Debate Info

yes, it does no, it's fiction
Debate Score:8
Total Votes:8
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 yes, it does (4)
 no, it's fiction (2)

Debate Creator

judgemaster(265) pic

Does luck really exist?

yes, it does

Side Score: 4

no, it's fiction

Side Score: 4

How do you define luck? Simply good things happening to you or possession of some mystical thing that causes good things to happen to you? The former defenitely exists because good, bad, etc will always happen. Things go our way sometimes, sometimes they don't.

Side: yes, it does
judgemaster(265) Disputed
2 points

But cannot everything be traced back to some logical action which results in our favor or disadvantage?

Side: no, it's fiction
zephyr20x6(2386) Disputed
1 point

Exactly. Things outside of my control benefit me by chance, or does the opposite by chance. Luck by chance exists, but not by as any power or mystical thing. Thanks for helping me find the better means to express myself, I don't mean that sarcastically or provokingly, you genuinely pointed out with what I was talking about with my first def of luck.

Side: yes, it does

No one can tell anyone that it wasn't his lucky rabbit's foot that made him win the jackpot on a slot machine. Luck is in the mind of the beholder.

Side: yes, it does
No arguments found. Add one!