CreateDebate


Debate Info

10
7
I absolutely WOULD I LOVE Nazis
Debate Score:17
Arguments:20
Total Votes:18
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 I absolutely WOULD (10)
 
 I LOVE Nazis (7)

Debate Creator

excon(18261) pic



I'm a Jew. If I was watching a parade of Nazis, I'd ATTACK them too. Would you??

I absolutely WOULD

Side Score: 10
VS.

I LOVE Nazis

Side Score: 7
1 point

I would certainly OPPOSE them. They don't like opposition so that usually leads to an attack whether you intend it or not. A shame, but, letting them have their democratic bully-pulpit without opposition will simply embolden them to carry on. It's one of the worst catch 22's a democracy can face! I don't believe in the violence but if more Germans had stood up to the "Brown Shirts" of Hitler, they may not have taken over that country! I don't want them taking over mine, sooooo if we don't have a President who will stand against them ... even with a Jewish daughter ... who will??

Side: I absolutely WOULD
outlaw60(15368) Clarified
1 point

AL were those dreadful Nazis you oppose rioting in the streets when Obama was POTUS ?

Side: I absolutely WOULD

Probably not. It's why Conservatives stay out of ANTIFA and BLM's way. It'd be a good way to get hurt or killed. When hate mongering leftists demonstrate, we on the right don't round up in mass and "go take em on" like mindless idiots. You aren't going to change their minds. You aren't going to accomplish anything. And if you did and won, they'd gather more ranks and do more hateful crap, right Con?

Side: I absolutely WOULD
1 point

i would definitely go up to them and ask them if they even knew what there were fighting for and if so id probably fight them

Side: I absolutely WOULD
1 point

I don't love Nazis.

But I also believe in Constitutional rights, law and order, and winning the war is more important than winning the battle. Any violence initiatied from the counter protesters has only served to give an excuse to the Nazi idiots who went there to start this whole thing. You did more harm than good.

The difference would be if I saw Nazis directly attacking the innocent and then I had to decide how to help the innocent and deter from othres being attacked. That might actually be the case here, but I don't know that yet from the news reports I've read so far.

Side: I LOVE Nazis
excon(18261) Disputed
1 point

Hello G:

Oh, I don't disagree with you at all.. But, it wouldn't be the thinking me that attacks them.. It would be the visceral me who sees them as the MURDERERS of my family.

excon

Side: I absolutely WOULD
Cartman(18192) Disputed
1 point

There is no part of you that is the "thinking me".

Side: I LOVE Nazis
1 point

You are the child of a reformed Jewish family (i.e. that arent ethnically jewish) but yet you are not practising. How can you consider yourself to be Jewish? You or neither ethnically nor religiously jewish.

Side: I LOVE Nazis
excon(18261) Disputed
1 point

Hello again, A:

I'm a Jew, because in this great country of ours, I'M FREE to choose my religion. WHO the fuck are you to tell me I'm NOT????

If you don't like our freedoms, why don't you leave???

excon

Side: I absolutely WOULD
Atrag(5666) Disputed
1 point

OK I am not giving you a definition now alright...? Can you tell me what a Jew is and how you are one?

Side: I LOVE Nazis
1 point

You would be arrested in Germany if you attacked a certain group of Neo Nazis , Germany’s supreme constitutional court has rejected a proposed ban on a far-right party accused of neo-Nazi links because its members are deemed too ineffective to pose a real threat to democracy.

The Federal Constitutional Court rejected a historic attempt by all of Germany’s 16 states to outlaw the National Democratic Party (NPD), which has been described by intelligence services as racist and anti-Semitic.

In its unanimous judgement, the court agreed that the NPD wants to eliminate existing democratic freedoms in favour of an authoritarian state housing an ethnically defined “national community”.

“Their political concept disregards human dignity and is incompatible with the principle of democracy,” it continued.

npd-germany-far-right-neo-nazi

Supporters of anti-immigration right-wing movement PEGIDA (hold up a banner with the logo of the far-right National Democratic Party (NPD) (Reuters)

“The NPD also works in a well-planned way and with sufficient intensity to achieve its goals against the liberal democratic order.

“However, there is (currently) a lack of concrete evidence showing it is possible for these actions to lead to success.”

READ MORE

Syrian refugees rescue neo-Nazi German politician after car crash

Far-right groups make huge gains in local German elections

Far-right party mocked for poster 'to deport German people first'

The court’s judgement said the NPD had an “essential affinity with national socialism [Nazism]”, including using the phrase Volksgemeinschaft, which has strong anti-Semitic and Nazi associations.

Judges said the party employs the vocabulary, songs and symbolism of the Third Reich, and that some of its supporters display “intimidating and criminal behaviour”.

The ban, which was applied for in 2013, would have been the first of its kind since 1956.

It was the second attempt to prohibit the NPD, which officials say violates the constitution of the state that funds it.

It states: “Parties that, by reason of their aims or the behaviour of their adherents, seek to undermine or abolish the free democratic basic order or to endanger the existence of the Federal Republic of Germany shall be unconstitutional.”

Side: I LOVE Nazis
1 point

Not attacking someone simply because I don't agree with their parade isn't "loving nazi's". In fact I do not love them, I do not agree with them and I think they are despicable. If they are being peaceful it would not justify an attack against them. If they, however, are assaulting someone, either verbally or physically, I would do all I could to defend their victim. As much as I hate the white extremist mindset, they have that right to think as they do up until they act on it by oppressing someone else.

Side: I LOVE Nazis