CreateDebate


Debate Info

8
5
It isn't. Here is how.
Debate Score:13
Arguments:9
Total Votes:13
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 It isn't. (6)
 
 Here is how. (3)

Debate Creator

SitaraForJesus(3819) pic



How is it antisemitic to criticize the injustices in the Old Testament?

So I was told that I am antisemitic for criticizing the injustices in the Old Testmaent. Way to invoke Godwin's law.

It isn't.

Side Score: 8
VS.

Here is how.

Side Score: 5

It's not, but ever since WWII even hinting at the fact that Jews share many of the same prejudices as Christians you'll be labeled as an anti-semitic neo-nazi.

Side: It isn't.

Exactly. It's like if you criticize Israel, Judaism, the Old Testament and such, you get called an antichrist commie faggot who hates Jews. SMH.

Side: It isn't.

The people who would call you antisemitic for voicing legitimate concerns re: the old testament have the exact same mentality as those who would call you racist for expressing legitimate concerns re: President Obama.

Rather than attempt to address your points or engage in any kind of meaningful discourse, they throw the most socially stigmatized word (that could be considered REMOTELY applicable) they can think of at you, hoping for the illusion of a moral victory.

Pretty pathetic, really.

Side: It isn't.

Exactly. The rampant use of Godwin's Law and other fallacies is so annoying.

Side: It isn't.
Saurbaby09(50) Disputed
1 point

nononononononononononononononononononononono!

You is ams a nazi! Go backs to da Germanies you skins heads!

Side: Here is how.

There is a difference between disdaining Jewish people in general and disagreeing with what there people wrote about or did thousands of years ago.

Side: It isn't.

Thank you. That is what I think. .

Side: It isn't.

The Bible is the word of god. You can't say or do anything against god because he is (metaphorically) the big kahuna of hona huna, the 8 inch among 4 inches, the President among congressmen, the beer bottle among water bottles, the... (you know where I'm going with this)

Side: Here is how.

LOL, good point. .

Side: Here is how.