CreateDebate


Debate Info

1
3
Temperaments Myers-Briggs
Debate Score:4
Arguments:4
Total Votes:4
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Temperaments (1)
 
 Myers-Briggs (3)

Debate Creator

HarryPits(301) pic



Four Temperaments or Myers-Briggs? Which do you prefer?

If you don't know what temperaments are, look them up.  They're elemental personalities.

Temperaments

Side Score: 1
VS.

Myers-Briggs

Side Score: 3
1 point

While I know more people are familiar with Myers-Briggs, I personally find it more complicated than colourful, as I can't paint a picture out of it like I can with temperaments. Temperaments are more simple, so I find it easier to think of them more generally and not think all people of a temperament are the same.

Side: Temperaments

Myers-Briggs has the same temperaments, and with 16 types instead of 4, it describes people better.

Side: Myers-Briggs

Because it's much more useful.

The temperaments are obsolete because there are concepts in the MBTI that cover those four temperaments as well.

I can't apply the information given only from the four temperaments in any objective way.

Yes....and very obsolete indeed. You really can't squeeze that much into only 4 temperaments and expect to be even 50% correct.

Side: Myers-Briggs
1 point

Myers-Briggs personalities are more accurate, because it discusses more peoples personalities in a more detailed way. Its almost like thee four temperaments, but in a more definite way.

Side: Myers-Briggs