CreateDebate


Debate Info

43
10
Harry Potter Twilight
Debate Score:53
Arguments:34
Total Votes:64
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Harry Potter (23)
 
 Twilight (8)

Debate Creator

Brainsikk13(80) pic



Harry Potter or Twilight and why?

Harry Potter

Side Score: 43
VS.

Twilight

Side Score: 10
4 points

HP has a Mass Murdering Psychopath wizard.

Side: Harry Potter
Cuaroc(8829) Disputed
0 points

But then again Twilight has Sparkly vampires and nothing beats the entertainment value of that.

Side: Twilight

Harry Potter did not base it's entire plot on overused teenage cliches. It was about a boy moving on past a childhood of misfortune and neglect as he slowly devopled into a man of his own with a new family and a greater understanding of what his parents were like.

Side: Harry Potter
4 points

Harry potter is for all ages.

Twilight is for the retarded ages.

Rock on!

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

I just don't like twilight, they fooled me in the 1st one into thinking it was about vampires when it's actually about love.

I hear the latest movie has an epic fight scene and the emo girl is finally a vampire but I feel if i watched it i'd be missing so much from the 1st ones and I am still upset about the lies that were sold to me in the 1st one.

So No Twilight For Me!

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

Harry Potter all the way. Not only are the books written 5000x more better, but the message sent by the Harry Potter series is actually a good one about love and friendship... Not about having the worlds most obnoxious crush and sexual relations with a vampire. Ew.

Side: Harry Potter

Edward can run fast and sparkle. Harry can just cast a spell to open a black hole and destroy everything. Harry also has more spells and tricks than Edward or Jacob or Bella......omg and Bella is like the first girl to have no emotion of pleasure. Not a smile. If she did I know the camera commited suicide by just exploding.

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

edward cullen can kill harry by biting harry potter can kill him by a flick of his wand

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

this debate is a waste of time because everyone knows that harry potter is much better than twilight

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

twilight has no story and i hate bella she's soooo sick she never smiles in the movie too . harry potter is the best book and movie in the universe no one can over take its story or characters.

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

Vampires don't sparkle in Harry Potter... they're a hell of a lot more accurate than the ones in Twilight.

Side: Harry Potter
mithoo19(806) Disputed
1 point

harry potter's vampires are much better than twilight's vampires..

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

I don't hate Twilight. It's not terrible. There are some cheesy, unrealistic aspects to it, but there are also some cute aspects. And, this wasn't written as a cliche, overexposed topic. No one really talked about it until Twilight came out. Twilight is what caused it to become a cliche.

However, Harry Potter has a complex storyline. Twilight is basically a love story. Harry Potter is about a kid who's had a rough life finding his place. He goes on amazing adventures, makes amazing friends, and there are a few love stories. It keeps you on the edge of your seat, very emotionally invested.

I don't have anything against Twilight, but I think Harry Potter has more to it. I also think the acting is better in Harry Potter. Everyone in Twilight is pretty emotionless.

Side: Harry Potter

"Twilight" was boring to me. "Harry Potter" brought back the innocence of childhood back to me.

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

Harry Potter was the most fascinating series i had ever read since WARRIORS. HARRY POTTER TAUGHT ME THAT A MOTHER`S LOVE IS THE STRONGEST FORCE OF ALL! WHILE TWILIGHT JUST TAUGHT THAT YOU CAN`T DO ANYTHING WITHOUT A BOYFRIEND.

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

its fascinating and has vampires and makes it more interesting

Side: Twilight
Berrystar(159) Disputed
3 points

They aren't ' vampires ' Vampires die in the light.

VAMPIRES :

Dracula,

Let me in,

HELL, EVEN SCARY GODMOTHER was more accurate.

Fascinating? If you like cilched romance, teen, and Valentino's fish taco themes.

Interesting? These are interesting.

- Warrior Cats

- Harry Potter

- Halloween

- Happy Tree Friends

- Pudding

- Airman

- Profiles of the Presidents

Hell, even a WORM is more interesting than Twilight.......

Harry potter :

ORIGINAL

EPIC

REAL WEREWOLVES

WELL-WRITTEN

NOT A FAIL TEEN STORY.....

NOT FISH TACOS.....

Etc.

Side: Harry Potter
Cuaroc(8829) Disputed
1 point

REAL WEREWOLVES

Actually twilight has the more realistic werewolves.

Side: Harry Potter
-1 points

Twilight. Honestly, there is not much to debate about. Unless you are a hardcore fangirl/fanboy. Which I am not. However, I much prefer twilight. I have never gotten into Harry Potter. The first movie was good, but after that I feel that they slowly declined. The story was worn out, didn't keep my interest. But I also know that many could say the same exact thing for Twilight. It has more to do with your taste in movies than actual facts. Twilight is simply just more of my kind of movie. It involves the modern day representation of vampires, and it is a love story. What is there not to love? Especially if you are a girl. However, I fully respect those who favor Harry Potter. Its just a matter of the difference in personal preferences.

Side: Twilight
JadynDonovan(244) Clarified
1 point

HOWEVER, I will say that Harry Potter is better as far as originality goes. Because as you guys said, Twilight is based on a 'teen cliche' But then again, I am a teenager. So is it so wrong that I prefer Twilight?

Side: Harry Potter
holly2d(52) Disputed
1 point

Have you READ the BOOKS? Movies are just basically rip-offs of books. If you haven't read the books, your argument is invalid.

Side: Harry Potter
-1 points

The harry potter books have a great plot, but made for younger children who dream about the easter bunny and magical horsies with human heads! Twilight is a better writen book series made for mature children who like hot guys.

Side: Twilight
toxic_007 Disputed
2 points

Harry potter is published by Scholastic because it helps develop the brain for all ages.

Twilight is for lonely girls who are on their period.

Side: Harry Potter
mithoo19(806) Disputed
2 points

harry potter is a book for all ages but not like twilight which is only for teens

Side: Harry Potter