CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
2
Yes. No.
Debate Score:5
Arguments:5
Total Votes:5
Ended:10/24/23
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes. (3)
 
 No. (2)

Debate Creator

Sciencerules(592) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Flu vaccine mandates.

Should flu vaccine mandates exist? For example should schools require students to have their flu vaccine both private and public? Business require their employees for example a small local business and a big business like Walmart? How about state level mandates?

Yes.

Side Score: 3
Winning Side!
VS.

No.

Side Score: 2

Absolutely, I think it is shameful that we allow such waste in the name of excess freedom and liberty to occur.

"flu vaccination during the 2018–2019 flu season prevented 3.1 million illnesses, 1.6 million medical visits, 43,000 hospitalizations and 2,800 deaths associated with flu. " CDC

https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden-averted/2018-2019.htm

This is not even taking into account economic costs. All the doctors visits, hospital visits, lost days of school and work. Let alone the immune compromised.

By passively allowing the flu to go through unchecked we are complicit in ableism. Forcing people who are immune compromised to become hermits or risk hospitalization or dying.

Yes, schools both private and public should have vaccine mandates. As well as businesses and state level mandates. For example, you don't want your postal clerk to be unvaccinated.

We need to pass laws closing loopholes in vaccine exemptions allowing medical exemptions only. Even those medical exemptions should be a hassle to get.

Supporting Evidence: Flu cost 10.4 billion just is medical costs. (www.cnbc.com)
Side: Yes.
NigerInnis(120) Disputed
1 point

So Hitler should have been able to mandate the Jews be injected with whatever he said. Pull your head out of your god damned ass dipshit. The left was saying the vaccine was dangerous and rushed and then flipped positions one day. Do you psychologically have the ability to actually comprehend a god damned thing I just said?

Side: No.
1 point

Equating a vaccine with the worst regimes is a very common technique. For example anti-vaxxers sometimes use the yellow star of David as do smokers. A despicable tactic.

"German Jews protest use of yellow Star of David by pro-smokers"

Supporting Evidence: Pro smokers yellow Star of David. (www.jpost.com)
Side: Yes.
1 point

Flu vaccine mandates

No they shouldn't exist. How many times have you seen a commercial saying something like "have you takenNapromonazingra and experienced deadly side effects? Call the law offices of Simon and Simon. You may be owed a large cash settlement." Those drugs were tested. Those drugs were approved. Those drugs gave people cancer, blindness, and infertility. And some leaders throughout history were genocidal maniacs. Imagine being forced to take something at the command of Hitler while being a Jew. If you ever dare to say a drug of any kind should be mandated, and then turn around and say "my body my choice", go directly to Hell, and then go f-ck yourself.

Side: No.
1 point

Here's an idea if you are so worried about being forced to take a flu vaccine, why not help convince people of their own free will? If people took the vaccine willingly in high enough numbers herd immunity could be achieved.

I am not sure about the law offices of Simon's commercial. With any drug there is always a risk. An ironic example is homeopathy is laxly regulated and there are containments that cause some of those symptoms.

Side: Yes.