CreateDebate


Debate Info

20
27
Sniff sniff Yep, they're back
Debate Score:47
Arguments:62
Total Votes:52
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Sniff sniff (15)
 
 Yep, they're back (24)

Debate Creator

brontoraptor(28599) pic



German Government Tells Jews: Don't Look Like Jews

German Government Tells Jews: Don't Look Like Jews


According to Germany’s government commissioner on anti-Semitism, Jews in his country should stop wearing kippahs (skullcaps) in public lest they incur the wrath of anti-Semites.

https://www.dailywire.com/news/47699/german-government-tells-jews-dont-look-jews-hank-berrien?utm_source=facebook&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=benshapiro

Sniff sniff

Side Score: 20
VS.

Yep, they're back

Side Score: 27
2 points

Nom will be in ecstasy at this news .....................

Side: Sniff sniff
1 point

I wonder if he has a swastika crescent moon tattoo.

Side: Yep, they're back
1 point

Its pretty likely , I bet he runs breathlessly up the stairs of his mums basement and announces “ mum today I’m gonna be a Muslim “ to which his long suffering mum says “ yes dear , now eat up your spaghetti hoops before we go see your therapist “ .......

Side: Yep, they're back

Looks like the tolerant, leftist, National Socialists are back.

Side: Sniff sniff
1 point

Looks like the tolerant, leftist, National Socialists are back.

Do you literally EVER stop turning reality upside down you lying Nazi prick? You're disgusting. No wonder your ex-wife and kids can't stand the sight of you. Nobody wants to live with (or even know) somebody who won't stop telling lies.

The National Socialist German Workers' Party, commonly referred to in English as the Nazi Party,[5] was a far-right political party in Germany that was active between 1920 and 1945

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NaziParty

Carry on trying to convince people the Nazis were on the left you deranged, delusional fucking idiot.

Side: Yep, they're back
1 point

Still can't rebuttal that you support Hitler's positions, eh Nom?

Side: Sniff sniff
1 point

According to Germany’s government commissioner on anti-Semitism, Jews in his country should stop wearing kippahs (skullcaps) in public lest they incur the wrath of anti-Semites.

Hello bront:

I don't facebook, so I can't tell if it's good ADVICE, or an antisemitic DEMAND.. I'm not too fond of Germans in any case, but there's no question that antisemitism is on the rise worldwide..

Looks like we're in for yet another round.. It's ok...We've been hated for 6,000 fucking years and we're still around and going strong.. Fuck those Jew hating pieces of shit..

excon, Jewish Warrior

Side: Sniff sniff
1 point

I don't facebook

From the piece-

Quoted in an interview published on Saturday by the Funke regional press group, Felix Klein, whose job was created in 2018, stated, “I cannot advise Jews to wear the kippah everywhere, all the time, in Germany.” Klein posited that “the lifting of inhibitions and the uncouthness which is on the rise in society” had contributed to the soaring rise in anti-Semitism, commenting, “The internet and social media have largely contributed to this, but so have constant attacks against our culture of remembrance.” Klein added he had “changed his mind compared to previously.”

The Guardian notes, “Antisemitic hate crimes rose by 20% in Germany last year, according to interior ministry data, which blamed nine out of ten cases on the extreme right. There were 62 violent antisemitic attacks, compared to 37 in 2017. “

Israeli President Reuven Rivlin responded on Sunday, saying that he was "shocked" by Klein’s recommendation, continuing, “Fears about the security of German Jews are a capitulation to anti-Semitism and an admittance that, again, Jews are not safe on German soil. We will never submit, will never lower our gaze and will never react to anti-Semitism with defeatism — and expect and demand our allies act in the same way.”

Richard Grenell, U.S. ambassador to Germany, added on Twitter, “The opposite is true. Wear your kippa. Wear your friend’s kippa. Borrow a kippa and wear it for our Jewish neighbors. Educate people that we are a diverse society.”

In April 2018, Klein noted that some of the rising anti-Semitism in Germany came from immigrants from the Middle East. He asserted:

Side: Yep, they're back
1 point

Continued-

There are several developments. One, of course, is the great influx of refugees and people who came to Germany that were raised and educated in countries that are still in the state of war with Israel, or that have been brought up with certain perceptions of Jews in Israel that are totally unacceptable to a German society. So we’re facing an integration problem. Because, of course, these people do not leave that image of Jews in Israel when they enter Germany … We have Palestinians in Germany that have lived here for a long time, and we see that crimes and incidents are also committed at a high percentage by people from that group.

Klein quickly added, “I would not say that generally Arabs or Muslims are anti-Semitic. That’s not true. You can’t generalize it. But of course there’s a certain image of Jews that is not acceptable.”

