CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
5
Fate Free Will
Debate Score:9
Arguments:8
Total Votes:9
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Fate (4)
 
 Free Will (4)

Debate Creator

DarthVader(36) pic



Fate or Free Will

"Do you believe in fate, mr. Thompson?"

Remember that famous line from that blockbuster movie, The Matrix. Well, watching that movie made me think. What if fate controls our actions. What if we were not in control of our own life. What if, even, things like sickness were destined to happen to us and there was no way to avoid it. What if...

 

 

 

Fate

Side Score: 4
VS.

Free Will

Side Score: 5

I totally believe in fate and not free will. I mean, look at teens. They are like totally controlled by their hormones ;)

Side: fate
1 point

Free will assumes unfettered choice. I doubt such a thing exists. Our choices are limited by the actions of others. To the extent that our choices are limited by the actions of others, free will is curtailed.

Side: fate

No one asks to be born, therefore, there is no such thing as free will.

Side: Fate
2 points

If it was not free will, Columbus would have just lazed around and depended on fate for him to discover America. But, he did not and so he achieved it by his free will.

Side: free will
Peekaboo(704) Disputed
1 point

You're making this argument upon the assumption that we do have free will, thus begging the question.

If our lives are driven by fate, then it was fate that led Columbus to discover the Americas.

If our lives are driven by free will, then Columbus freely chose to set sail, leading him to discover the Americas.

If our lives are driven by free will, but Columbus erroneously believed that fate determined his life, he might have done as you suggested, lazing around and waiting for fate to get him to do whatever he needed to do.

Side: fate

I absolutely don't believe in fate. Not because I don't want to, but simply because I don't think some controlling power has our lives planned out. I make choices; I'm not destined to make those choices.

Side: free will

Free will is more probable because it is hard to believe that an omnipotent entity created an divine plan for some 100 billion people who inhabited the Earth at one thing and 6.5 billion today. Fate really has no argument. With 100 billion plans, that is a lot of planning.

Side: free will
1 point

the argument about teens is nothing to do with fate, teens are coverened by there actions and what their parents allow them to do. That is not fate that is free will, to say that we are controlled makes our life worthless, fate is nothing but a word used by people to hide themselves FROM life!

Side: free will