CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:20
Arguments:11
Total Votes:21
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 How AFRICAN are AFRICAN AMERICANS. (11)

Debate Creator

TopShottah(41) pic



How AFRICAN are AFRICAN AMERICANS.

I hate political correctness. I think black people tend to be at the forefront of PC in America. Especially with this African American title.

How African are these 'African' Americans? Do they know how to speak an African language? Do they follow an African religion? Do they dress African? Does their culture/traditions resemble their counterparts in Africa or their African Ancestor's?

To me this does not constitute African American. Only Black Americans. I'm fighting political correctness with political correctness.

:D

Add New Argument
2 points

Not Very.

Most of them don't even know what part of Africa they're from.

How insulting is that?

Side: not very
2 points

I hate political correctness. I think black people tend to be at the forefront of PC in America. Especially with this African American title.

What is PC about African American?

How African are these 'African' Americans?

Very.

Do they know how to speak an African language?

English is an African language. For instance, it's the official language of Nigeria (among other places). So is French, Dutch, Arabic and innumerable other languages and dialects in other parts of Africa.

Do they follow an African religion?

What is an African religion?

Do they dress African?

What does this mean? Do you suppose that Africans all wear the same clothes? Do you think they all live in huts and walk around naked, too?

Does their culture/traditions resemble their counterparts in Africa or their African Ancestor's?

Yes.

To me this does not constitute African American.

Well, you seem to be basing your understanding of Africanness (and contingently "African American") on a host of stereotypes and generalizations that does a grave injustice to the continent and those members of the diaspora.

Only Black Americans.

Why is "black" less politically correct than African American?

I'm fighting political correctness with political correctness.

With a liberal sprinkling of abject ignorance.

Side: More than you apparently think and know
TopShottah(41) Disputed
3 points

Very. - Explain.

English is an African language.- Bwahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaaaa!!!

What is an African religion? - This is the only questionable question. I am referring to traditional african beliefs. That is not to say that you cannot be african without being christian - it's just something to be pointed out. Other ethnicities follow their traditional religions such as chinese, indian, italian, jewish and more.

What does this mean? Do you suppose that Africans all wear the same clothes? Do you think they all live in huts and walk around naked, too? - They differ depending on the part of Africa their ancestors were from. I don't think you know what traditional african clothing looks like.

Yes. - Bwahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaaaaaa!!

I'm sorry. I don't know where you're from but you look black (not african american) from your picture. Do you know anything about your ancestors/african's cultures and traditions?

You're American. That is what you have become. Apart from your DNA there is nothing that links you to your ancestors.

Side: More than you apparently think and know
2 points

In my opion there is no such thing as a "African American"

Its idiotic!

Your either African or your American.

Just as lame as "Asian American" "European American" "Russian American"

I don't go around calling myself "European American"

Politicly correct my ass.

Also nigroes in America have this stupid/wierd "Black Attitude" crap where it's a necessity to act a certain way.

My cousin Jordan got a girl from Africa into the US through an arranged marriage since thats the only way she could get here.

She has the most wonderful personnality ever!

I went to school with a girl from Nigeria and she had a good attitude to but now that she has been living in the slums she has this "Black Attitude" and she talks way differently.

Blacks in America in NO way act like the real African people.

Side: not very
brycer2012(1002) Disputed
2 points

My cousin Jordan got a girl from Africa into the US through an arranged marriage since thats the only way she could get here.

She has the most wonderful personnality ever!

I went to school with a girl from Nigeria and she had a good attitude to but now that she has been living in the slums she has this "Black Attitude" and she talks way differently.

Wow! you've met two whole African people! If you are going to compare African Americans to Africans, try to find something that is actually proportionately correct. You can't compare two people to an entire countries worth of people that you, stereotypically, believe is one way.

Side: not very
Sulith(508) Disputed
1 point

that is actually proportionately correct.

This IS correct this is my own evidence you idiot.

I have also lived in the ghetto part of California and those people were animals.

Side: not very

I think that a great man once said, "African is as African does." I have no idea what that means but it sounds cool. Wait..., that sounds familiar :)

Side: not very
2 points

They're no more African than most of the general public.

There's nothing that defines them culturally, lilnguistically, religiously and mentally from other Americans.

I don't have a problem with the term African American if it was used as equally as irish american, italian american, polish american and all the other 'americans'. But it's not. That is why I think it is just stupid. It's all for black people to pat themselves on the back because they have a term for themselves.

Side: not very

It is a politically correct insult. They are Americans. Call them blacks, negroes, just so long as it is accurate.

Side: not very

Their ancestry may have been from Africa, but I wouldn't call them an 'African' unless they were born in Africa. I just call them Negroid, just as I call whites 'Caucasoid' and orientals 'Mongoloids'.

Side: not very