Asked which was more pervasive, anti-Semitism from Muslim immigrants or from the far-Right, Klein answered:

Side: Yep, they're back
1 point

Continued-

I wouldn’t like to prioritize the kind of anti-Semitism to combat first. It is generally unacceptable. But what I think is particularly difficult, and absolutely unacceptable, is the way the extreme right is threatening and insulting Jews, also with historical prejudices and arguments. That’s particularly insulting to them. Whereas I think more aggression and physical attacks maybe generally fall more into the category of anti-Semitic attacks that are motivated by Muslims.

The Jerusalem Post noted:

According to the interior ministry, right-wing extremists committed 90% of the 1,800 incidents in 2018. The real number of Islamic-animated antisemitic attacks in Germany is not well documented due to authorities characterizing Islamic antisemitism as right-wing antisemitism.

Side: Yep, they're back
excon(18261) Clarified
1 point

Borrow a kippa and wear it for our Jewish neighbors. Educate people that we are a diverse society.

Hello again, bront:

Dude! Hatred from the left, or hatred from the right - I don't notice a difference.. We've been through it all before.. BOTH right wingers and left can buy zyklon gas..

You're NOT suggesting, are you, that the fucking right wing Nazis that murdered Heather Heyer in Charlottesville, were "very fine people"???

excon

Side: Sniff sniff
1 point

Looks like we're in for yet another round.. It's ok...We've been hated for 6,000 fucking years and we're still around and going strong.. Fuck those Jew hating pieces of shit..

How about we remember those that defeated them the first time

Happy Memorial Day

Side: Yep, they're back
1 point

It's ok...We've been hated for 6,000 fucking years and we're still around and going strong

You're not Jewish you hopelessly dishonest bastard. What you are is a parasite looking for sympathy by pretending to belong to a historically persecuted religious group which you do not belong to at all.

Why you and Bronto don't vote for the same party is a complete enigma to me. You are both nasty, delusional, lying pieces of shit with no concern for facts.

Side: Yep, they're back
2 points

Oh wow, have they heard of religious liberty, and free speech? If they can ban Jewish clothing, why not the burqa?

Side: Yep, they're back

According to Germany’s government commissioner on anti-Semitism, Jews in his country should stop wearing kippahs (skullcaps) in public lest they incur the wrath of anti-Semites.

So hold on. Shapiro wants Jews to get beaten up by the German far right to ostensibly win support for the American far right? I don't get how that works. Should the German commissioner for anti-Semitism be giving out tips on how to get beaten up, or should he be giving out tips on how not to get beaten up?

Side: Yep, they're back
1 point

So hold on. Shapiro wants Jews to get beaten up by the German far right

Except that Germany's Government Commisioner, who made the request to stop looking Jewish, is a leftist.

Side: Sniff sniff
1 point

Should the German commissioner for anti-Semitism be giving out tips on how to get beaten up, or should he be giving out tips on how not to get beaten up?

Germany's left wing government should have not imported millions of Islamic antisemites, which is what is mainly causing the issue.

Side: Sniff sniff
seanB(950) Disputed
1 point

Jesus Christ, context.

Felix Klein's actual words were "I cannot advise Jews to wear the Kippah everywhere in Germany, as the lifting of inhibitions, and the uncouthness which is on the rise in society has contributed to a worrying increase in anti-semitism".

He also urged as many people as will do so in Germany, to show solidarity with Jews and wear the Kippah in support of them tomorrow in a protest en-masse.

This wasn't the German government telling Jews "you can't practice your faith", it was the German Minister for Anti-Semitism sympathizing with German Jews who unfortunately are facing some level of increased anti-Semitism from right-wing populists and nationalists among the German public (the same treatment many Muslims are getting from white supremacists, and paradoxically, the same treatment some hardline Muslims are giving to Jews). It is also the German Minister showing his empathy and encouraging many Germans to show solidarity with Jews by joining in their customs in public.

Very different to the government telling Jews they can't show their faith.

Side: Yep, they're back
1 point

How and why this apparent anti-semitism in Germany, and indeed many other European countries materialized is the mystery of the century.

Some mischievous agitators propound the theory that the reason could be the importation of millions of Muslim migrants into Germany and those other European nations with liberal progressive administrations.

I say, absolutely not. Such an outlandish suggestion is tantamount to insinuating that Islam is not a peaceful faith of religious and political tolerance and some Muslims may engage in deadly violence against anyone who does not follow the teachings of Mohamed, especially Jews.

I'm certain the bewildered German authorities and their social-scientist advisers would be greatly relieved if someone could solve this puzzling phenomenon for them.

Side: Yep, they're back