligence but instead knowledge.

So what you stated is that accomplishment = knowledge. Yes true but accomplishment does not equal to intelligence.

Side: No

Old age and treachery will overcome youth and skill every time ;)

Side: No

I find that I am never impressed by anyone with their pants pulled down bellow their ass ;)

Side: Yes
6 points

I think of intelligence as the proficiency with which we handle information stored in our memory. Older people may have more information but that doesn't necessarily mean they are using it well.

Side: No
4 points

No. Not at all. I know teens who are much more intelligent than adults I know. It all depends on the person.

For example, Apollo is one of the most intelligent debaters on this site, but he's only fifteen, I believe. I also know some adults who act like absolute children.

I AM more impressed by someone who is younger and wiser though. Only because it makes me wonder what kind of life they've had to have the maturity they do.

I am less impressed by an adult being immature than a child as well. You'd think an adult would have enough life experience to know how to behave, and once again it makes me wonder what kind of life they've had to be that way.

Side: No
BenWalters(1513) Disputed
2 points

You're contradicting yourself though. You claim that you're impressed with those who are young and intelligent, and annoyed with those who are old and immature. Surely that's admitting that you feel there's a link between the age and intelligence?

Side: Yes
2 points

You're right. I meant really that I don't judge based on age because there are people like that I suppose. And when someone strays from what's expected I have a reaction. Though it's not just adults who are immature that annoy me, pretty much anyone who is immature annoys me, teenager or adult. The only people who are tolerable when immature are children who truly don't know better.

Thanks for pointing that out.

Side: Yes
4 points

Only so much brain development is concerned. Once into mid-teens people don't get much smarter although they will likely gain experience, knowledge and learn techniques on ow to make best use of their intelligence.

Side: No
3 points

No i actually know 12 year olds who understand the complications and mechanics of love while more than all the adults in my life are just... how you say...dumb??

Side: No
3 points

Only so much brain development is concerned. Once into mid-teens people don't get much smarter although they will likely gain experience, knowledge and learn techniques on ow to make best use of their intelligence.

Side: No
2 points

People of any age can be wise. One example is Apollo on this website.

Side: No
2 points

Age is but a matter of time, therefore if there was no time everyone in the world's age would be the same but our intelligence levels wouldn't be. So, if everyone in the world was whatever age they would be able to adapt intelligence themselves but seen as though the time does exist, people judge intelligence by age.

Side: No
2 points

No, age does not matter when considering intelligence. IQ's, for example, are proof of this. But also the way people look at things are a factor, or emotional intelligence. I believe that no matter what type of intelligence, age does not matter. Now I'm discussing adults and teens or even younger, not babies and infants. I believe this because, through experience, I have seen people do the opposite of what they should have in certain situations. I have seen people older than me, not able to solve a problem or just use their head. Things like "street smarts" are also factors. I do believe that with age comes experience, as of course, someone who has lived longer has lived a longer time, which is saying they have had more experience, or time, living. And this means they've had more time to learn facts or figures, but honestly, some kids have more maturity than many adults, and so it doesn't really matter.

Side: No

In my opinion, age does not matter with intelligence. In fact, plenty of people become more wise with age.

Side: No

Only brute force matters. If you're really strong, it doesn't matter how dumb your argument is, you can beat it into people ;)

Side: No