CreateDebate


Debate Info

0
7
solipcism Externalism
Debate Score:7
Arguments:6
Total Votes:7
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Externalism (6)

Debate Creator

FactMachine(430) pic



I am the Supreme and Ultimate Reality

I don't know for sure that this universe is real or that any being other than me is sentient, I can only truly know one thing, that I EXIST BECAUSE I AM SENTIENT, AND SINCE I AM SELF AWARE I MUST EXIST, AND EVERYTHING OTHER THAN ME COULD VERY WELL BE A MANIFESTATION PULLED OUT OF THE ASS OF MY SUBCONSCIOUS BRAIN, I COULD BE A BOLTZMANN BRAIN IMAGINING ALL OF YOU, AS FAR AS I AM CONCERNED I AM THE SUPREME AND ULTIMATE REALITY AND WHETHER OR NOT YOU ACKNOWLEDGE IT DOESNT MATTER BECAUSE YOU ONLY EXIST IN MY  IMAGINATION

solipcism

Side Score: 0
VS.

Externalism

Side Score: 7
No arguments found. Add one!
2 points

As soon as we allow that our imagination indicates real possibility, we allow a parallel universe of possibllities that are evident to imagination alone, and whose real existence does not follow from actual external sensation.

Side: Externalism
1 point

I don't know why, because this observation appears relatively simple and obvious, but it feels like it has the depth of an ocean.

Side: Externalism
1 point

Thank you Winston , sometimes things just seem so obvious

Side: Externalism
1 point

CONGRATULATIONS! You sound like conservative Presidential material.(Did you forget the word "Show" at the end of your title??)

Side: Externalism
1 point

It's as valid as a very similar argument I recall hearing somewhere. In fact, it's more valid.

Side: Externalism
1 point

Subconscious is by definition not a type of self awareness. Does your sub-conscious exist? Your self awareness is surprised at times, right? Incorrect at times, right? You must have a subconscious then... So if there are things that you are not aware of, how can you be The Supreme and Ultimate Reality? Ignorance has power over you.

You have identified yourself in such a way that you could not be The Supreme and Ultimate Reality.

Side: Externalism