Debate Info

Debate Score:7
Total Votes:7
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph

Debate Creator

Jody(1785) pic

How do American courts reach these two totally different conclusions?

How can it be wrong for the Christian baker to refuse to bake a cake on religious principles yet  get fined 150,000 dollars ......yet Muslim truck drivers get 250,000 dollars compensation for refusing to transport beer because it violated their religious principles seems very unfair .....

Jury Awards $240,000 to Muslim Truck Drivers In EEOC Religious Discrimination Suit

Star Transport Fired Truckers for Refusing to Transport Alcohol, Federal Agency Charged

CHICAGO - A federal jury in Peoria, Ill., has awarded $240,000 to two Somalian-American Muslims who were fired from their jobs as truck drivers at Star Transport, an over-the-road trucking company, when they refused to transport alcohol because it violated their religious beliefs, according to the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), which brought the case. The trial started on Oct. 19, and the jury returned its verdict the next day after 45 minutes of deliberation.

An Oregon couple who closed their bakery after being fined $135,000 for refusing to bake a cake for a same-sex wedding is asking the Supreme Court to intervene in their case. 

Add New Argument
2 points

The biased Judiciary in most western countries make these outrageous judgments because they go unchallenged.

Whilst their prejudiced judgments may go unchallenged they do not go unnoticed and we can see across Europe for instance that the rumblings of civil discontent is well under way in such countries as Italy and France where the silent majority are becoming not so silent and have taken to the streets to voice their discontent at the loaded scales of injustice.

The politicians, whom we all voted into power, imported Bongos and Muslim terrorists en mass and are now trying to keep their belligerent guests from wrecking their respective countries by continually trying to appease them with concessions and showing favoritism at the expense of the indigenous populations.

There are three kinds of filth in this escalating crisis.

The imported filth, the political filth, and the electorate filth voted the political filth into power.

As the imported filth propagate and assert their culture and laws on the naive civilians who were duped into believing that swamping their countries with low lives is good for the country as it introduces DIVERSITY into their societies.

As 100s of people lie dead and permanently maimed from terrorist activity and females are being raped on an industrial scale along with daily helpings of violent crime which have reached crisis levels throughout Europe, the dim witted liberal sector of the electorate are asking themselves;- WHAT PRICE DIVERSITY?

1 point

It’s remarkable really how P C the world is going , this self same dance went on after the cartoon of Muhammad drove Muslims into a frenzy , all across the U S and Europe images of the cartoon were pixallated on the news channels so as not to cause offence to Muslims . The late great Christopher Hitchens was called an Islamphobe and screeched down by the mob for saying “ The term Islamaphobe is used by P C bullies to shut down rational discourse”

The dance still goes on as P C friendly horeshit sweeps the world.

last year my wife’s handbag was swiped by a Roma gypsy I wasn’t with her at the time but she rang me distressed and told me what happened and who did it , I arrived on the scene and a cop said to me “ we are looking into it” I said “ well you know it’s a Roma gypsy who took the bag “ he said “ you cannot say that its racist “ I said “ it’s not it’s the truth “ an older cop told him go for a walk and cool down he then told me “ they are learning all this P C bullshit at the police academy now it’s all European over the top P C horseshit”

Amarel(5551) Clarified
1 point

It’s not quite that bad here (your Purse snatching account). If you say something to a cop that is racist, they won’t tell you you can’t say it. Also, I bet they take note of suspect description, if perhaps in less racist terms.

Although, whenever I see a video on social media where some dispatcher describes some suspect as “black male wearing...” someone in the comments always suggests the cops are racist for the dispatcher describing the suspect.

1 point

Because American courts are not filled with objective arbitrators but with left wing activists, many appointed by Obama. It's why they are obstructing Trump's appointments at all costs. They like governing from the bench more than governing from the government.

1 point

Does the law differ from state to state on these matters?

Pedestrian(152) Disputed
1 point

In fact the American courts are outlandishly right wing and capitalist fascists.

Corps. are like people ?

Property (wealth) is free speech ?

You must sign away your right to sue and go to arbitration over a class action ?

Taxpayers must fund price supports for the capitalist, direct cash subsidies for the rich and pay billion$ each year for ethanol [it] does not want or need ?

Taxpayers much pay for insurance for bankers, farmers, pension thieves and overseas investors [sic] ?

1 point

I really don't know. Honestly there are times I wonder what the hell happened to have two separate instances with different results in the court systems. If you have a job, do it. If it goes against your personal belief, get a new job. That's just my opinion though.