CreateDebate


Debate Info

6
24
Liberty Lock me up & close my business
Debate Score:30
Arguments:12
Total Votes:34
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Liberty (6)
 
 Lock me up & close my business (10)

Debate Creator

PotatoChip(70) pic



Give me liberty or give me death?

Liberty

Side Score: 6
VS.

Lock me up & close my business

Side Score: 24
No arguments found. Add one!
5 points

You are at perfect liberty to expose yourself to a deadly contagion. You are NOT at liberty to expose others to it.

You have the right to risk your life doing dangerous stunts. So long as it doesn't affect others.

There's a common theme there.

Side: Lock me up & close my business
ModerateJew(53) Disputed
0 points

You are at perfect liberty to expose yourself to a deadly contagion. You are NOT at liberty to expose others to it.

That's bizarre. Democrats take the opposite position on knowingly infecting someone with AIDS, which is far more deadly.

New California Law Reduces Penalty for Knowingly Exposing Someone to HIV

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna809416

Side: Liberty
3 points

Which you already know was done to make it "the same punishment as knowingly exposing someone to other communicable diseases" (from your own link)

But don't let the facts get in the way of innuendo.

Side: Lock me up & close my business
3 points

These are tough times for stupid little spoiled rotten narcissistic extroverted psychopaths with the dreaded red hat disease. Poor babies

Side: Lock me up & close my business
2 points

Give me liberty or give me death?

Hello Pat:

Dude! You DON'T have the liberty to go around infecting people with a killer virus.. Learn yourself some law, Dude!!!

excon

Side: Lock me up & close my business
3 points

Give me liberty or give me death?

Hello again P:

Let's delve a little deeper into your so called liberty, shall we???

If you have KNOWLEDGE that the virus can be passed by ASYMPTOMATIC people, and YOU, personally infect someone who later dies, you can be charged with MANSLAUGHTER..

That's some freedom, huh?

excon

Side: Lock me up & close my business
ModerateJew(53) Disputed
1 point

If you have KNOWLEDGE that the virus can be passed by ASYMPTOMATIC people, and YOU, personally infect someone who later dies, you can be charged with MANSLAUGHTER..

Yet you have no problem with this.

New California Law Reduces Penalty for Knowingly Exposing Someone to HIV

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna809416

Side: Liberty
1 point

"A nation that holds its freedoms above its principles soon loses BOTH." D. D. Eisenhower

I hope if I only have one principle left, it's that I respect the wishes of our first responders, nurses, EMTs, etc., that WE would take the precautions THEY recommend .... so that THEY can live to enjoy THEIR "freedoms".

Think about it, those of you who feel wearing a mask, and staying socially distant, "infringes on YOUR freedoms". Those mentioned above, if they survive, will be needing a bit of "free" time! We ALL should be doing our best to make that SOONER, rather than later .... or prevent it from being permanent!

About 39% of Americans need to become more "principled", IMO!

Side: Lock me up & close my business